then while they continue in a wilful rejection of him (which according to Mr. W. all unre-
generate men do) they live continually in the violation of their promise and oath. 409
I would observe one thing further under this head, viz. That ungodly men which live
under the gospel, notwithstanding any moral sincerity they may have, are worse, and more
provoking enemies to God, than the very heathen, who never sinned against gospel-light
and mercy. This is very manifest by the Scriptures, particularly Matt. x. 13, 14. Amos iii. 2.
Rom. ii. 9. 2 Pet. ii. 21. Rev. iii. 15, 16.
I had suggested, concerning Mr. Stoddard’s doctrine of admitting more unconverted
than converted by attending Christ’s rule, that this supposes it to be the case of the members
of the visible church, that the greater part of them are more provoking enemies to God than
most of the heathen. Mr. W. represents himself as greatly alarmed at this: he calls it an ex-
traordinary passage, and puts five questions about it to my serious consideration. (p. 72,
73.) The first and chief question is this; “Did Mr. S. ever say in the Appeal, or any where
else, of most of our fellow-worshippers at the sacrament, that we have no reason to think
409 Here I would observe, that not only in the general do unsanctified men, notwithstanding their moral
sincerity, thus live in the most heinous wickedness; but particularly, according to Mr. W.‘s own doctrine, their
very attendance on the outward ordinances and duties of worship, is the vilest, most flagrant, and abominable
impiety. In his sermons on Christ a King and Witness, (p. 77, 78.) he says, “If a man could perform all the outward
acts of worship and obedience, which the Bible requires, from the beginning to the end of it. and not do them
from faith in Christ, and love to God, and not express by them the thoughts, desires, and actings of his soul;
they would be so far from being that obedience which Christ requires, that they would be a mocking of God,
and hateful to him. These outward acts ought to be no other, and in religion are designed to stand for nothing
else, but to be representations of a man’s soul, and the acts of that. And when they are not so. they are in their
own nature a lie, and false pretence of something within, which is not there: Therefore the Lord abhors them,
and reckons these false pretences the vilest wickedness.—Now when a man performs all outward obedience and
worship, but it does not come from his heart, he practically denies the omniscience of Christ, while he puts before
him a show and pretence of something for the reality; and so he belies his own profession. And all this, be it
more or less, whatever it pretends to be of religion, instead of being that which Christ requires, is entirely different
from it, yea. infinitely contrary to it. And those same actions, which when they are the language of the heart,
and flow from it, are pleasing and acceptable to God and Jesus Christ, are true obedience to him; when they do
not, are reckoned the most flagrant and abominable impiety, and threatened with the severest damnation of
hell.”—Now, who can believe, that God has, by his own holy institution, made that sort of sincerity, which is
nothing better than what is consistent with such a lying, vile, abominable, flagrantly wicked pretence and show
of religion as this, the very thing that gives a right, even in his sight, to christian sacraments. I might here also
observe, that if moral sincerity or common grace gives a right to sacraments in the sight of God, then that which
(according to Mr. S - d’s doctrine before observed) is a spirit of lust, that which is contrary to, and at war with,
and would destroy saving grace, is the thing which gives a right in the sight of God to christian sacraments.
1954
SECTION VIII. Of sincerity.