has been marked either with greater earnestness or indifference, according to the goodness
or badness of their nature, and not to any partiality on the part of the Disposer. But that
this may more easily be shown to be the case with heavenly beings, let us borrow an illustra-
tion from what either has been done or is done among men, in order that from visible things
we may, by way of consequence, behold also things invisible.
Paul and Peter are undoubtedly proved to have been men of a spiritual nature. When,
therefore, Paul is found to have acted contrary to religion, in having persecuted the Church
of God, and Peter to have committed so grave a sin as, when questioned by the maid-servant,
to have asserted with an oath that he did not know who Christ was, how is it possible that
these—who, according to those persons of whom we speak, were spiritual beings—should
fall into sins of such a nature, especially as they are frequently in the habit of saying that a
good tree cannot bring forth evil fruits? And if a good tree cannot produce evil fruit, and
as, according to them, Peter and Paul were sprung from the root of a good tree, how should
they be deemed to have brought forth fruits so wicked? And if they should return the answer
which is generally invented, that it was not Paul who persecuted, but some other person, I
know not whom, who was in Paul; and that it was not Peter who uttered the denial, but
some other individual in him; how should Paul say, if he had not sinned, that “I am not
worthy to be called an apostle, because I persecuted the Church of God?” 2063 Or why did
Peter weep most bitterly, if it were another than he who sinned? From which all their silly
assertions will be proved to be baseless.
3. According to our view, there is no rational creature which is not capable both of
good and evil. But it does not follow, that because we say there is no nature which may not
admit evil, we therefore maintain that every nature has admitted evil, i.e., has become wicked.
As we may say that the nature of every man admits of his being a sailor, but it does not follow
from that, that every man will become so; or, again, it is possible for every one to learn
grammar or medicine, but it is not therefore proved that every man is either a physician or
a grammarian; so, if we say that there is no nature which may not admit evil, it is not neces-
sarily indicated that it has done so. For, in our view, not even the devil himself was incapable
of good; but although capable of admitting good, he did not therefore also desire it, or make
266
any effort after virtue. For, as we are taught by those quotations which we adduced from
the prophets, there was once a time when he was good, when he walked in the paradise of
God between the cherubim. As he, then, possessed the power either of receiving good or
evil, but fell away from a virtuous course, and turned to evil with all the powers of his mind,
so also other creatures, as having a capacity for either condition, in the exercise of the freedom
of their will, flee from evil, and cleave to good. There is no nature, then, which may not
admit of good or evil, except the nature of God—the fountain of all good things—and of
2063 1 Cor. xv. 9.
611
On the Angels.