Chapter 3.—Concerning the Arguments Which Nigidius the Mathematician Drew from
the Potter’s Wheel, in the Question About the Birth of Twins.
It is to no purpose, therefore, that that famous fiction about the potter’s wheel is brought
forward, which tells of the answer which Nigidius is said to have given when he was perplexed
with this question, and on account of which he was called Figulus.191 For, having whirled
round the potter’s wheel with all his strength he marked it with ink, striking it twice with
the utmost rapidity, so that the strokes seemed to fall on the very same part of it. Then,
when the rotation had ceased, the marks which he had made were found upon the rim of
the wheel at no small distance apart. Thus, said he, considering the great rapidity with which
the celestial sphere revolves, even though twins were born with as short an interval between
their births as there was between the strokes which I gave this wheel, that brief interval of
time is equivalent to a very great distance in the celestial sphere. Hence, said he, come
whatever dissimilitudes may be remarked in the habits and fortunes of twins. This argument
is more fragile than the vessels which are fashioned by the rotation of that wheel. For if
there is so much significance in the heavens which cannot be comprehended by observation
of the constellations, that, in the case of twins, an inheritance may fall to the one and not to
the other, why, in the case of others who are not twins, do they dare, having examined their
constellations, to declare such things as pertain to that secret which no one can comprehend,
and to attribute them to the precise moment of the birth of each individual? Now, if such
predictions in connection with the natal hours of others who are not twins are to be vindic-
ated on the ground that they are founded on the observation of more extended spaces in
the heavens, whilst those very small moments of time which separated the births of twins,
and correspond to minute portions of celestial space, are to be connected with trifling things
about which the mathematicians are not wont to be consulted,—for who would consult
them as to when he is to sit, when to walk abroad, when and on what he is to dine? —how
can we be justified in so speaking, when we can point out such manifold diversity both in
the habits, doings, and destinies of twins?
191 I.e. the potter.
Concerning the Arguments Which Nigidius the Mathematician Drew from the Potter’s Wheel, in the Question About the Birth of Twins.
213
Concerning the Arguments Which Nigidius the Mathematician Drew from the…