wickedness, takes notice that the apostle observes, it will be so, that they which are approved,
might be made manifest: and says Mr. W. upon it, evil and unsanctified men, by such sins,
will discover their hypocrisy.
Now seeing this is the case with moral sincerity and common religion, how can it be a
qualification for a standing privilege ? Nothing can be a fitness for a durable privilege, but
a durable qualification. For no qualification has any fitness or adaptedness for more than it
extends to; as a short scabbard cannot be fit for a long sword. If a man going a journey in
the night, needs a lamp to light him in his way, who will pretend that a flaming wick without
oil, which will last but a few rods, is fit for his purpose ? Or if a man were building a house
for himself and family, should he put into the frame pieces of timber known to be of such
a nature as that they would probably be rotten in a few months; or should he take blocks of
ice, instead of hewn stone, because during a present cold season they seemed to be hard and
firm; and withal should for a covering put only leaves that will soon fade away, instead of
tiles or shingles, that are solid and lasting; would not every spectator ridicule his folly?
If it should be said, that unsanctified men, when they lose their moral sincerity, may be
cast out again: this is far from helping the case, or showing that such men were ever fit to
be admitted. To say, a piece of timber, though not of a durable nature, is fit to be put into
the frame of a building, because when it begins to rot, it may be pulled out again, is so far
from proving that it was ever fit to be put in, that the speedy necessity of pulling it out rather
proves the contrary. If we had the power of constituting a human body, or it were left to us
to add members to our own bodies, as there might be occasion; we should not think such
a member was fit to be added to the frame, that had already radically seated in it a cancer
or gangrene, by which it could last but a little while itself, and would endanger the other
members; though it were true, that when the disease should prevail, there were surgeons
which might be procured to cut that member off.
But to consider a little further this point of moral sincerity qualifying persons for the
privileges of the church. I would lay down this proposition as a thing of clear evidence: those
persons have no fitness in themselves to come to the privileges of the church, who, if they were
known, would not be fit to be admitted by others. For to say, they are fit to be members, and
yet not fit to be allowed to be members, is apparently absurd. But they who have no better
fitness than moral sincerity, if that were known, would not be fit to be admitted by others;
as is allowed by Mr. W. For he holds, that in order to be fit to be admitted by others, they
must credibly appear to them to have something more than moral sincerity, even gospel-
holiness. And it is evident in itself, as well as allowed by Mr. W. that if such were known,
they would not be fit to be admitted, only on their moral sincerity, and the profession and
promises they make from such a principle; and that for this reason, because such a principle
alone would not be fit to be trusted. God himself has taught his church, that the religion of
unsanctified men is not fit to be trusted; as a lamp without oil, and a plant without root, are
1951
SECTION VIII. Of sincerity.