“Therefore also they disagree among themselves, maintaining an inconsistent opinion. For Apelles, one of the herd, priding himself on his manner of life and his age, acknowledges one principle, but says that the prophecies are from an opposing spirit, being led to this view by the responses of a maiden by name Philumene, who was possessed by a demon.
{"author":"Eusebius of Caesarea (historical work attribution)","date_end":null,"date_label":"Date uncertain","date_start":null,"edition_year":1890,"edition_year_basis":"Original NPNF Series II Volume I title and copyright, 1890; transcription physical printing year unknown","id":"bulk-eusebius-history-npnf2-1-passage:ancl:69a3161f43fa4faec559:p:4","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"metadata_approval_pending":true,"original_note_proof_record_id":"private-eusebius-history-npnf2-1-next-note:69a3161f43fa4faec559:cite_note-11","original_work_path_hint":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_I/Church_History_of_Eusebius/Book_V/Chapter_13","public_import_allowed":false,"record_type":"indexed-source-passage","references":[{"book":"ACT","chapter":21,"kind":"citation","verse":9}],"section":"Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.; original source section: Chapter 13, source paragraph 4","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_I/Church_History_of_Eusebius/Book_V/Chapter_13#cite_note-11","translator":"Rev. Arthur Cushman McGiffert (Ph.D.)","verification":{"note":{"backlink_hrefs":["#cite_ref-11"],"body_html":{"$text_sha256":"1e481cd59190725904e46e41e73dd58d9cf295a6a360db168f5f83e7152ee9da"},"body_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[11]/span[2]","container_html":{"$text_sha256":"28309001cd1751f094056a2c6b7a32c39966696646d8eb825d1627435dfadaef"},"container_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[11]","id":"cite_note-11","marker_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[4]/sup[6]/a"},"original_work_coordinate":{"actual_original_callouts":[{"backlink_href":"#cite_ref-11","nearest_preceding_main_text_book_heading":null,"nearest_preceding_main_text_chapter_heading":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"0094cfb78030e5832c193fe2aea1567b9d662b4686093fc8d5866dc36fa138a6"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"0094cfb78030e5832c193fe2aea1567b9d662b4686093fc8d5866dc36fa138a6","original_node_id":"mwBA","source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/69a3161f43fa4faec559.html","source_sha256":"a8309530ebd8e42a43647d90b4cd2967d3721fbf34eef686bea5a2096b8a3daa","text":"Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[1]"},"nearest_preceding_main_text_section_heading":null,"nearest_preceding_transcription_book_heading":null,"nearest_preceding_transcription_chapter_heading":null,"nearest_preceding_transcription_section_heading":null,"original_callout":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"d4d63d8fb132d8836e54147fdd4a67ae640414ddaf50408b26afaa68a56d44bb"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"d4d63d8fb132d8836e54147fdd4a67ae640414ddaf50408b26afaa68a56d44bb","original_node_id":"cite_ref-11","source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/69a3161f43fa4faec559.html","source_sha256":"a8309530ebd8e42a43647d90b4cd2967d3721fbf34eef686bea5a2096b8a3daa","text":"","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[4]/sup[6]"}}],"ancient_author_assignment_approved":true,"author_assignment_basis":{"original_author_translation_credit":{"original_text":"THE CHURCH HISTORY OF EUSEBIUS, \n\n\nTRANSLATED WITH PROLEGOMENA AND NOTES \n\nBY \n\nTHE REV. ARTHUR CUSHMAN McGIFFERT, Ph.D., \n\nPROFESSOR OF CHURCH HISTORY IN LANE THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY, CINCINNATI.","sha256":"08b9399b8b0ebc3317bc414aa222f45edfeb99f5ccf06614773fd6065315ae91","source_path":"raw/research/anf-npnf/archive/selectlibraryofn18901scha.ocr.txt","source_sha256":"830863b4b98bfb54a69b8fdd1e0081bb1b3e4d3df22f1770c99de277e9dd9d2f","utf8_byte_end":2046,"utf8_byte_start":1816},"original_work_memberships":[{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"bf575f58e965326f637a82474340240df1cf7dfba808a938081e4e898a1bd511"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"bf575f58e965326f637a82474340240df1cf7dfba808a938081e4e898a1bd511","original_node_id":"mwGg","source_id":"baf2f1439c97f48051fd","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage9/baf2f1439c97f48051fd.html","source_sha256":"df7f33f9e41dba1e8d70106b5ddf43d8a07a9973046301dc91acdffeab9558b1","text":"Book V","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[10]/a"}],"scope":"Historical compiler and work attribution only; quoted letter writers and speakers and individual exposition remain unreviewed. Historical English editorial notes separately attributed."