PHILOSOPHY
Germany or Holland. I assert that, in every fibre, it is ofhome
growth and national texture. Whatevermy dominion over truth
may be, I have conquered every inch of it myself." In this
somewhat boastful utterance he does not mean to disown
indebtedness to his predecessors. What he intends to assert is,
that he adopted from them no ready-made doctrines, but that
what he derived from them was rather stimulus, suggestion, and
material for the development of his own thought. This is true
more or less of all whose names deserve to appear in the History
of Philosophy. But it held good in a special degree of Ferrier.
He was, indeed, an assiduous reader of philosophical literature.
He had, for instance, " read most of Hegel's work again and
again." But what was the nature of his reading ? An anecdote
told by Dr. Hutcheson Stirling seems to me to throw a flood of
light on this question. Stirling found him diligently engaged
on a volume of Hegel which turned out to be upside down.
Ferrier's explanation was that, being utterly baffled in the
attempt to understand his author the right side up, he had tried
the other way in desperation. Now, I am strongly inclined to
believe that, in a metaphorical sense, most of Ferrier's reading
was done with the book upside down. The book might be
Plato's or Hegel's or Kant's or Berkeley's ; what Ferrier read in it,
or rather into it, was not so much Plato or Hegel or Kant or
Berkeley, as Ferrier. His dominating interest lay in discovering
not so much what his author actually said, aswhat from his own
point of view his author ought to have said. Thus, there is a
real sting in Samuel Bailey's remark, that Ferrier is " far more
successful in involving himself in subtle speculations of his own
than in faithfully guiding his readers through the theories of
other philosophers."
This characteristic of Ferrier is most conspicuous in what
is perhaps his best book, the Lectures on Greek Philosophy.
As an historical exposition of Heraclitus, Socrates, Plato, etc.,
155