Book
V.
Wherein Tertullian proves, with respect
to St. Paul’s epistles, what he had proved in the preceding book
with respect to St. Luke’s gospel. Far from being at variance,
they were in perfect unison with the writings of the Old Testament, and
therefore testified that the Creator was the only God, and that the
Lord Jesus was his Christ. As in the preceding books, Tertullian
supports his argument with profound reasoning, and many happy
illustrations of Holy Scripture.
————————————
Chapter I.—Introductory. The
Apostle Paul Himself Not the Preacher of a New God. Called by
Jesus Christ, Although After the Other Apostles, His Mission Was from
the Creator. States How. The Argument, as in the Case of the Gospel,
Confining Proofs to Such Portions of St. Paul’s Writings as
Marcion Allowed.
There
is nothing without a
beginning but God alone. Now, inasmuch as the beginning occupies the
first place in the condition of all things, so it must necessarily take
precedence in the treatment of them, if a clear knowledge is to be
arrived at concerning their condition; for you could not find the means
of examining even the quality of anything, unless you were certain of
its existence, and that after discovering its origin.
5192
Since therefore I am brought, in the course
of my little work, to this point,
5193
I require to
know of Marcion the origin of his apostle
5194
even—I, who am to some degree a new disciple,
5195
the follower of no other master; who at the
same time
5196
can believe
nothing, except that nothing ought to be believed hastily
5197
(and
that
I may further say is
hastily believed, which is believed without any examination
5198
of its beginning); in short, I who have the
best reason possible for bringing this inquiry to a most careful
solution,
5199
since a man is
affirmed to me to be an apostle whom I do not find mentioned in the
Gospel in the catalogue
5200
of the apostles.
Indeed, when I hear that this man was chosen by the Lord after He had
attained His rest in heaven, I feel that a kind of improvidence is
imputable to Christ, for not knowing before that this man was necessary
to Him; and because He thought that he must be added to the apostolic
body in the way of a fortuitous encounter
5201
rather than a deliberate selection; by necessity (so to speak), and not
voluntary choice, although the members of the apostolate had been duly
ordained, and were now dismissed to their several missions.
Where
fore, O
shipmaster of Pontus,
5202
if you have never
taken on board your small craft
5203
any contraband
goods or smuggler’s cargo, if you have never thrown overboard or
tampered with a freight, you are still more careful and conscientious,
I doubt not, in divine things; and so I should be glad if you would
inform us under what bill of lading
5204
you admitted
the Apostle Paul on board, who ticketed him,
5205
what owner forwarded him,
5206
who handed him to
you,
5207
that so you may land him without any
misgiving,
5208
lest he should turn
out to belong to him,
5209
who can
substantiate his claim to him by producing all his apostolic
writings.
5210
He professes
himself to be “an apostle”—to use his own
words—“not of men, nor by man, but by Jesus
Christ.”
5211
Of course, any one
may make a profession concerning himself; but his profession is only
rendered valid by the authority of a second person. One man signs,
another countersigns;
5212
one man appends his
seal, another registers in the public records.
5213
No
one is at once a proposer and a seconder to himself. Besides, you have
read, no doubt, that “many shall come, saying, I am
Christ.”
5214
Now if any one can
pretend that he is Christ, how much more might a man profess to be an
apostle of Christ! But still, for my own part, I appear
5215
in the character of a disciple and an
inquirer; that so I may even thus
5216
both refute
your belief, who have nothing to support it, and confound your
shamelessness, who make claims without possessing the means of
establishing them. Let there be a Christ, let there be an apostle,
although of another god;
but what matter?
since they are only to
draw their proofs out of the Testament of the Creator. Because even the
book of Genesis so long ago promised me
the Apostle
Paul. For
among the types and prophetic blessings which he pronounced over his
sons, Jacob, when he turned his attention to Benjamin, exclaimed,
“Benjamin shall ravin as a wolf; in the morning he shall devour
the prey, and at night he shall impart nourishment.”
5217
He foresaw that Paul would arise out of the
tribe of Benjamin, a voracious wolf, devouring his prey in the morning:
in order words, in the early period of his life he would devastate the
Lord’s sheep, as a persecutor of the churches; but in the evening
he would give them nourishment, which means that in his declining years
he would educate the fold of Christ, as the teacher of the Gentiles.
Then, again, in Saul’s conduct towards David, exhibited first in
violent persecution of him, and then in remorse and
reparation,
5218
on his receiving
from him good for evil, we have nothing else than an
anticipation
5219
of Paul in
Saul—belonging, too, as they did, to the same tribe—and of
Jesus in David, from whom He descended according to the Virgin’s
genealogy.
5220
Should you,
however, disapprove of these types,
5221
the Acts of
the Apostles,
5222
at all events, have
handed down to me this career of Paul, which you must not refuse to
accept. Thence I demonstrate that from a persecutor he became “an
apostle, not of men, neither by man;”
5223
thence am I led to believe
the Apostle
himself; thence do I find
reason for rejecting your defence of him,
5224
and for bearing fearlessly your taunt. “Then you deny the
Apostle Paul.” I do not calumniate him whom I
defend.
5225
I deny him, to
compel you to the proof of him. I deny him, to convince you that he is
mine. If you have regard to our belief you should admit the particulars
which comprise it. If you challenge us to your belief, (pray) tell us
what things constitute its basis.
