Arminian principles; viz. because as difficulty, by antecedent bent and bias on the Will, is
increased, liberty of indifference, and self-determination in the Will, is diminished; so much
hindrance, impediment is there, in the way of the Will acting freely, by mere self-determin-
ation. And if ten degrees of such hindrance take away all such liberty, then nine degrees
take away nine parts in ten, and leave but one degree of liberty. And therefore there is but
one degree of blameableness, cateris paribus, in the neglect; the man being no further
blamable in what he does, or neglects, than he has liberty in that affair: for blame or praise
(say they) arises wholly from a good use or abuse of liberty.
From all which it follows, that a strong bent and bias one way, and difficulty of going
the contrary, never causes a person to be at all more exposed to sin, or any thing blamable:
because, as the difficulty is increased, so much the less is required and expected. Though in
one respect, exposedness to sin is increased, viz. by an increase of exposedness to the evil
action or omission; yet it is diminished in another respect, to balance it; namely, as the sin-
fulness or blamableness of the action or omission is diminished in the same proportion. So
47
that, on the whole, the affair, as to exposedness to guilt or blame, is left just as it was.
To illustrate this, let us suppose a scale of a balance to be intelligent, and a free agent,
and indued with a self-moving power, by virtue of which it could act and produce effects
to a certain degree, ex. gr. to move itself up or down with a force equal to a weight of ten
pounds; and that it might therefore be required of it, in ordinary circumstances, to move
itself down with that force; for which it has power and full liberty, and therefore would be
blameworthy if it failed of it. But then let us suppose a weight of ten pounds to be put in the
opposite scale, which in force entirely counterbalances its self-moving power, and so renders
it impossible for it to move down at all; and therefore wholly excuses it from any such motion.
But if we suppose there to be only nine pounds in the opposite scale, this renders its motion
not impossible, but yet more difficult; so that it can now only move down with the force of
one pound: but however, this is all that is required of it under these circumstances; it is
wholly excused from nine parts of its motion: and if the scale, under these circumstances,
neglect to move, and remain at rest, all that it will be blamed for, will be its neglect of that
one tenth part of its motion; for which it had as much liberty and advantage, as in usual
circumstances it has for the greater motion, which in such a case would be required. So that
this new difficulty does not at all increase its exposedness to any thing blameworthy.
And thus the very supposition of difficulty in the way of a man’s duty, or proclivity to
sin, through a being given up to hardness of heart, or indeed by any other means whatsoever,
is an inconsistence, according to Dr. Whitby’s notions of liberty, virtue and vice, blame and
praise. The avoiding of sin and blame, and the doing of what is virtuous and praiseworthy,
most be always equally easy.
Dr. Whitby’s notions of liberty, obligation, virtue. sin, &c. led him into another great
inconsistence. He abundantly insists, that necessity is inconsistent with the nature of sin or
639
SECTION III. The case of such as are given up of God to sin, and of fallen…