§3.
The
Persecution of Diocletian.
In this delightful circle and
engaged in such congenial tasks, the time must have passed very happily
for Eusebius, until, in 303, the terrible persecution of Diocletian
broke upon the Church almost like a thunderbolt out of a clear sky. The
causes of the sudden change of policy on Diocletian’s part, and
the terrible havoc wrought in the Church, it is not my intention to
discuss here (see below, Bk. VIII. chap. 2, note 3 sq.). We are
concerned with the persecution only in so far as it bears upon the
present subject. In the first year of the persecution Procopius, the
first martyr of Palestine, was put to death at Cæsarea
(Eusebius’
Martyrs of Palestine,
Cureton’s ed. p.
4), and from that time on that city, which was an important Christian
center, was the scene of a tempest which raged with greater or less
violence, and with occasional cessations, for seven years. Eusebius
himself was an eyewitness of many martyrdoms there, of which he gives
us an account in his
Martyrs of Palestine
. The little circle
which surrounded Pamphilus did not escape. In the third year of the
persecution (
Mart. of Pal
. p. 12 sq.) a youth named Apphianus,
or Epiphanius (the former is given in the Greek text, the latter in the
Syriac), who “resided in the same house with us, confirming
himself in godly doctrine, and being instructed by that perfect martyr,
Pamphilus” (as Eusebius says), committed an act of fanatical
daring which caused his arrest and martyrdom. It seems that without the
knowledge of his friends, concealing his design even from those who
dwelt in the same house with him, he laid hold of the hand of the
governor, Arbanus, who was upon the point of sacrificing, and
endeavored to dissuade him from offering to “lifeless idols and
wicked devils.” His arrest was of course the natural consequence,
and he had the glory of witnessing a good profession and suffering a
triumphant death. Although Eusebius speaks with such admiration of his
conduct, it is quite significant of the attitude of himself, and of
most of the circle of which he was one, that Apphianus felt obliged to
conceal his purpose from them. He doubtless feared that they would not
permit him to perform the rash act which he meditated, and we may
conclude from that, that the circle in the main was governed by the
precepts of good common sense, and avoided that fanaticism which so
frequently led men, as in the present case it led Apphianus, to expose
themselves needlessly, and even to court martyrdom. It is plain enough
from what we know of Eusebius’ general character that he himself
was too sensible to act in that way. It is true that he speaks with
admiration of Apphianus’ conduct, and in
H. E
. VIII. 5, of
the equally rash procedure of a Nicomedian Christian; but that does not
imply that he considered their course the wisest one, and that he would
not rather recommend the employment of all proper and honorable
precautions for the preservation of life. Indeed, in
H. E.
IV.
15, he speaks with evident approval of the prudent course pursued by
Polycarp in preserving his life so long as he could without violating
his Christian profession, and with manifest disapproval of the rash act
of the Phrygian Quintus, who presumptuously courted martyrdom, only to
fail when the test itself came. Pamphilus also possessed too much sound
Christian sense to advocate any such fanaticism, or to practice it
himself, as is plain enough from the fact that he was not arrested
until the fifth year of the persecution. This unhealthy temper of mind
in the midst of persecution was indeed almost universally condemned by
the wisest men of the Church, and yet the boldness and the very
rashness of those who thus voluntarily and needlessly threw their lives
away excited widespread admiration and too often a degree
of commendation which
served only to promote a wider growth of the same unhealthy
sentiment.
In the fifth year of the
persecution Pamphilus was arrested and thrown into prison, where he
remained for two years, when he finally, in the seventh year of the
persecution, suffered martyrdom with eleven others, some of whom were
his disciples and members of his own household. (
Pal. Mart.
Cureton’s ed. p. 36 sq.;
H. E.
App. chap. 11.) During the
two years of Pamphilus’ imprisonment Eusebius spent a great deal
of time with him, and the two together composed five books of an
Apology for Origen
, to which Eusebius afterward added a sixth
(see below, p. 36). Danz (p. 37) assumes that Eusebius was imprisoned
with Pamphilus, which is not an unnatural supposition when we consider
how much they must have been together to compose the
Apology
as
they did. There is, however, no other evidence that he was thus
imprisoned, and in the face of Eusebius’ own silence it is safer
perhaps to assume (with most historians) that he simply visited
Pamphilus in his prison. How it happened that Pamphilus and so many of
his followers were imprisoned and martyred, while Eusebius escaped, we
cannot tell. In his
Martyrs of Palestine
, chap. 11, he states
that Pamphilus was the only one of the company of twelve martyrs that
was a presbyter of the Cæsarean church; and from the fact that he
nowhere mentions the martyrdom of others of the presbyters, we may
conclude that they all escaped. It is not surprising, therefore, that
Eusebius should have done the same. Nevertheless, it is somewhat
difficult to understand how he could come and go so frequently without
being arrested and condemned to a like fate with the others. It is
possible that he possessed friends among the authorities whose
influence procured his safety. This supposition finds some support in
the fact that he had made the acquaintance of Constantine (the Greek in
Vita Const
. I. 19 has
žγνωμεν
,
which implies, as Danz remarks, that he not only saw, but that he
became acquainted with Constantine) some years before in Cæsarea.
