of love! But what more can I do than present my words before your eye, and my heart before
God?
6. Let us put away from between us those vain objections which are wont to be thrown
at each other by the ignorant on either side. Do not on your part cast up to me the persecu-
tions of Macarius. I, on mine, will not reproach you with the excesses of the Circumcelliones.
If you are not to blame for the latter, neither am I for the former; they pertain not to us. The
Lord’s floor is not yet purged—it cannot be without chaff; be it ours to pray, and to do what
in us lies that we may be good grain. I could not pass over in silence the rebaptizing of our
deacon; for I know how much harm my silence might do to myself. For I do not propose
to spend my time in the empty enjoyment of ecclesiastical dignity; but I propose to act as
mindful of this, that to the one Chief Shepherd I must give account of the sheep committed
unto me. If you would rather that I should not thus write to you, you must, my brother,
excuse me on the ground of my fears; for I do fear greatly, lest, if I were silent and concealed
my sentiments, others might be rebaptized by you. I have resolved, therefore, with such
strength and opportunity as the Lord may grant, so to manage this discussion, that by our
peaceful conferences, all who belong to our communion may know how far apart from
heresy and schism is the position of the Catholic Church, and with what care they should
guard against the destruction which awaits the tares and the branches cut off from the Lord’s
vine. If you willingly accede to such conference with me, by consenting to the public reading
of the letters of both, I shall unspeakably rejoice. If this proposal is displeasing to you, what
can I do, my brother, but read our letters, even without your consent, to the Catholic con-
gregation, with a view to its instruction? But if you do not condescend to write me a reply,
I am resolved at least to read my own letter, that, when your misgivings as to your procedure
are known, others may be ashamed to be rebaptized.
7. I shall not, however, do this in the presence of the soldiery, lest any of you should
think that I wish to act in a violent way, rather than as the interests of peace demand; but
only after their departure, that all who hear me may understand, that I do not propose to
compel men to embrace the communion of any party, but desire the truth to be made known
to persons who, in their search for it, are free from disquieting apprehensions. On our side
there shall be no appeal to men’s fear of the civil power; on your side, let there be no intim-
idation by a mob of Circumcelliones. Let us attend to the real matter in debate, and let our
arguments appeal to reason and to the authoritative teaching of the Divine Scriptures, dis-
passionately and calmly, so far as we are able; let us ask, seek, and knock, that we may receive
and find, and that to us the door may be opened, and thereby may be achieved, by God’s
blessing on our united efforts and prayers, the first towards the entire removal from our
district of that impiety which is such a disgrace to Africa. If you do not believe that I am
willing to postpone the discussion until after the soldiery have left, you may delay your answer
until they have gone; and if, while they are still here, I should wish to read my own letter to
564
To Maximin