59
Introductory Note to the Canons of the Provincial Synods which in this Volume are
Interjected Between the First and the Second Ecumenical Councils.
The First Canon of the Fourth Ecumenical Council, Chalcedon, reads as follows: “We
have judged it right that the canons of the Holy Fathers made in every synod even until
now, should remain in force.” And the Council in Trullo, in its second canon, has enumer-
ated these synods in the following words. “We set our seal to all the rest of the canons which
have been established by our holy and blessed fathers, that is to say by the 318 God-inspired
fathers who met at Nice, and by those who met at Ancyra, and by those who met at
Neocæsarea, as well as by those who met at Gangra: in addition to these the canons adopted
by those who met at Antioch in Syria, and by those who met at Laodicea in Phrygia; moreover
by the 150 fathers who assembled in this divinely kept and imperial city, and by the 200 who
were gathered in the metropolis of Ephesus, and by the 630 holy and blessed fathers who
met at Chalcedon,” etc., etc.
There can be no doubt that this collection of canons was made at a very early date, and
from the fact that the canons of the First Council of Constantinople do not appear, as they
naturally would, immediately after those of Nice, we may not improbably conclude that the
collection was formed before that council assembled. For it will be noticed that Nice, al-
though not the earliest in date, takes the precedence as being of ecumenical rank. And this
is expressly stated in the caption to the canons of Ancyra according to the reading in the
Paris Edition of Balsamon. “The canons of the holy Fathers who assembled at Ancyra; which
are indeed older than those made at Nice, but placed after them, on account of the authority
(αὐθεντίαν) of the Ecumenical Synod.”
On the arrangement of this code much has been written and Archbishop Ussher has
made some interesting suggestions, but all appear to be attended with more or less diffi-
culties. The reader will find in Bp. Beveridge, in the Prolegomena to his Synodicon a very
full treatment of the point,115 the gist of the matter is admirably given in the following brief
note which I take from Hammond. In speaking of this early codex of the Church he says:
(Hammond, Definitions of Faith and Canons of Discipline, pp. 134 and 135.)
That this collection was made and received by the Church previous to the Council of
Chalcedon is evident from the manner in which several of the Canons are quoted in that
Council. Thus in the 4th Action, in the matter of Carosus and Dorotheus, who had acknow-
ledged Dioscorus as Bishop, though he had been deposed from his bishopric, “the holy
Synod said, let the holy Canons of the Fathers be read, and inserted in the records; and Ac-
tius the Archdeacon taking the book read the 83d Canon, If any Bishops, etc. And again
the 84th Canon, concerning those who separate themselves, If any Presbyter,” etc. These
115 Beveridge, Synodicon., tom. I., p. vi. et seqq. (Bev. Works, tom. II., Append. p. xiii. et seqq. [Anglo.-Cath.
Lib.]).
Introductory Note to the Canons of the Provincial Synods which in this Volume are Interjected Between the First and the Second Ecumenical Councils.
132
Introductory Note to the Canons of the Provincial Synods which in this Volume…