},"book_number_approved":false,"book_number_inferred_from_URL":false,"chapter_number_approved":false,"chapter_number_inferred_from_URL":false,"chapter_uncertain":false,"native_paragraph_number_prefix":null,"note_id":"cite_note-11","original_ancestor_location_witnesses":[],"original_main_text_heading_labels":["Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion."],"original_page_catalogue_memberships":[{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"1774a04ae662973ff0f4d723050b185048f60837afbf4f26d95e84407bd5c1cf"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"1774a04ae662973ff0f4d723050b185048f60837afbf4f26d95e84407bd5c1cf","original_node_id":"mwIQ","source_id":"22c9d5d53ac5acce3cef","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage9/22c9d5d53ac5acce3cef.html","source_sha256":"c756ac32ab2c956e4594d30d95b33af2de66660888cb16ffac449d185efc67d3","text":"Chapter 13","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[14]/a"}],"original_parent_paragraph_witness":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5","original_node_id":"mwHg","source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/69a3161f43fa4faec559.html","source_sha256":"a8309530ebd8e42a43647d90b4cd2967d3721fbf34eef686bea5a2096b8a3daa","text":{"$text_sha256":"e465f9d124d847eaf9ce79141aff49a246a302e0395dddebbd7913b38a4183d7"},"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[4]"},"original_supporting_note_proof_record_id":"private-eusebius-history-npnf2-1-next-note:69a3161f43fa4faec559:cite_note-11","original_transcription_heading_labels":[],"original_work_catalogue_memberships":[{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"bf575f58e965326f637a82474340240df1cf7dfba808a938081e4e898a1bd511"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"bf575f58e965326f637a82474340240df1cf7dfba808a938081e4e898a1bd511","original_node_id":"mwGg","source_id":"baf2f1439c97f48051fd","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage9/baf2f1439c97f48051fd.html","source_sha256":"df7f33f9e41dba1e8d70106b5ddf43d8a07a9973046301dc91acdffeab9558b1","text":"Book V","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[10]/a"}],"owner_verified_section_label":"Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.; original source section: Chapter 13","record_type":"indexed-source-passage","section_number_approved":false,"section_number_inferred_from_URL":false,"source_author_assignment_approved":true,"source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_paragraph_index":4,"source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_I/Church_History_of_Eusebius/Book_V/Chapter_13","work_catalogue_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_I/Church_History_of_Eusebius/Book_V"},"reference_proofs":[{"book":"ACT","book_context_end":1068,"book_context_start":1064,"chapter":21,"chapter_context_end":1072,"chapter_context_start":1069,"end":1075,"historical_native_verse_equivalence_reviewed":false,"index_label":"Editorial Bible reference / verse mention","numeric_coordinate_exists_in_WEB":true,"public_import_allowed":false,"semantic_exposition_reviewed":false,"source_notation":"Acts xxi. 9","start":1064,"verse_segment_end":1075,"verse_segment_start":1074,"verses":[9]}],"source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5"},"html_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5"},"source_html_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5","source_utf8_byte_end":53070,"source_utf8_byte_start":50429,"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[4]"},"source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/69a3161f43fa4faec559.html","source_record_file":"raw/review/patristic-bulk-parts/part009/paragraphs/69a3161f43fa4faec559.paragraphs.jsonl","source_record_file_sha256":"1f55a2474d233777cbff2e01f517137017b2952fc524834c55af0fa58a8c488e","source_record_id":"ancl:69a3161f43fa4faec559:p:4","source_sha256":"a8309530ebd8e42a43647d90b4cd2967d3721fbf34eef686bea5a2096b8a3daa","text_sha256":"e465f9d124d847eaf9ce79141aff49a246a302e0395dddebbd7913b38a4183d7","type":"bulk-source-dom"},"verified":true,"work":"Book V","work_id":"ws-npnf2-1-eusebius-history-22c9d5d53ac5acce3cef"}
