of the three hundred and eighteen Fathers assembled at Nicæa, and to all that was done at
the great and Holy Synod at Ephesus.”
The Creed of Constantinople appears for the first time to have been highly honoured
at the fourth General Council, which had it recited after that of Nicæa, and thus solemnly
approved it. Since then this Synod has been universally honoured as ecumenical by the
Greeks, and was mentioned by the Emperor Justinian with the Councils of Nicæa, Ephesus,
and Chalcedon, as of equal rank.236
But in the West, and especially in Rome, however satisfied people were with the decree
of faith enacted by this Synod, and its completion of the creed, yet its third canon, respecting
the rank of Constantinople, for a long time proved a hindrance to its acknowledgment.
This was especially shown at the Council of Chalcedon, and during the time immediately
following. When at that Council the creed of Constantinople was praised, repeated, and
confirmed the Papal Legates fully concurred; but when the Council also renewed and con-
firmed the third canon of Constantinople, the Legates left the assembly, lodged a protest
against it on the following day, and declared that the rules of the hundred and fifty bishops
at Constantinople were never inserted among the Synodal canons (which were recognised
at Rome). The same was mentioned by Pope Leo himself, who, immediately after the close
of the Council of Chalcedon wrote to Bishop Anatolius of Constantinople: “that document
of certain bishops (i.e. the third canon of Constantinople) was never brought by your pre-
decessors to the knowledge of the Apostolic See.”237 Leo also, in his 105th letter to the
Empress Pulcheria, speaks just as depreciatingly of this Council of Constantinople; and
Quesnel is entirely wrong in maintaining that the Papal Legates at the Synod of Chalcedon
at first practically acknowledged the validity of the third canon of Constantinople. Bishop
Eusebius of Dorylæum was equally mistaken in maintaining at Chalcedon itself, that the
third canon had been sanctioned by the Pope; and we shall have occasion further on, in the
history of the Council of Chalcedon, to show the untenable character of both statements.
Pope Felix III. took the same view as Pope Leo, when, in his letter to the monks at
Constantinople and Bithynia in 485, he only spoke of three General Councils at Nicæa,
Ephesus, and Chalcedon; neither did his successor Gelasius (492–496) in his genuine decree,
De libris recipiendis, mention this Synod. It may certainly be said, on the other hand, that
in the sixth century its ecumenical character had come to be most distinctly acknowledged
in the Latin Church also, and, as we have seen above, had been expressly affirmed by the
Popes Vigilius, Pelagius II., and Gregory the Great. But this acknowledgment, even when
it is not expressly stated, only referred to the decrees on faith of the Council of Con-
236 In his edict against the Three Chapters.
237 Leo, Epist. cvi. n., ed. Ballerini, t. i., p. 1165.
366
Excursus on the Authority of the Second Ecumenical Council.