Chapter 3.—How Pronunciation Serves to Remove Ambiguity. Different Kinds of In-
terrogation.
6. And all the directions that I have given about ambiguous punctuations are to be ob-
served likewise in the case of doubtful pronunciations. For these too, unless the fault lies
in the carelessness of the reader, are corrected either by the rule of faith, or by a reference
to the preceding or succeeding context; or if neither of these methods is applied with success,
they will remain doubtful, but so that the reader will not be in fault in whatever way he may
pronounce them. For example, if our faith that God will not bring any charges against His
elect, and that Christ will not condemn His elect, did not stand in the way, this passage,
558
“Who shall lay anything to the charge of God’s elect?” might be pronounced in such a way
as to make what follows an answer to this question, “God who justifieth,” and to make a
second question, “Who is he that condemneth?” with the answer, “Christ Jesus who
died.”1843 But as it would be the height of madness to believe this, the passage will be pro-
nounced in such a way as to make the first part a question of inquiry,1844 and the second a
rhetorical interrogative.1845 Now the ancients said that the difference between an inquiry
and an interrogative was this, that an inquiry admits of many answers, but to an interrogative
the answer must be either “No” or “Yes.”1846 The passage will be pronounced, then, in such
a way that after the inquiry, “Who shall lay anything to the charge of God’s elect?” what
follows will be put as an interrogative: “Shall God who justifieth?”—the answer “No” being
understood. And in the same way we shall have the inquiry, “Who is he that condemneth?”
and the answer here again in the form of an interrogative, “Is it Christ who died? yea, rather,
who is risen again? who is even at the right hand of God? who also maketh intercession for
us?”—the answer “No” being understood to every one of these questions. On the other
hand, in that passage where the apostle says, “What shall we say then? That the Gentiles
which followed not after righteousness have attained to righteousness;”1847 unless after the
inquiry, “What shall we say then?” what follows were given as the answer to this question:
“That the Gentiles, which followed not after righteousness, have attained to righteousness;”
it would not be in harmony with the succeeding context. But with whatever tone of voice
one may choose to pronounce that saying of Nathanael’s, “Can any good thing come out
of Nazareth?”1848—whether with that of a man who gives an affirmative answer, so that
1843 Rom. viii. 33, 34.
1844 Percontatio.
1845 Interrogatio.
1846 The English language has no two words expressing the shades of meaning assigned by Augustin to
percontatio and interrogatio respectively.
1847 Rom. ix. 30.
1848 John i. 47.
How Pronunciation Serves to Remove Ambiguity. Different Kinds of Interrogation.
1256
How Pronunciation Serves to Remove Ambiguity. Different Kinds of Inter…