SECT. XIV.
Concerning that great argument, which Mr. W. urges in various parts of his book of those
being born in the church, who are children of parents that are in covenant.
It is hard to understand distinctly what Mr. W. would be at, concerning this matter, or
what his argument is. He often speaks of parents that are in covenant, as born in covenant,
and so born in the church. For to be in covenant, is the same with him as to be members of
the visible church. (See p. 98. c. 88. d. 89. b. 59. e. 60. a. 136. b.) And he speaks of them as
admitted into the church in their ancestors, and by the profession of their ancestors. (p. 135.
e. 136. a.) Yea, for ought I can see, he holds that they were born members in complete
standing in the visible church, (p. 3.)
And yet he abundantly speaks of their being admitted into the church, and made
members, after they are born, viz. by their baptism. And his words (unless we will suppose
him to speak nonsense) are such as will not allow us to understand him, merely, that baptism
is a sign and public acknowledgment of their having been admitted in their ancestors, in
preceding generations. For he speaks of baptism as the only rite (or way) of admission into
the visible church, applying it to the baptism of children; and as that which makes them
members of the body of Christ. (p. 99. c. d.) And he grants, that it was ordained for the ad-
mission of the party baptized into the visible church. (p. 99. e. p. 100. c.) That baptism is an
admission; and that they were thus before admitted, (p. 100. c.) still speaking of the baptism
of infants, and of admission of members into churches.—But surely these things do not
harmonize with the doctrine of their first receiving being in the church—as a branch receives
being in the tree, and grows in it and from it—or their being born in the covenant, born in
the house of God. And yet these repugnant things are uttered as it were in the same breath
by Mr. W. (p. 99.) And he joins them together in the same line, (p. 46. e.) in these
words,—“Baptism instituted by him, as a rite of admission into his church, and being con-
tinued in covenant with God.”—Certainly, being then admitted into the church, and being
continued in covenant (or in the church) into which they were admitted before, are not the
same thing, nor consistent one with another. If infants are born members in complete
standing, as it seems Mr. W. holds, then their baptism does nothing towards making them
members; nor is there any need of it to make the matter more complete.
Again, (p. 3. b. where he also speaks of infants as members having a complete standing
in the church,) he maintains, that nothing else is requisite in order to communion and
privileges of members in complete standing, but only that they should be capable hereof, and
should desire the same, and should not be under censure, or scandalously ignorant or immoral.
(See also p. 100. c. d. to the same purpose.) Mr. W says this in opposition to my insisting
on something further, viz. making a profession of godliness. And yet he himself insists on
something further, as much as I; which has been observed before. For he abundantly insists
on a personal, explicit profession and open declaration of believing that the gospel is indeed
SECTION XIV. Of being born in covenant.
2012
SECTION XIV. Of being born in covenant.