He could hardly have made his acquaintance unless he had some friend
among the high officials of the city. Influential family connections
may account in part also for the position of prominence which he later
acquired at the imperial court of Constantine. If he had friends in
authority in Cæsarea during the persecution his exemption from
arrest is satisfactorily accounted for. It has been supposed by some
that Eusebius denied the faith during the terrible persecution, or that
he committed some other questionable and compromising act of
concession, and thus escaped martyrdom. In support of this is urged the
fact that in 335, at the council of Tyre, Potamo, bishop of Heraclea,
in Egypt, addressed Eusebius in the following words: “Dost thou
sit as judge, O Eusebius; and is Athanasius, innocent as he is, judged
by thee? Who can bear such things? Pray tell me, wast thou not with me
in prison during the persecution? And I lost an eye in behalf of the
truth, but thou appearest to have received no bodily injury, neither
hast thou suffered martyrdom, but thou hast remained alive with no
mutilation. How wast thou released from prison unless thou didst
promise those that put upon us the pressure of persecution to do that
which is unlawful, or didst actually do it?” Eusebius, it seems,
did not deny the charge, but simply rose in anger and dismissed the
council with the words, “If ye come hither and make such
accusations against us, then do your accusers speak the truth. For if
ye tyrannize here, much more do ye in your own country” (Epiphan.
Hær
. LXVIII. 8). It must be noticed, however, that Potamo
does not directly charge Eusebius with dishonorable conduct, he simply
conjectures that he must have acted dishonorably in order to escape
punishment; as if every one who was imprisoned with Potamo must have
suffered as he did! As Stroth suggests, it is quite possible that his
peculiarly excitable and violent temperament was one of the causes of
his own loss. He evidently in any case had no knowledge of unworthy
conduct on Eusebius’ part, nor had any one else so far as we can
judge. For in that age of bitter controversy, when men’s
characters were drawn by their opponents in the blackest lines,
Eusebius must have suffered at the hands of the Athanasian party if it
had been known that he had acted a cowardly part in the persecution.
Athanasius himself refers to this incident (
Contra Arian.
VIII.
1), but he only says that Eusebius was “accused of
sacrificing,” he does
not venture to affirm that he
did sacrifice; and thus it is evident that he knew nothing of such an
act. Moreover, he never calls Eusebius “the sacrificer,” as
he does Asterius, and as he would have been sure to do had he possessed
evidence which warranted him in making the accusation (cf. Lightfoot,
p. 311). Still further, Eusebius’ subsequent election to the
episcopate of Cæsarea, where his character and his conduct during
the persecution must have been well known, and his appointment in later
life to the important see of Antioch, forbid the supposition that he
had ever acted a cowardly part in time of persecution. And finally, it
is psychologically impossible that Eusebius could have written works so
full of comfort for, and sympathy with, the suffering confessors, and
could have spoken so openly and in such strong terms of condemnation of
the numerous defections that occurred during the persecution, if he was
conscious of his own guilt. It is quite possible, as remarked above,
that influential friends protected him without any act of compromise on
his part; or, supposing him to have been imprisoned with Potamo, it may
be, as Lightfoot suggests, that the close of the persecution brought
him his release as it did so many others. For it would seem natural to
refer that imprisonment to the latter part of the persecution, when in
all probability he visited Egypt, which was the home of Potamo. We must
in any case vindicate Eusebius from the unfounded charge of cowardice
and apostasy; and we ask, with Cave, “If every accusation against
any man at any time were to be believed, who would be
guiltless?”
From his
History
and his
Martyrs in Palestine
we learn that Eusebius was for much of the
time in the very thick of the fight, and was an eyewitness of numerous
martyrdoms not only in Palestine, but also in Tyre and in
Egypt.
The date of his visits to the
latter places (
H. E.
VIII. 7, 9) cannot be determined with
exactness. They are described in connection with what seem to be the
earlier events of the persecution, and yet it is by no means certain
that chronological order has been observed in the narratives. The
mutilation of prisoners—such as Potamo suffered—seems to
have become common only in the year 308 and thereafter (see
Mason’s
Persecution of Diocletian,
p. 281), and hence if
Eusebius was imprisoned with Potamo during his visit to Egypt, as seems
most probable, there would be some reason for assigning that visit to
the later years of the persecution. In confirmation of this might be
urged the improbability that he would leave Cæsarea while
Pamphilus was still alive, either before or after the latter’s
imprisonment, and still further his own statement in
H. E.
VII.
32, that he had observed Meletius escaping the fury of the persecution
for seven years in Palestine. It is therefore likely that Eusebius did
not make his journey to Egypt, which must have occupied some time,
until toward the very end of the persecution, when it raged there with
exceeding fierceness during the brief outburst of the infamous
Maximin.