that all his mss. agree in reading “twenty-five” instead of “thirty” in the latter passage, so
that it would seem that the vulgar text is incorrect.
It is impossible to form an accurate notion of the nature and quality of Eusebius’ refut-
ation. Socrates speaks of it in terms of moderate praise (“which [i.e. the work of Porphyry]
has been ably answered by Eusebius”), and Jerome does the same in his Ep. ad Magnum
(“Alteri [i.e. Porphyry] Methodius, Eusebius, et Apollinaris fortissime responderunt”). At
the same time the fact that Apollinaris and others still thought it necessary to write against
Porphyry would seem to show that Eusebius’ refutation was not entirely satisfactory. In
truth, Jerome (Ep. ad Pammachium et Oceanum, §2, Migne’s ed. Ep. 84) appears to rank
the work of Apollinaris above that of Eusebius, and Philostorgius expressly states that the
former far surpassed the latter (ἐπὶ πολὺ κρατεῖν ἠγωνισμένων ᾽Ευσεβί& 251· κατ᾽ αὐτοῦ).
The date of Eusebius’ work cannot be determined. The fact that he never refers to it, although
he mentions the work of Porphyry a number of times, has been urged by Valesius and others
as proof that he did not write it until after 325 a.d.; but it is quite possible to explain his si-
lence, as Lardner does, by supposing that his work was written in his earlier years, and that
afterward he felt its inferiority and did not care to mention it. It seems, in fact, not unlikely
that he wrote it as early, or even earlier than his work against Hierocles, at any rate before
his attention was occupied with the Arian controversy and questions connected with it.
On the Numerous Progeny of the Ancients (περὶ τῆς τῶν παλαιῶν ἀνδρῶν πολυπαιδίας).
This work is mentioned by Eusebius in his Præp. Evang. VII. 8. 20 (Migne, Opera, III. 525),
but by no one else, unless it be the book to which Basil refers in his De Spir. Sancto, 29, as
Difficulties respecting the Polygamy of the Ancients. The work is no longer extant, but we
can gather from the connection in which it is mentioned in the Præparatio, that it aimed at
accounting for the polygamy of the Patriarchs and reconciling it with the ascetic ideal of
the Christian life which prevailed in the Church of Eusebius’ lifetime. It would therefore
seem to have been written with an apologetic purpose.
Præparatio Evangelica (προπαρασκευὴ εὐαγγελική) and Demonstratio Evangelica
(᾽Ευαγγελικὴ ἀπόδειξις). These two treatises together constitute Eusebius’ greatest apologetic
work. The former is directed against heathen, and aims to show that the Christians are jus-
tified in accepting the sacred books of the Hebrews and in rejecting the religion and philo-
sophy of the Greeks. The latter endeavors to prove from the sacred books of the Hebrews
themselves that the Christians do right in going beyond the Jews, in accepting Jesus as their
Messiah, and in adopting another mode of life. The former is therefore in a way a preparation
for the latter, and the two together constitute a defense of Christianity against all the world,
Jews as well as heathen. In grandeur of conception, in comprehensiveness of treatment, and
in breadth of learning, this apology undoubtedly surpasses all other apologetic works of
antiquity. Lightfoot justly says, “This great apologetic work exhibits the same merits and
defects which we find elsewhere in Eusebius. There is the same greatness of conception
52
Catalogue of his Works.