It seems strange that any person familiar with the facts of the case could for a moment
entertain a doubt as to the ecumenical character of the council which met at Nice in 787.
(a) It was called by the Roman Emperors to be an Ecumenical Council. Vide letter of
Tarasius.
(b) It was called with the approval of the Pope (not like I. Constantinople, without his
knowledge; or like Chalcedon, contrary to his expressed wish), and two papal legates were
present at its deliberations and signed its decrees.
(c) The Patriarch of Constantinople was present in person.
(d) The other Patriarchates were represented, although on account of the Moslem
tyranny the Patriarchs could not attend in person, nor could they even send proctors.
(e) The decrees were adopted by an unanimous vote of the three hundred and fifty
bishops.
524
(f) They were immediately received in all the four Eastern Patriarchates.510
(g) They were immediately accepted by the Pope.
(h) For a full thousand years they have been received by the Latin and Greek Churches
with but a few exceptions altogether insignificant, save the Frankish kingdom.
In the face of such undisputed facts, it would be strange were anyone to doubt the his-
torical fact that the Second Council of Nice is one of the Ecumenical Councils of the Cath-
olic Church, and indeed so far as I am aware none have done so except such as have been
forced into this position for doctrinal consistency.
Nor have all Protestants allowed their judgment to be warped in this matter. As a sample
I may quote from that stanch Protestant whom Queen Elizabeth appointed a chaplain in
ordinary in 1598, and who in 1610 was made Dean of Gloucester, the profoundly learned
Richard Field. In his famous “Book of the Church” (Book V. chap. lj.), he says: “These”
[six, which he had just described] “were all the lawful General Councils (lawful, I say, both
in their beginning and proceeding and continuance) that ever were holden in the Christian
Church, touching matters of faith. For the Seventh, which is the Second of Nice, was not
called about any question of faith but of manners. So that there are but Seven General
Councils that the whole Church acknowledgeth, called to determine matters of faith and
manners. For the rest that were holden afterwards, which our adversaries [the Roman
Catholics] would have to be acknowledged general, they are not only rejected by us but by
the Grecians also, as not general, but patriarchal only, etc.”
510 “It is certain,” confesses Dr. Neale (History of the Holy Eastern Church, Vol. II., p. 113; in his attempt to
overthrow the authority of this council) “that Politian approved (S. Theod. Stud. Ep. xviij.) although he was not
present at the council of Nicæa; and the controversy, which had never much disturbed Africa, may henceforth
be considered as terminated in the Diocese of Alexandria.”
985
Introduction.