by conception must be ascribed to Him Who is the Author of that faculty. Thus human life
invented the Art of Healing, but nevertheless he would be right who should assert that Art
to be a gift from God. And whatever discovery has been made in human life, conducive to
any useful purposes of peace or war, came to us from no other quarter but from an intelli-
gence conceiving and discovering according to our several requirements; and that intelligence
is a gift of God. It is to God, then, that we owe all that intelligence supplies to us. Nor do I
deny the objection made by our adversaries, that lying wonders also are fabricated by this
faculty. For their contention as to this makes for our own side in the argument. For we too
assert that the science of opposites is the same, whether beneficial or the reverse; e.g. in the
case of the arts of healing and navigation, and so on. For he who knows how to relieve the
sick by drugs will also know, if indeed he were to turn his art to an evil purpose, how to mix
some deleterious ingredient in the food of the healthy. And he who can steer a boat with its
rudder into port can also steer it for the reef or the rock, if minded to destroy those on board.
And the painter, with the same art by which he depicts the fairest form on his canvas, could
give us an exact representation of the ugliest. So, too, the wrestling-master, by the experience
which he has gained in anointing, can set a dislocated limb, or, should he wish to do so,
dislocate a sound one. But why encumber our argument by multiplying instances? As in
the above-mentioned cases no one would deny that he who has learned to practise an art
for right purposes can also abuse it for wrong ones, so we say that the faculty of thought
and conception was implanted by God in human nature for good, but, with those who abuse
it as an instrument of discovery, it frequently becomes the handmaid of pernicious inventions.
But although it is thus possible for this faculty to give a plausible shape to what is false and
unreal, it is none the less competent to investigate what actually and in very truth subsists,
and its ability for the one must in fairness be regarded as an evidence of its ability for the
other.
269
For that one who proposes to himself to terrify or charm an audience should have plenty
of conception to effect such a purpose, and should display to the spectators many-handed,
many-headed, or fire-breathing monsters, or men enfolded in the coils of serpents, or that
he should seem to increase their stature, or enlarge their natural proportions to a ridiculous
extent, or that he should describe men metamorphosed into fountains and trees and birds,
a kind of narrative which is not without its attraction for such as take pleasure in things of
that sort;—all this, I say, is the clearest of demonstrations that it is possible to arrive at
higher knowledge also by means of this inventive faculty.
For it is not the case that, while the intelligence implanted in us by the Giver is fully
competent to conjure up non-realities, it is endowed with no faculty at all for providing us
with things that may profit us. But as the impulsive and elective faculty of the soul is estab-
lished in our nature, to incite us to what is good and noble, though a man may also abuse
it for what is evil, and no one can call the fact that the elective faculty sometimes inclines to
508
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.