{"author":"Eusebius of Caesarea (historical work attribution)","date_end":null,"date_label":"Date uncertain","date_start":null,"edition_year":1890,"edition_year_basis":"Original NPNF Series II Volume I title and copyright, 1890; transcription physical printing year unknown","id":"bulk-eusebius-history-npnf2-1-passage:ancl:69a3161f43fa4faec559:p:4","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"metadata_approval_pending":false,"original_note_proof_record_id":"private-eusebius-history-npnf2-1-next-note:69a3161f43fa4faec559:cite_note-11","public_import_allowed":true,"record_type":"indexed-source-passage","references":[{"book":"ACT","chapter":21,"kind":"citation","verse":9}],"section":"Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.; original source section: Chapter 13, source paragraph 4","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_I/Church_History_of_Eusebius/Book_V/Chapter_13#cite_note-11","translator":"Rev. Arthur Cushman McGiffert (Ph.D.)","verification":{"note":{"backlink_hrefs":["#cite_ref-11"],"body_html":{"$text_sha256":"1e481cd59190725904e46e41e73dd58d9cf295a6a360db168f5f83e7152ee9da"},"body_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[11]/span[2]","container_html":{"$text_sha256":"28309001cd1751f094056a2c6b7a32c39966696646d8eb825d1627435dfadaef"},"container_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[11]","id":"cite_note-11","marker_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[4]/sup[6]/a"},"original_work_coordinate":{"actual_original_callouts":[{"backlink_href":"#cite_ref-11","nearest_preceding_main_text_book_heading":null,"nearest_preceding_main_text_chapter_heading":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"0094cfb78030e5832c193fe2aea1567b9d662b4686093fc8d5866dc36fa138a6"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"0094cfb78030e5832c193fe2aea1567b9d662b4686093fc8d5866dc36fa138a6","original_node_id":"mwBA","source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/69a3161f43fa4faec559.html","source_sha256":"a8309530ebd8e42a43647d90b4cd2967d3721fbf34eef686bea5a2096b8a3daa","text":"Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[1]"},"nearest_preceding_main_text_section_heading":null,"nearest_preceding_transcription_book_heading":null,"nearest_preceding_transcription_chapter_heading":null,"nearest_preceding_transcription_section_heading":null,"original_callout":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"d4d63d8fb132d8836e54147fdd4a67ae640414ddaf50408b26afaa68a56d44bb"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"d4d63d8fb132d8836e54147fdd4a67ae640414ddaf50408b26afaa68a56d44bb","original_node_id":"cite_ref-11","source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/69a3161f43fa4faec559.html","source_sha256":"a8309530ebd8e42a43647d90b4cd2967d3721fbf34eef686bea5a2096b8a3daa","text":"","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[4]/sup[6]"}}],"ancient_author_assignment_approved":true,"author_assignment_basis":{"original_author_translation_credit":{"original_text":"THE CHURCH HISTORY OF EUSEBIUS, \n\n\nTRANSLATED WITH PROLEGOMENA AND NOTES \n\nBY \n\nTHE REV. ARTHUR CUSHMAN McGIFFERT, Ph.D., \n\nPROFESSOR OF CHURCH HISTORY IN LANE THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY, CINCINNATI.","sha256":"08b9399b8b0ebc3317bc414aa222f45edfeb99f5ccf06614773fd6065315ae91","source_path":"raw/research/anf-npnf/archive/selectlibraryofn18901scha.ocr.txt","source_sha256":"830863b4b98bfb54a69b8fdd1e0081bb1b3e4d3df22f1770c99de277e9dd9d2f","utf8_byte_end":2046,"utf8_byte_start":1816},"original_work_memberships":[{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"bf575f58e965326f637a82474340240df1cf7dfba808a938081e4e898a1bd511"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"bf575f58e965326f637a82474340240df1cf7dfba808a938081e4e898a1bd511","original_node_id":"mwGg","source_id":"baf2f1439c97f48051fd","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage9/baf2f1439c97f48051fd.html","source_sha256":"df7f33f9e41dba1e8d70106b5ddf43d8a07a9973046301dc91acdffeab9558b1","text":"Book V","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[10]/a"}],"scope":"Historical compiler and work attribution only; quoted letter writers and speakers and individual exposition remain unreviewed. Historical English editorial notes separately attributed."