saken wealth. For my patrimony can scarcely be considered a twentieth part of the ecclesi-
astical property which I am now supposed to possess as master. But in whatever church,
especially in Africa, our Pinianus might be ordained (I do not say a presbyter, but) a bishop,
he would be still in deep poverty compared with his former affluence, even if he were using
the church’s revenues in the spirit of one lording it over God’s heritage. Christian poverty
is much more clearly and certainly loved in the case of one in whom there is no room for
suspecting a desire for acquiring an accession to his wealth. It was this admiration which
kindled the minds of the people, and roused them to such violence of persevering clamour.
Let us therefore not charge them gratuitously with base covetousness, but rather, without
imputing unworthy motives, allow them at least to love in others that good thing which
they do not themselves possess. For although there may have mixed in the crowd some who
are indigent or beggars, who helped to increase the clamour, and were actuated by the hope
of some relief to their wants out of your honourable affluence, even this is not, in my opinion,
base covetousness.
8. It remains, therefore, that the reproach of disgraceful covetousness must be levelled
indirectly at the clergy, and especially at the bishop. For we are supposed to act as lords of
the church’s property; we are supposed to enjoy its revenues. In short, whatever money we
have received for the church either is still in our possession or has been spent according to
our judgment; and of it we have given nothing to any of the people besides the clergy and
the brethren in the monastery, excepting only a very few indigent persons. I do not mean
by this to say that the things which were said by you must necessarily have been said specially
against us, but that, if said against any others than ourselves, they must have been incredible.
What, then, shall we do? If it be not possible to clear ourselves before enemies, by what
means may we at least clear ourselves before you? The matter is one pertaining to the soul;
it is within us, hidden from the eyes of men, and known to God alone. What, then, remains
for us but to call to witness God, to whom it is known? When, therefore, you harbour these
suspicions concerning us, you do not command but absolutely compel us to give our oath,—a
much more grievous wrong than the commanding of an oath, which you have thought
proper in your letter to censure as highly culpable in me; you compel us, I say, not by men-
acing death to the body, as the people of Hippo were supposed to have done, but by menacing
death to our good name, which deserves to be regarded by us as more precious than life itself,
for the sake of those weak brethren to whom we endeavour in all circumstances to exhibit
ourselves as ensamples in good works.
9. We, however, are not indignant against you who compel us to this oath, as you are
indignant against the people of Hippo. For you believe, as men judging of other men, things
which, though not actually existing in us, might possibly have existed. Your suspicions we
must labour not so much to reprove as to remove; and since our conscience is clear in the
988
To Albina