Introductory Note to the Spurious
Epistles of Ignatius
To
the following introductory
note of the translators nothing need be prefixed, except a grateful
acknowledgment of the value of their labours and of their good judgment
in giving us even these spurious writings for purposes of comparison.
They have thus placed the materials for a complete understanding of the
whole subject, before students who have a mind to subject it to a
thorough and candid examination.
The following is the original
Introductory Notice
:—
We
formerly stated that eight out of the fifteen Epistles bearing the name
of Ignatius are now universally admitted to be spurious. None of them are
quoted or referred to by any ancient writer previous to the sixth
century. The style, moreover, in which they are written, so different
from that of the other Ignatian letters, and allusions which they contain
to heresies and ecclesiastical arrangements of a much later date than
that of their professed author, render it perfectly certain that they are
not the authentic production of the illustrious bishop of Antioch.
We cannot tell when or by whom these Epistles were
fabricated. They have been thought to betray the same hand as the longer
and interpolated form of the seven Epistles which are generally regarded
as genuine. And some have conceived that the writer who gave forth to the
world the Apostolic Constitutions under the name of Clement, was probably
the author of these letters falsely ascribed to Ignatius, as well as of
the longer recension of the seven Epistles which are mentioned by
Eusebius.
It was a considerable time before editors in modern
times began to discriminate between the true and the false in the
writings attributed to Ignatius. The letters first published under his
name were those three which exist only in Latin. These came forth in 1495
at Paris, being appended to a life of Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury.
Some three years later, eleven Epistles, comprising those mentioned by
Eusebius, and four others, were published in Latin, and passed through
four or five editions. In 1536, the whole of the professedly Ignatian
letters were published at Cologne in a Latin version; and this collection
also passed through several editions. It was not till 1557 that the
Ignatian Epistles appeared for the first time in Greek at Dillingen.
After this date many editions came forth, in which the probably genuine
were still mixed up with the certainly spurious, the three Latin letters,
only being rejected as destitute of authority. Vedelius of Geneva first
made the distinction which is now universally accepted, in an edition of
these Epistles which he published in 1623; and he was followed by
Archbishop Usher and others, who entered more fully into that critical
examination of these writings which has been continued down even to our
own day.
The reader will have no difficulty in detecting the
internal grounds on which these eight letters
are set aside
as spurious. The difference of style from the other Ignatian writings
will strike him even in perusing the English version which we have given,
while it is of course much more marked in the original. And other
decisive proofs present themselves in every one of the Epistles. In that
to the Tarsians there is found a plain allusion to the Sabellian heresy,
which did not arise till after the middle of the third century. In the
Epistle to the Antiochians there is an enumeration of various Church
officers, who were certainly unknown at the period when Ignatius lived.
The Epistle to Hero plainly alludes to Manichæan errors, and could not
therefore have been written before the third century. There are equally
decisive proofs of spuriousness to be found in the Epistle to the
Philippians, such as the references it contains to the Patripassian
heresy originated by Praxeas in the latter part of the second century,
and the ecclesiastical feasts, etc., of which it makes mention. The
letter to Maria Cassobolita is of a very peculiar style, utterly alien
from that of the other Epistles ascribed to Ignatius. And it is
sufficient simply to glance at the short Epistles to St. John and the
Virgin Mary, in order to see that they carry the stamp of imposture on
their front; and, indeed, no sooner were they published than by almost
universal consent they were rejected.
But though the additional Ignatian letters here given
are confessedly spurious, we have thought it not improper to present them
to the English reader in an appendix to our first volume.
1176
We have done so,
because they have been so closely connected with the name of the bishop
of Antioch, and also because they are in themselves not destitute of
interest. We have, moreover, the satisfaction of thus placing for the
first time within the reach of one acquainted only with our language, all
the materials that have entered into the protracted agitation of the
famous Ignatian controversy.
1176
[Spurious writings, if they can
be traced to antiquity, are always useful. Sometimes they are evidence of
facts, always of opinions, ideas and fancies of their date; and often
they enable us to identify the origin of corruptions. Even interpolations
prove what later partisans would be glad to find, if they could, in early
writers. They bear unwilling testimony to the absence of
genuine
evidence in favour of their assumptions.]