no more than a “relative union,” and would reduce the Saviour to a “Theophoros,” the title
claimed of old by one of his chief martyrs. And the real identity of Nestorius’s view with
that of Theodore [of Mopsuestia] was but too plainly exhibited by such statements as occur
in some of the extracts preserved in Cyril’s treatise Against Nestorius—to the effect that
Christ was one with the Word by participation in dignity; that “the man” was partaker of
Divine power, and in that sense not mere man; that he was adored together with the Word;
and that “My Lord and my God” was a doxology to the Father; and above all, by the words
spoken at Ephesus, “I can never allow that a child of three months old was God.”
It is no part of my duty to defend the truth of either the Catholic or Nestorian proposi-
tion—each has found many adherents in most ages since it was first started, and probably
what is virtually Nestorianism is to-day far more widely held among persons deemed to be
orthodox than is commonly supposed. Be this as it may, Nestorianism is clearly subversive
of the whole Catholic Doctrine of the Incarnation, and therefore the importance of the word
Θεοτόκος cannot be exaggerated.
208
I shall treat the word Theotocos under two heads; (1) Its history (2) its meaning, first
however quoting Bp. Pearson’s words on its Conciliar authority. (Pearson, Exp. of the
Creed, Art. III., n. 37). “It is plain that the Council of Ephesus which condemned Nestorius
confirmed this title Θεοτόκος; I say confirmed it; for it is evident that it was before used in
the Church, by the tumult which arose at the first denial of it by Anastasius [Nestorius’s
presbyter]; and so confirmed it as received before, because they approved the Epistles of St.
Cyril, who proved it by the usage of those Fathers which preceded him.”
(1) History of Word Θεοτόκος.
It has not been unfrequently assumed that the word Theotocos was coined to express
the peculiar view of the Incarnation held by St. Cyril. Such however, is an entire mistake.
It was an old term of Catholic Theology, and the very word was used by bishop Alexander
in a letter from the synod held at Alexandria in a.d. 320,248 to condemn the Arian heresy
(more than a hundred years before the meeting of the Council of Ephesus); “After this, we
receive the doctrine of the resurrection from the dead, of which Jesus Christ our Lord became
the first-fruits; who bore a body in truth, not in semblance, which he derived from Mary
the Mother of God (ἐκ τῆς Θεοτόκου Μαρίας).”249 The same word had been used by many
church writers among whom may be mentioned St. Athanasius, who says, “As the flesh was
born of Mary, the Mother of God, so we say that he, the Word, was himself born of Mary”
(Orat. c. Arian., iij., 14, 29, 33; also iv., 32). See also Eusebius (Vit. Const., iij., 43); St. Cyril
of Jerusalem (Cat., x., 9); and especially Origen, who (says Bp. Pearson) “did not only use,
but expound at large the meaning of that title Θεοτόκος in his first tome on the Epistle to
248 The date is not certain, it may have been a year or so different.
249 Theod., Hist. Eccl., I., 4.
395
Excursus on the Word .