§9. In charging Basil with not defending his faith at the time of the ‘Trials,’ he lays himself
open to the same charge.
He hints at a certain locality where this trial for heresy took place; but he gives us no
certain indication where it was, and the reader is obliged to guess in the dark. Thither, he
tells us, a congress of picked representatives from all quarters was summoned; and he is at
his best here, placing before our eyes with some vigorous strokes the preparation of the
event which he pretends took place. Then, he says, a trial in which he would have had to
run for his very life was put into the hands of certain arbitrators, to whom our Teacher and
Master who was present gave his charge84; and as all the voting power was thus won over
to the enemies’ side, he yielded the position85, fled from the place, and hunted everywhere
for some hearth and home; and he is great, in this graphic sketch86, in arraigning the cow-
ardice of our hero; as any one who likes may see by looking at what he has written. But I
cannot stop to give specimens here of the bitter gall of his utterances; I must pass on to that,
for the sake of which I mentioned all this.
Where, then, was that unnamed spot in which this examination of his teachings was to
take place? What was this occasion when the best then were collected for a trial? Who were
these men who hurried over land and sea to share in these labours? What was this ‘expectant
world that hung upon the issue of the voting?’ Who was ‘the arranger of the trial?’ However,
let us consider that he invented all that to swell out the importance of his story, as boys at
school are apt to do in their fictitious conversations of this kind; and let him only tell us
who that ‘terrible combatant’ was whom our Master shrunk from encountering. If this also
is a fiction, let him be the winner again, and have the advantage of his vain words. We will
say nothing: in the useless fight with shadows the real victory is to decline conquering in
that. But if he speaks of the events at Constantinople and means the assembly there, and is
in this fever of literary indignation at tragedies enacted there, and means himself by that
great and redoubtable athlete, then we would display the reasons why, though present on
the occasion, we did not plunge into the fight.
44
Now let this man who upbraids that hero with his cowardice tell us whether he went
down into the thick of the fray, whether he uttered one syllable in defence of his own ortho-
doxy, whether he made any vigorous peroration, whether he victoriously grappled with the
84 ὑποφωνεῖν
85 Sozomen (vi. 26): “After his (Eunomius) elevation to the bishopric of Cyzicus he was accused by his own
clergy of introducing innovations. Eudoxius obliged him to undergo a public trial and give an account of his
doctrines to the people: finding, however, no fault in him, Eudoxius exhorted him to return to Cyzicus. He
replied he could not remain with people who regarded him with suspicion, and it is said seized this opportunity
to secede from communion.”
86 ὑπογραφῇ; or else ‘on the subject of Basil’s charge.’
In charging Basil with not defending his faith at the time of the 'Trials,' he lays himself open to the same charge.
79
In charging Basil with not defending his faith at the time of the 'Trials,'…