This subject, at the time of which we are speaking, had become, also, a subject of warm
and extended controversy. The advocates of revivals of religion, had too generally been ac-
customed to attach to the mere circumstances of conversion—to the time, place, manner,
and means, in and by which it was supposed to be effected—an importance, no where given
them in the Scriptures; as well as to conclude, that all affections which were high in degree,
and accompanied with great apparent zeal and ardour, were of course gracious in their
nature; while their opposers insisted, that true religion did not consist at all in the affections,
but wholly in the external conduct. The latter class attributed the uncommon attention to
religion, which they could not deny had existed for four years in New England, to artificial
excitement merely; while the former saw nothing in it, or in the measures taken to promote
it, to condemn, but everything to approve. Mr. Edwards, in his views of the subject, differed
materially from both classes. As he knew from his own experience, that sin and the saving
grace of God might dwell in the same heart; so he had learned, both from observation and
testimony, that much false religion might prevail during a powerful revival of true religion,
and that at such a time, multitudes of hypocrites might spring up among real Christians.
Thus it was in the revival of religion in the time of Josiah, in that which attended the
preaching of John the Baptist, in those which occurred under the preaching of Christ, in
the remarkable outpouring of the Spirit in the days of the apostles, and in that which existed
in the time of the Reformation. He clearly saw, that it was this mixture of counterfeit religion
with true, which in all ages had given the devil his chief advantage against the kingdom of
Christ. “By this,” observes Mr. Edwards, “he hurt the cause of Christianity, in and after the
apostolic age, much more, than by all the persecutions of both Jews and heathens. By this
he prevailed against the Reformation, to put a stop to its progress, more than by all the
bloody persecutions of the church of Rome. By this he prevailed against the revivals of reli-
gion, that have occurred since the Reformation. By this he prevailed against New England,
to quench the love of her espousals, about a hundred years ago. And I think I have had op-
portunity enough to see plainly, that by this the devil has prevailed against the late great
revival of religion in New England, so happy and promising in its beginning. I have seen
the devil prevail in this way, against two great revivings of religion in this country. By per-
verting us from the simplicity that is in Christ, he hath suddenly prevailed to deprive us of
that fair prospect we had a little while ago, of a kind of paradisaic state of the church of God
in New England.”
These evils, it was obvious, must exist in the church, until their cause was removed, and
men had learned to distinguish accurately between true and false religion. To contribute
his own best endeavours for the accomplishment of this end, Mr. Edwards prepared and
published his “Treatise on Religious Affections.” The great design of this treatise is, to show,
in what true religion consists, and what are its distinguishing marks and evidences; and thus
to enable every man, who will be honest and faithful with himself, to decide whether he is,
164
CHAPTER XIV. Mistakes extensively prevalent at this time, as to the nature…