Chapter 20.—That It is as
Shameful for the Virtues to Serve Human Glory as Bodily
Pleasure.
Philosophers,—who place the end
of human good in virtue itself, in order to put to shame certain
other philosophers, who indeed approve of the virtues, but measure
them all with reference to the end of bodily pleasure, and think
that this pleasure is to be sought for its own sake, but the
virtues on account of pleasure,—are wont to paint a kind of
word-picture, in which Pleasure sits like a luxurious queen on a
royal seat, and all the virtues are subjected to her as slaves,
watching her nod, that they may do whatever she shall command.
She commands Prudence to be ever on the watch to discover how
Pleasure may rule, and be safe. Justice she orders to grant what
benefits she can, in order to secure those friendships which are
necessary for bodily pleasure; to do wrong to no one, lest, on
account of the breaking of the laws, Pleasure be not able to live
in security. Fortitude she orders to keep her mistress, that is,
Pleasure, bravely in her mind, if any affliction befall her body
which does not occasion death, in order that by remembrance of
former delights she may mitigate the poignancy of present pain.
Temperance she commands to take only a certain quantity even of the
most favorite food, lest, through immoderate use, anything prove
hurtful by disturbing the health of the body, and thus Pleasure,
which the Epicureans make to consist chiefly in the health of the
body, be grievously offended. Thus the virtues, with the whole
dignity of their glory, will be the slaves of Pleasure, as of some
imperious and disreputable woman.
There is nothing, say our
philosophers, more disgraceful and monstrous than this picture, and
which the eyes of good men can less endure. And they say the
truth. But I do not think that the picture would be sufficiently
becoming, even if it were made so that the virtues should be
represented as the slaves of human glory; for, though that glory be
not a luxurious woman, it is nevertheless puffed up, and has much
vanity in it. Wherefore it is unworthy of the solidity and
firmness of the virtues to represent them as serving this glory, so
that Prudence shall provide nothing, Justice distribute nothing,
Temperance moderate nothing, except to the end that men may be
pleased and vain glory served. Nor will they be able to defend
themselves from the charge of such baseness, whilst they, by way of
being despisers of glory, disregard the judgment of other men, seem
to themselves wise, and please themselves. For their
virtue,—if, indeed, it is virtue at all,—is only in another way
subjected to human praise; for he who seeks to please himself seeks
still to please man. But he who, with true piety towards God,
whom he loves, believes, and hopes in, fixes his attention more on
those things in which he displeases himself, than on those things,
if there are any such, which please himself, or rather, not
himself, but the truth, does not attribute that by which he can now
please the truth to anything but to the mercy of Him whom he has
feared to displease, giving thanks for what in him is healed, and
pouring out prayers for the healing of that which is yet
unhealed.