the part of a judge, or else judges falsely. The very notion of judging is to determine what
is, and what is not, in any one’s case. The judge’s work is twofold; it is to determine first
what is fact, and then whether what is in fact be according to rule, or according to the law.
If a judge has no rule or law established beforehand, by which he should proceed in judging,
he has no foundation to go upon in judging, he has no opportunity to be a judge; nor is it
possible that he should do the part of a judge. To judge without a law or rule by which to
judge, is impossible; for the very notion of judging, is to determine whether the object of
judgment be according to rule; and therefore God has declared, that when he acts as a judge,
he will not justify the wicked, and cannot clear the guilty; and, by parity of reason, cannot
justify without righteousness.
And the scheme of the old law’s being abrogated, and a new law introduced, will not
help at all in this difficulty; for an imperfect righteousness cannot answer the law of God
we are under, whether that be an old or a new one; for every law requires perfect obedience
to itself. Every rule whatsoever requires perfect conformity to itself; it is a contradiction to
suppose otherwise. For to say, that there is a law that does not require perfect obedience to
itself, is to say that there is a law that does not require all that it requires. That law that now
forbids sin, is certainly the law that we are now under, (let that be an old or a new one,) or
else it is not sin. That which is not forbidden, and is the breach of the law, is no sin. But if
we are now forbidden to commit sin, then it is by a law that we are now under; for surely
we are neither under the forbiddings nor commanding of a law that we are not under.
Therefore, if all sin is now forbidden, then we are now under a law that requires perfect
obedience; and therefore nothing can be accepted as a righteousness in the sight of our
Judge, but perfect righteousness. So that our Judge cannot justify us, unless he sees a perfect
righteousness, some way belonging to us, either performed by ourselves, or by another, and
justly and duly reckoned to our account.
eous, just or unjust, i.e. exact performers or transgressors of the law.” Again, in p. 477. “The way of works then
in short is, that law which requires perfect obedience, without any remission or abatement; so that by that law
a man cannot be just or justified, without an exact performance of every tittle. Such a perfect obedience in the
New Testament, is termed , which we translate righteousness.” In which last passage it is also to be
noted, that Mr. Locke, by the law of works, does not understand the ceremonial law, but the covenant of works;
as he more fully expresses himself in the next paragraph but one. “Where this law of works was to be found, the
New Testament tells us, viz. in the law delivered by Moses; John i.17.The law was given by Moses, but grace and
truth came by Jesus Christ. Chap. vii. 19. Did not Moses give you the law, says our Saviour, and yet none of you
keep the law? And this is the law which he speaks of– verse 28. This do, and thou shalt live. This is that which
St. Paul so often styles the law, without any other distinction; Rom. ii. 13.. Not the hearers of the law are just
before God, but the doers of the law are justified. It is needless to quote any more places, his epistles are all full
of it, especially this to the Romans.”
2329
DISCOURSE. I. Justification by Faith alone.