to make the mind insensible to any thing else. Those appetites take up the whole soul; and,
through habit and custom, the water is all drawn out of other channels, in which it naturally
flows, and is all carried as it were into one channel.
In like manner, natural affection, and natural pity, though not of the nature of virtue,
may be diminished greatly by the increase of pride and sensuality; and, as the consequence
of this, be habitually disposed to envy, malice, &c. These lusts, when they prevail to a high
degree, may overcome and diminish the exercise of those natural principles; even as they
often overcome and diminish common prudence in a man, who seeks his own private interest
in point of health, wealth, or honour; and yet no one will think it proves that a man being
cunning in seeking his own personal and temporal interest, has any thing of the nature and
essence of true virtue.
Another reason why these natural principles and affections are mistaken for true virtue,
is, that in several respects they have the same effect which true virtue tends to; especially in
these two ways:
1. The present state of the world is so constituted by the wisdom and goodness of its
supreme Ruler, that these natural principles, for the most part, tend to the good of mankind.
139
So do natural pity, gratitude, parental affection, &c. Herein they agree with the tendency of
general benevolence, which seeks and tends to the general good. But this is no proof that
these natural principles have the nature of true virtue. For self-love is exceeding useful and
necessary; and so are the natural appetites of hunger, thirst, &c. Yet nobody will assert that
these have nature of true virtue.
2. These principles have a like effect with true virtue in this respect, that they tend sev-
eral ways to restrain vice, and prevent many acts of wickedness. So natural affection, love
to our party, or to particular friends, tends to keep us from acts of injustice towards these
persons; which would be real wickedness. Pity preserves from cruelty, which would be real
and great moral evil. Natural conscience tends to restrain sin in general. But this cannot
prove these principles themselves to be of the nature of true virtue. For so is this present
state ordered by a merciful God, that even self-love often restrains from acts of true
wickedness; and not only so, but puts men upon seeking true virtue; yet is not itself true
virtue, but is the source of all the wickedness that is in the world.
Another reason why these inferior affections, especially some of them, are accounted
virtuous, is, that there are affections of the same denomination which are truly virtuous.
Thus, for instance, there is a truly virtuous pity, or a compassion to others, under affliction
or misery, from general benevolence. Pure benevolence would be sufficient to excite pity to
another in calamity, if there were no particular instinct, or any other principle determining
the mind thereto. It is easy to see how benevolence, which seeks another’s good, should
cause us to desire his deliverance from evil. And this is a source of pity far more extensive
than the other. It excites compassion in cases that are overlooked by natural instinct; and
912
CHAPTER VII. The reasons of many mistakes