25. Manes said: Not all receive the word of God, but only those to whom it is given to
know the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven.1655 And even now1656 I know who are ours;
for “my sheep,” He says, “hear my voice.”1657 For the sake of those who belong to us, and
to whom is given the understanding of the truth, I shall speak in similitudes. The wicked
one is like a lion that sought to steal upon the flock of the good shepherd; and when the
shepherd saw this, he dug a huge pit, and took one kid out of the flock and cast it into the
pit. Then the lion, hungering to get at it, and bursting with passion to devour it, ran up to
the pit and fell in, and discovered no strength sufficient to bring him out again. And
thereupon the shepherd seized him and shut him up carefully in a den, and at the same time
secured the safety of the kid which had been with him in the pit. And it is in this way that
the wicked one has been enfeebled,—the lion, so to speak, possessing no more capacity for
198
doing aught injurious; and so all the race of souls will be saved, and what once perished will
yet be restored to its proper flock. Archelaus said: If you compare the wicked one to the lion,
and God to the true shepherd, tell us, whereunto shall we liken the sheep and the kid? Manes
said: The sheep and the kid seem to me to be of one nature: and they are taken as figures of
souls. Archelaus said: Well, then, God gave a soul over to perdition when He set it before
the lion in the pit. Manes said: By no means; far from it. But He was moved by a particular
disposition,1658 and in the future He will save that other, the soul. Archelaus said: Now,
surely it would be an absurd procedure, my hearers, if a shepherd who dreaded the inroad
of a lion were to expose to the beast’s devouring fury a lamb that he was wont to carry in
his bosom, and if it were then to be said that he meant to save the creature hereafter. Is not
this something supremely ridiculous? Yea, there is no kind of sense in this. For on the sup-
position implied in your similitude God thus handed over to Satan a soul that he might seize
and ruin. But when did the shepherd ever do anything like that?1659 Did not David deliver
a sheep out of the mouth of a lion or of a bear? And we mention this on account of the ex-
pression, out of the mouth of the lion; for, on your theory, this would imply that the shepherd
can bring forth out of the mouth of the lion, or out of the belly of the same, the very object
which it has devoured.1660 But you will perhaps make this answer, that it is of God we speak,
1655 Matt. xix. 11.
1656 The text gives et jam quidem for the etiam quidem of the Cod. Casin.
1657 John x. 27.
1658 Apprehensus est hoc ingenio. For hoc here, Routh suggests hic in reference to the leo so that the sense
might be = But by this plan the lion was caught, and hereafter He will save the soul.
1659 The text is, “Quando enim pastor, nonne David de ore leonis,” etc. We adopt the amended reading,
“Quando enim pastor hoc fecit? Nonne David,” etc.
1660 Routh would put this interrogatively = Can he bring out of the mouth or the belly of the lion what it has
once devoured?
Chapter XXV.
464
Chapter XXV.