to Mr. Clap’s letter of the 12th; and receiving another, dated Oct. 28th, before he sent it, he
replied to that also in the postscript, under date of Nov. 3d. Mr. Clap, finding that Mr. Ed-
wards’s contradiction of his statement was believed; and having heard, though incorrectly,
that Mr. Edwards was about to publish such a contradiction; incautiously published a letter
to his friend in Boston, in which he not only re-asserted his former statement, but declared
that Mr. Edwards, in his private correspondence with him on the subject, had made a declar-
ation, equally full and strong, to the same point. Mr. Edwards published a reply, in a letter
to his friend in Boston, dated Feb. 4, 1745; in which he gave his two letters of Oct. 18, and
Oct. 29, with the postscript of Nov. 3; from which it appears that, instead of admitting the
truth of Mr. Clap’s statement, he had most explicitly and solemnly denied it; and, in order
to show how Mr. Clap might have been led into the mistake, acknowledged that he himself
supposed that Mr. Whitefield was formerly of the opinion, that unconverted ministers ought
not to be continued in the ministry; and that he himself supposed that Mr. Whitefield en-
lxxviii
deavoured to propagate this opinion, and a practice agreeable to it; and that all he had ever
stated to any one was, his own opinion merely, and not any declared design of Mr. Whitefield.
He also admitted, that Mr. Whitefield told him he intended to bring over a number of young
men, to be ordained by the Messrs. Tennents, in New Jersey. He then asks, whether this is
the same thing as Mr. Clap asserted, and suggests a variety of arguments, which seem abso-
lutely conclusive, that he could never have made such a statement.
Mr. Clap, in reply to this, in a letter to Mr. Edwards, dated April 1, 1745, enters seriously
upon the task of showing that Mr. Edwards’s assertion—“that Mr. Whitefield told him, that
he intended to bring over a number of young men, to be ordained by the Messrs. Tennents,
in New Jersey”—connected with the assertion—that Mr. Edwards himself supposed, that
Mr. Whitefield was formerly of the opinion, that unconverted ministers ought not to be
continued in the ministry, and that Mr. Edwards himself supposed that Mr. Whitefield en-
deavoured to propagate this opinion, and a practice agreeable to it—was equivalent to Mr.
Edwards’s saying, that Mr. Whitefield told him, “that he had the design of turning out of
their places the greater part of the ministers of New England, and of supplying their places
with ministers from England, Scotland, and Ireland.”
Mr. Edwards, in a letter to Mr. Clap, of May 20, 1745, after exposing in a few words the
desperate absurdity of this attempt, enters on the discussion of the question—Whether he
ever made such a statement to Mr. Clap?—with as much calmness as he afterwards exhibited
in examining the question of a self-determining power; and with such logical precision of
argument, that probably no one of his readers ever had a doubt left upon his mind, with
regard to it;—no, not even his antagonist himself; for he never thought proper to attempt
a reply; and in the public protest of the faculty of Yale college, against Mr. Whitefield, he
and his associates in office say, in alluding to this very conversation, “You told the Rev. Mr.
Edwards of Northampton, that you intended to bring over a number of young men from
154
Chapter XIII. First Interview with David Brainerd--Separations From Churches--Letter…