Every degree of benevolence, from the least to the greatest, must be altogether optional. Perfect rectitude, with
respect to created beings, and each individual creature, may subsist, without any more benevolence than what
is necessarily included in mere existence. 10. This being the case, the state of the universe, in reference to perfect
rectitude, and irrespective of benevolence, may be further compared to a balance in perfect equilibrium. The
least weight of benevolence makes it preponderate, proportionally, in favour of virtue and happiness; but without
which weight neither could take place. 11. But, according to what has been said in a former note, every created
being is the subject of passive power; which, with respect to its influence on the creature, is, in some respect, the
opposite of benevolence. In some, not in all respects. Benevolence is an exercise of will, and implies an agent;
but passive power is a quality or principle inseparable from every creature, and from the universe at large. In
reference to a former illustration, this may be compared to another cone exactly opposite, the vertex of which,
from below, meets that of the other in the same plane. The intermediate point, and Indeed every point in the
same plane, may represent the perfect rectitude of God towards every individual; the inverted cone above, divine
benevolence; the cone below, passive power, with its base necessarily equal to the whole plane, as it respects the
created universe. 12. Hence we may say that the neutral state of any being is placed in the plane; his degree of
influence from passive power, the predisposing cause of vice, is represented by a corresponding given part of
the cone below; and his degree of predisposition to virtue from divine benevolence, is represented by a corres-
ponding given part of the cone above. Or, to change the comparison, if a perfectly poised balance be made to
represent perfect rectitude, then we may suppose weights at each end in all possible proportions, from the
smallest to the greatest. Passive power not being the effect of will, but of the relative nature of things, and insep-
arably connected with one end of the balance, it is evident, that it can be counteracted in its tendency only by
the weight of benevolence, or sovereign pleasure. Therefore, whoever on earth or in heaven, rises to, and is
confirmed in virtue, his attainment must be the effect of mere benevolence. And whoever on earth, or in hell,
falls into, and is confirmed in vice, bis deterioration must be the effect of passive power, as the predisposing
cause of vice, which nothing in the universe can counteract but sovereign, free, unmerited benevolence. 13.
Consequently, all the good and happiness in the universe is the effect of benevolence, or sovereign pleasure, and
exists above the plane of perfect rectitude; but all the evil and misery in the world is the effect of passive power,
in union with free agency, and exists below the plane of rectitude. The one generates virtue, and raises to happiness
and heaven; the other generates vice, and sinks to misery and hell. 14. Every thing in the universe planned, decreed,
and effected by Jehovah, is a structure of benevolence. All he effects is good, and only good. The evil that exists
is not his work. Benevolence has decreed an endless chain of antecedents, including the natural and moral
worlds; and the consequents peculiar to them result therefrom with infallible certainty. But other antecedents,
in this world, and in hell, are constantly interposed by free agents under the influence of passive power, whose
consequences also follow with equal Infallible certainty. To the eye of created intelligence these counter positions,
and opposite consequents, appear blended in an inextricable manner, like the different rays of light in the same
pencil, different gasses in a given space, and different subtle fluids in the same body. But to the eye of Omniscience
they appear perfectly distinct, in their proper nature, in all their directions and bearings, in all their tendencies
and effects. 15. Instead, therefore, of saying, “There is no evil in the universe,” we should say, “There is much
evil in the universe; there is much on earth, and more in hell; but none of God’s appointment.” It is demonstrable,
that passive power can no more be an object of appointment, than the most direct contradictions; and yet it is
740
SECTION IX. Concerning that objection against the doctrine which has been…