no proper willingness to comply with the cost and difficulty. That which he is willing for,
with a moral sincerity, is something else, which is a great deal easier, and less cross to flesh
and blood. Suppose a king should propose to a subject his building him such a tower,
504
promising him a certain reward. If the subject should undertake it, not counting the cost,
thinking with himself that the king meant another sort of tower, much cheaper; and should
be willing only to build that cheap one, which he imagined in his own mind; when he would
by no means have consented to build so costly a tower as the king proposed, if he had un-
derstood him right: such a man could not be said properly to be willing to comply with his
prince’s proposal, with any sincerity at all. For what he consents to with a moral sincerity,
is not the thing which the king proposed.
The promises of unsanctified men are like the promises of the man we read of, (Luke
ix. 57, 58.) who said, “Lord, I will follow thee whithersoever thou goest.” To whom Christ
replied, “The foxes have holes, and the birds of the air have nests, but the Son of man hath
not where to lay his head.” When he made his promise, he probably quite mistook the thing,
and did not imagine, that to follow Christ wherever he went, would be to follow him in such
poverty and hardship. I suppose, the rich young man we read of (Mark x. 17, &c.) might
have what is called moral sincerity. But he had no sincerity in the covenant of grace. When
he came to Christ to know what he should do to have eternal life, it is probable he ignorantly
thought himself willing to yield himself to Christ’s direction. Yet when it came to a trial,
and Christ told him he must go and sell all that he had and give to the poor, it proved that
he had no sincerity of willingness at all for any such thing.—So that it is evident, however
unsanctified men may be morally sincere in some things, yet they have no sincerity of any
sort in that covenant, of which the sacraments are seals; and that moral sincerity, distinct
from gracious, in this covenant, is a mere imagination, there being indeed no such thing.
II. Another argument against this notion of moral sincerity, giving a right to church
communion, is this: a quality that is transient and vanishing, can be no qualification of fitness
for a standing privilege. Unsanctified men may be very serious, greatly affected, and much
engaged in religion; but the Scripture compares their religion to a lamp not supplied with
oil, which will go out, and to a plant that has no root nor deepness of earth, which will soon
wither ; and compares such unsanctified men to the dog that will return to his vomit, and
to the sow which, though washed ever so clean, yet her nature not being changed, will return
to her wallowing in the mire.
Mr. W. allows, that persons in order to come to sacraments, must have deep convictions,
an earnest concern to obtain salvation, &c. Now every one who is in any degree acquainted
with religious matters, knows that such convictions are not wont to last a great while, if they
have no saving issue. Mr. S. in his sermon on the danger of speedy degeneracy, (p. 11.) says,
“Unconverted men will grow weary of religious duties.” And our author himself, (p. 78. c.)
speaking of those professors in the primitive churches that fell away to heresy and other
1950
SECTION VIII. Of sincerity.