CHAP. II.
CONCERNING THE OBJECTION, AGAINST THE DOCTRINE OF NATIVE COR-
RUPTION, THAT TO SUPPOSE MEN RECEIVE THEIR FIRST EXISTENCE IN SIN, IS
TO MAKE HIM WHO IS THE AUTHOR OF THEIR BEING, THE AUTHOR OF THEIR
DEPRAVITY.
One argument against a supposed native, sinful depravity, which Dr. T. greatly insists
upon, is, “that this does in effect charge him, who is the author of our nature, who formed
us in the womb, with being the author of a sinful corruption of nature; and that it is highly
injurious to the God of our nature, whose hands have formed and fashioned us, to believe
our nature to be originally corrupted, and that in the worst sense of corruption. 134
With respect to this, I would observe, in the first place, that this writer, in handling this
grand objection, supposes something to belong to the doctrine objected against, as maintained
by the divines whom he is opposing, which does not belong to it, nor follow from it. As
particularly, he supposes the doctrine of original sin to imply, that nature must be corrupted
by some positive influence; “something, by some means or other, infused into the human
nature; some quality or other, not from the choice of our minds, but like a taint, tincture,
or infection, altering the natural constitution, faculties, and dispositions of our souls. 135
That sin and evil dispositions are implanted in the fœtus in the womb.” 136 Whereas truly
our doctrine neither implies nor infers any such thing. In order to account for a sinful cor-
ruption of nature, yea, a total native depravity of the heart of man, there is not the least need
of supposing any evil quality, infused, implanted, or wrought into the nature of man, by any
positive cause, or influence whatsoever, either from God, or the creature; or of supposing,
that man is conceived and born with a fountain of evil in his heart, such as is any thing
properly positive. I think, a little attention to the nature of things will be sufficient to satisfy
any impartial considerate inquirer, that the absence of positive good principles, and so the
withholding of a special divine influence to impart and maintain those good principles—leav-
ing the common natural principles of self-love, natural appetite, &c. to themselves, without
the government of superior divine principles—will certainly be followed with the corruption;
yea, the total corruption of the heart, without occasion for any positive influence at all: and
that it was thus in fact that corruption of nature came on Adam, immediately on his fall,
and comes on all his posterity, as sinning in him, and falling with him. 137
134 P. 137, 187-189, 256, 258, 260, 143. S. and other places.
135 Page 187.
136 Page 146, 148, 149. S. and the like in many other places.
137 The sentiment contained in this paragraph, and illustrated in the following part of this chapter, is of the
utmost importance, in order not only to remove Pelagian prejudices, and the cavils of modern philosophers,
but also to give a just and consistent view of the nature and cause of sin; the cause of all sin in general, and ori-
ginal sin in particular. Our author’s explanation, which immediately follows, both in the text and in the note,
CHAPTER II. God not the Author of Sin.
1138
CHAPTER II. God not the Author of Sin.