to take part in the approaching festival to be held there on the occasion of his tricennalia.
The scene was one of great splendor. Bishops were present from all parts of the world, and
the occasion was marked by the dedication of the new and magnificent basilica which
Constantine had erected upon the site of Calvary (Theodoret, I. 31; Socrates, I. 28 and 33;
Sozomen, II. 26; Eusebius, Vita Const. IV. 41 and 43). The bishops gathered in Jerusalem
at this time held another synod before separating. In this they completed the work begun
at Tyre, by re-admitting Arius and his adherents to the communion of the Church (see So-
crates, I. 33, and Sozomen, II. 27). According to Sozomen the Emperor, having been induced
to recall Arius from banishment in order to reconsider his case, was presented by the latter
with a confession of faith, which was so worded as to convince Constantine of his orthodoxy.
He therefore sent Arius and his companion Euzoius to the bishops assembled in Jerusalem
with the request that they would examine the confession, and if they were satisfied with its
orthodoxy would re-admit them to communion. The Council, which was composed largely
of Arius’ friends and sympathizers, was only too glad to accede to the Emperor’s request.
Meanwhile Athanasius had induced Constantine, out of a sense of justice, to summon
the bishops that had condemned him at Tyre to give an account of their proceedings before
the Emperor himself at Constantinople. This unexpected, and, doubtless, not altogether
welcome summons came while the bishops were at Jerusalem, and the majority of them at
once returned home in alarm, while only a few answered the call and repaired to Con-
stantinople. Among these were Eusebius of Nicomedia, Theognis of Nicæa, Patrophilus of
Scythopolis, and other prominent Arians, and with them our Eusebius (Athanasius, Apol.
c. Arian. §§86 and 87; Socrates, I. 33–35; Sozomen, II. 28). The accusers of Athanasius said
nothing on this occasion in regard to his alleged immoralities, for which he had been con-
demned at Tyre, but made another equally trivial accusation against him, and the result was
his banishment to Gaul. Whether Constantine banished him because he believed the charge
brought against him, or because he wished to preserve him from the machinations of his
enemies (as asserted by his son Constantine, and apparently believed by Athanasius himself;
see his Apol. c. Arian. §87), or because he thought that Athanasius’ absence would allay the
troubles in the Alexandrian church we do not know. The latter supposition seems most
probable. In any case he was not recalled from banishment until after Constantine’s death.
Our Eusebius has been severely condemned by many historians for the part taken by him
in the Eustathian controversy and especially in the war against Athanasius. In justice to him
a word or two must be spoken in his defense. So far as his relations to Eustathius are con-
cerned, it is to be noticed that the latter commenced the controversy by accusing Eusebius
of heterodoxy. Eusebius himself did not begin the quarrel, and very likely had no desire to
37
Continuance of the Arian Controversy. Eusebius' Relations to the Two Pa…