5226
Either prove
the truth of what you believe, or failing in your proof, (tell us) how
you believe. Else what conduct is yours,
5227
believing in opposition to Him from whom alone comes the proof of that
which you believe? Take now from my point of view
5228
the apostle, in the same manner as you have
received the Christ—the apostle shown to be as much
mine
as the Christ is. And here, too, we will fight within the same lines,
and challenge our
adversary on the mere ground of a simple
rule,
5229
that even an apostle who is said not to
belong to the Creator—nay, is displayed as in actual hostility to
the Creator—can be fairly regarded as teaching
5230
nothing, knowing nothing, wishing nothing in
favour of the Creator whilst it would be a first principle with him to
set forth
5231
another god with as
much eagerness as he would use in withdrawing us from the law of the
Creator. It is not at all likely that he would call men away from
Judaism without showing them at the same time what was the god in whom
he invited them to believe; because nobody could possibly pass from
allegiance to the Creator without knowing to whom he had to cross over.
For either Christ had already revealed another god—in which case
the apostle’s testimony would also follow to the same effect, for
fear of his not being else regarded
5232
as an apostle
of the god whom Christ had revealed, and because of the impropriety of
his being concealed by the apostle who had been already revealed by
Christ—or Christ had made no such revelation concerning God;
then
there was all the greater need why the apostle should
reveal a God who could now be made known by no one else, and who would
undoubtedly be left without any belief at all, if he were revealed not
even by an apostle. We have laid down this as our first principle,
because we wish at once to profess that we shall pursue the same method
here in the apostle’s case as we adopted before in Christ’s
case, to prove that he proclaimed no new god;
5233
that is, we shall draw our evidence from the epistles of
St.
Paul himself. Now, the garbled form in which we have found the
heretic’s Gospel will have already prepared us to expect to
find
5234
the epistles also mutilated by him with like
perverseness—and that even as respects their number.
5235
5192
Cum cognoveris unde
sit.
5193
Materiam.
5194
We have already
more than once referred to Marcion’s preference for
St.
Paul
. “The reason of the preference thus given to that
apostle was his constant and strenuous opposition to the Judaizing
Christians, who wished to reimpose the yoke of the Jewish ceremonies on
the necks of their brethren. This opposition the Marcionites
wished to construe into a direct denial of the authority of the Mosaic
law. They contended also from St. Paul’s assertion, that he
received his appointment to the apostolic office not from man, but from
Christ, that he alone delivered the genuine doctrines of the gospel.
This deference for St. Paul accounts also for Marcion’s accepting
St. Luke’s
Gospel as the only authentic one, as we saw in
the last book of this treatise; it was because that evangelist had been
the companion of St. Paul” (Bp. Kaye,
On the Writings of
Tertullian
, 3d edition, pp. 474–475).
5195
Novus aliqui
discipulus.
5196
Interim.
5197
Temere.
5198
Agnitione.
5199
Ad sollicitudinem.
5200
In albo.
5201
Ex incursu: in
allusion to St. Paul’s sudden conversion,
Acts ix. 3–8
. [On
St. Paul’s Epistles, see p. 324,
supra.
]
5202
Marcion is
frequently called “
Ponticus Nauclerus
,” probably
less on account of his own connection with a seafaring life, than that
of his countrymen, who were great sailors. Comp. book. i. 18.
(
sub fin
.) and book iii. 6. [pp. 284, 325.]
5203
In acatos tuas.
5204
Quo symbolo.
5205
Quis illum tituli
charactere percusserit.
5206
Quis transmiserit
tibi.
5207
Quis imposuerit.
5208
Constanter.
5209
Ne
illius
probetur, i.e., to the
Catholic
, for Marcion did
not admit all St. Paul’s epistles (Semler).
5210
Omnia apostolatus ejus
instrumenta.
5211
Gal. i. 1
.
5212
Subscribit.
5213
Actis refert.
5214
Luke xxi. 8
.
5215
Conversor.
5216
Jam hinc.
5217
Gen. xlix. 27
, Septuagint, the latter clause being
καὶ εἰς
τὸ ἑσπέρας
δίδωσι
τροφήν
.
5218
Satisfactio.
5219
Non aliud portendebat
quam.
5220
Secundum Virginis
censum.
5221
Figurarum
sacramenta.
5222
Although
St.
Luke
wrote the Acts of the Apostles, Marcion does not seem to have
admitted this book into his New Testament. “It is clearly
excluded from his catalogue, as given by Epiphanius. The same thing
appears from the more ancient authority of Tertullian, who begins his
Book v. against Marcion with showing the absurdity of his conduct in
rejecting the history and acts of the apostles, and yet receiving St.
Paul as the chief of the apostles, whose name is never mentioned in the
Gospel with the other apostles, especially since the account given by
Paul himself in
Gal.
i.–ii
. confirms
the account which we have in the Acts. But the reason why he rejected
this book is (as Tertullian says) very evident, since from it we can
plainly show that the God of the Christians and the God of the Jews, or
the Creator, was the same being and that Christ was sent by Him, and by
no other” (Lardner’s Works,
Hist. of Heretics
, chap.
x. sec. 41).
5223
Gal. i. 1
.
5224
Inde te a defensione
ejus expello.
5225
An insinuation that
Marcion’s defence of Paul was, in fact, a calumny of the
apostle.
5226
Præstruant
eam.
5227
Qualis es.
5228
Habe nunc de meo.
5229
In ipso gradu
præscriptionis.
5230
Oportere
docere…sapere…velle.
5231
Edicere.
5232
Ne non haberetur.
5233
Nullum alium deum
circumlatum.
5234
Præjudicasse
debebit.
5235
Marcion only
received
ten
of St. Paul’s epistles, and these altered by
himself.