into the unity of Christ, that we must act only by words, fight only by arguments, and prevail
by force of reason, lest we should have those whom we knew as avowed heretics feigning
themselves to be Catholics. But this opinion of mine was overcome not by the words of
those who controverted it, but by the conclusive instances to which they could point. For,
in the first place, there was set over against my opinion my own town, which, although it
was once wholly on the side of Donatus, was brought over to the Catholic unity by fear of
the imperial edicts, but which we now see filled with such detestation of your ruinous per-
versity, that it would scarcely be believed that it had ever been involved in your error. There
were so many others which were mentioned to me by name, that, from facts themselves, I
was made to own that to this matter the word of Scripture might be understood as applying:
“Give opportunity to a wise man, and he will be yet wiser.”2175 For how many were already,
as we assuredly know, willing to be Catholics, being moved by the indisputable plainness
of truth, but daily putting off their avowal of this through fear of offending their own party!
How many were bound, not by truth—for you never pretended to that as yours—but by the
heavy chains of inveterate custom, so that in them was fulfilled the divine saying: “A servant
(who is hardened) will not be corrected by words; for though he understand, he will not
answer”!2176 How many supposed the sect of Donatus to be the true Church, merely because
ease had made them too listless, or conceited, or sluggish, to take pains to examine Catholic
truth! How many would have entered earlier had not the calumnies of slanderers, who de-
clared that we offered something else than we do upon the altar of God, shut them out! How
many, believing that it mattered not to which party a Christian might belong, remained in
the schism of Donatus only because they had been born in it, and no one was compelling
them to forsake it and pass over into the Catholic Church!
18. To all these classes of persons the dread of those laws in the promulgation of which
kings serve the Lord in fear has been so useful, that now some say we were willing for this
some time ago; but thanks be to God, who has given us occasion for doing it at once, and
has cut off the hesitancy of procrastination! Others say: We already knew this to be true,
but we were held prisoners by the force of old custom: thanks be to the Lord, who has broken
these bonds asunder, and has brought us into the bond of peace! Others say: We knew not
that the truth was here, and we had no wish to learn it; but fear made us become earnest to
examine it when we became alarmed, lest, without any gain in things eternal, we should be
smitten with loss in temporal things: thanks be to the Lord, who has by the stimulus of fear
startled us from our negligence, that now being disquieted we might inquire into those
things which, when at ease, we did not care to know! Others say: We were prevented from
entering the Church by false reports, which we could not know to be false unless we entered
2175 Prov. ix. 9.
2176 Prov. xxix. 19.
857
To Vincentius