Chapter 20.—Of the Destruction of
the Saguntines, Who Received No Help from the Roman Gods, Though
Perishing on Account of Their Fidelity to Rome.
But among all the disasters of the
second Punic war, there occurred none more lamentable, or
calculated to excite deeper complaint, than the fate of the
Saguntines. This city of Spain, eminently friendly to Rome, was
destroyed by its fidelity to the Roman people. For when Hannibal
had broken treaty with the Romans, he sought occasion for provoking
them to war, and accordingly made a fierce assault upon Saguntum.
When this was reported at Rome, ambassadors were sent to Hannibal,
urging him to raise the siege; and when this remonstrance was
neglected, they proceeded to Carthage, lodged complaint against the
breaking of the treaty, and returned
to Rome without
accomplishing their object. Meanwhile the siege went on; and in
the eighth or ninth month, this opulent but ill-fated city, dear as
it was to its own state and to Rome, was taken, and subjected to
treatment which one cannot read, much less narrate, without
horror. And yet, because it bears directly on the matter in hand,
I will briefly touch upon it. First, then, famine wasted the
Saguntines, so that even human corpses were eaten by some: so at
least it is recorded. Subsequently, when thoroughly worn out,
that they might at least escape the ignominy of falling into the
hands of Hannibal, they publicly erected a huge funeral pile, and
cast themselves into its flames, while at the same time they slew
their children and themselves with the sword. Could these gods,
these debauchees and gourmands, whose mouths water for fat
sacrifices, and whose lips utter lying divinations,—could they
not do anything in a case like this? Could they not interfere for
the preservation of a city closely allied to the Roman people, or
prevent it perishing for its fidelity to that alliance of which
they themselves had been the mediators? Saguntum, faithfully
keeping the treaty it had entered into before these gods, and to
which it had firmly bound itself by an oath, was besieged, taken,
and destroyed by a perjured person. If afterwards, when Hannibal
was close to the walls of Rome, it was the gods who terrified him
with lightning and tempest, and drove him to a distance, why, I
ask, did they not thus interfere before? For I make bold to say,
that this demonstration with the tempest would have been more
honorably made in defence of the allies of Rome—who were in
danger on account of their reluctance to break faith with the
Romans, and had no resources of their own—than in defence of the
Romans themselves, who were fighting in their own cause, and had
abundant resources to oppose Hannibal. If, then, they had been
the guardians of Roman prosperity and glory, they would have
preserved that glory from the stain of this Saguntine disaster; and
how silly it is to believe that Rome was preserved from destruction
at the hands of Hannibal by the guardian care of those gods who
were unable to rescue the city of Saguntum from perishing through
its fidelity to the alliance of Rome. If the population of
Saguntum had been Christian, and had suffered as it did for the
Christian faith (though, of course, Christians would not have used
fire and sword against their own persons), they would have suffered
with that hope which springs from faith in Christ—the hope not of
a brief temporal reward, but of unending and eternal bliss. What,
then, will the advocates and apologists of these gods say in their
defence, when charged with the blood of these Saguntines; for they
are professedly worshipped and invoked for this very purpose of
securing prosperity in this fleeting and transitory life? Can
anything be said but what was alleged in the case of Regulus’
death? For though there is a difference between the two cases,
the one being an individual, the other a whole community, yet the
cause of destruction was in both cases the keeping of their
plighted troth. For it was this which made Regulus willing to
return to his enemies, and this which made the Saguntines unwilling
to revolt to their enemies. Does, then, the keeping of faith
provoke the gods to anger? Or is it possible that not only
individuals, but even entire communities, perish while the gods are
propitious to them? Let our adversaries choose which alternative
they will. If, on the one hand, those gods are enraged at the
keeping of faith, let them enlist perjured persons as their
worshippers. If, on the other hand, men and states can suffer
great and terrible calamities, and at last perish while favored by
the gods, then does their worship not produce happiness as its
fruit. Let those, therefore, who suppose that they have fallen
into distress because their religious worship has been abolished,
lay aside their anger; for it were quite possible that did the gods
not only remain with them, but regard them with favor, they might
yet be left to mourn an unhappy lot, or might, even like Regulus
and the Saguntines, be horribly tormented, and at last perish
miserably.