},"book_number_approved":false,"book_number_inferred_from_URL":false,"chapter_number_approved":false,"chapter_number_inferred_from_URL":false,"chapter_uncertain":false,"native_paragraph_number_prefix":null,"note_id":"cite_note-11","original_ancestor_location_witnesses":[],"original_main_text_heading_labels":["Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion."],"original_page_catalogue_memberships":[{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"1774a04ae662973ff0f4d723050b185048f60837afbf4f26d95e84407bd5c1cf"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"1774a04ae662973ff0f4d723050b185048f60837afbf4f26d95e84407bd5c1cf","original_node_id":"mwIQ","source_id":"22c9d5d53ac5acce3cef","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage9/22c9d5d53ac5acce3cef.html","source_sha256":"c756ac32ab2c956e4594d30d95b33af2de66660888cb16ffac449d185efc67d3","text":"Chapter 13","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[14]/a"}],"original_parent_paragraph_witness":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5","original_node_id":"mwHg","source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/69a3161f43fa4faec559.html","source_sha256":"a8309530ebd8e42a43647d90b4cd2967d3721fbf34eef686bea5a2096b8a3daa","text":{"$text_sha256":"e465f9d124d847eaf9ce79141aff49a246a302e0395dddebbd7913b38a4183d7"},"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[4]"},"original_supporting_note_proof_record_id":"private-eusebius-history-npnf2-1-next-note:69a3161f43fa4faec559:cite_note-11","original_transcription_heading_labels":[],"original_work_catalogue_memberships":[{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"bf575f58e965326f637a82474340240df1cf7dfba808a938081e4e898a1bd511"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"bf575f58e965326f637a82474340240df1cf7dfba808a938081e4e898a1bd511","original_node_id":"mwGg","source_id":"baf2f1439c97f48051fd","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage9/baf2f1439c97f48051fd.html","source_sha256":"df7f33f9e41dba1e8d70106b5ddf43d8a07a9973046301dc91acdffeab9558b1","text":"Book V","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[10]/a"}],"owner_verified_section_label":"Chapter XIII.—Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.; original source section: Chapter 13","record_type":"indexed-source-passage","section_number_approved":false,"section_number_inferred_from_URL":false,"source_author_assignment_approved":true,"source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_paragraph_index":4,"source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_I/Church_History_of_Eusebius/Book_V/Chapter_13","work_catalogue_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_I/Church_History_of_Eusebius/Book_V"},"reference_proofs":[{"book":"ACT","book_context_end":1068,"book_context_start":1064,"chapter":21,"chapter_context_end":1072,"chapter_context_start":1069,"end":1075,"historical_native_verse_equivalence_reviewed":false,"index_label":"Editorial Bible reference / verse mention","numeric_coordinate_exists_in_WEB":true,"public_import_allowed":false,"semantic_exposition_reviewed":false,"source_notation":"Acts xxi. 9","start":1064,"verse_segment_end":1075,"verse_segment_start":1074,"verses":[9]}],"source_id":"69a3161f43fa4faec559","source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5"},"html_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5"},"source_html_sha256":"23184591b5e471597b0a35cf999561958a350a72cb9030b0a161073aa5a916e5","source_utf8_byte_end":53070,"source_utf8_byte_start":50429,"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[4]"},"source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/69a3161f43fa4faec559.html","source_record_file":"raw/review/patristic-bulk-parts/part009/paragraphs/69a3161f43fa4faec559.paragraphs.jsonl","source_record_file_sha256":"1f55a2474d233777cbff2e01f517137017b2952fc524834c55af0fa58a8c488e","source_record_id":"ancl:69a3161f43fa4faec559:p:4","source_sha256":"a8309530ebd8e42a43647d90b4cd2967d3721fbf34eef686bea5a2096b8a3daa","text_sha256":"e465f9d124d847eaf9ce79141aff49a246a302e0395dddebbd7913b38a4183d7","type":"bulk-source-dom"},"verified":true,"work":"Book V","work_id":"ws-npnf2-1-eusebius-history-22c9d5d53ac5acce3cef"}