Testimonia

Publiek archief van verzamelde en verwerkte bronrecords.
Overzicht / Records / record

verse-keyed-module-record

Technische verwerking bevestigt geen inhoudelijke beoordeling of toestemming voor openbare publicatie.

record_key: 7d05dcdecc8f0d8bc032aa9be1f9179f2a296d02c3e1f84125fcd6ba02187429
origineel ID: sermonindex-ecf-10938 · verwerkingsstatus: Verwerkt, inhoudelijk nog niet beoordeeld · teksthash: 6e36f9a4d3cc2792471e766dacc386a67a9e3da3624bfa04f9d29dc5c01c9751 · 5,204 tekens

Tekst tekstblob openen

Augustine of Hippo : We can rightly ask why Joshua ordered the people to stone the individual who was surprised at having broken the anathema, when the Lord had commanded that, if it were discovered, he should be handed over to the fire. Or perhaps it was fitting that he should die, like Joshua, who was closer to the Lord, could he understand the words of the Lord who commanded him? No other, in fact, could understand them more easily. Therefore, we must ask why the Lord calls fire to stoning before thinking that Joshua did something different from what the Lord sent him. Because there could not be another wiser to understand the words of the Lord or anyone more obedient than him to fulfill them. Therefore, the Scripture testifies in Deuteronomy that, under the name of fire, the punishment could be indicated, when it is said to the children of Israel: "And I brought you out of the iron furnace of Egypt." Here, evidently, the Scripture wanted to mean a hard tribulation. Two reasons occur to me - not because they fit the two, but only one of them - to say why Akar was not burned with all his things by a visible fire. If the Lord judged that his sin was of such a nature that, atoned for by that torment, he would not punish it eternally, the penalty would very appropriately be called fire by his own atonement and purification. No one would be led to think this if a fire visible in its own right had burned him. Everyone would rather stop to think about what they clearly saw done and no one else would ask another reason. Now, since it is reasonably said that the stoning was also a fire, because of the words of God and the performance of Joshua, it is elegantly recognized that man was purified by that punishment, so that he would not perish later because of that sin In the same way, in Leviticus, the utensils that are purged by fire are also meant (Cf Leviticus 13,52) But if the sin was of such a nature that such a man was worthy of gehenna, because of that sin, even after this life, Joshua would have wanted to stone him precisely to warn that in what the Lord had said: he will be delivered to the fire (Joshua 7,15), you had to understand not what they did, but what the Lord was going to do. Well, if the Lord had said: You will give it to the fire with all its things, there would be no possibility for this sense. But as the sentence is set so that it seems that God foretold what would happen to the guilty rather than sending what men should do to him, that is why Joshua, who understood the divine words as a great prophet and prophetically realized this very thing, He could not do better than to make him die by stoning instead of burning, so that in those flames the words of the Lord would not be fulfilled, that he wished that it be understood that he had said them for another reason. And no problem should arise from the fact that God had predicted that not only the person, but all his things had to be given to fire. For the Lord said thus: He will be delivered to the fire with all his things. In all his things his works can be understood, that, according to God, they should be burned with him, not as the Apostle says about certain works burned by fire, that he, on the other hand, will be saved (1 Corinthians 3,15), if the sin of this man should be understood in the sense that he was punished even with eternal fire. The people, by punishing the guilty, also covered their children and their daughters with stones, with the cattle and with all the things they had. But Joshua did not do this moved by a human judgment, but by the prophetic spirit, or by having understood the words: with all his things, so that he did not even consider the stoning to be exempt from the children, by also applying the punishment instead of the fire, or because he wanted to signify his works, that God after the death of the culprit had to burn with him, not only by means of the other things that he had, but also by his children. But not for that reason we must think that also their children, after death, were punished with the torment of the fire of hell for the sin of their father, of whom they were innocent. Because this death, which awaits us all, even if it comes from the first sin, because we were born, and therefore we necessarily have to die, (Cf Rm 5,12) can be useful for some if it accelerates. That is why the following is read about a person: He was taken so that evil did not change his intelligence (Sab 4,11). Therefore, it is something that only those who have no iniquity know the reason for the judgment of God or for the mercy that was applied to both the sons of this man and those thirty-six warriors, all of whom are alien to the sin of that man. Man (Cf Rm 9,14) But it is clear that it was also convenient for the people to investigate with panic what had happened and the others feared so much more to imitate the action of the former the greater the fear of human frailty, and that such a great and just hatred of the people it also gave in those who thought that for the hope of the propagation of the lineage he would let die for his sin, consumed with him his own descendants. — QUESTIONS ON JOSHUA, Q. 9 (tr. J. Litteral, draft)

Versies (1)

Versie 20acb13962ada7a8d27850a7d528cdee606e5871a6773d810df28ba48cf2c81f
{"author":null,"canonical_references":[],"database_sha256":"8cfbe7284c6936871d57c02dc6aa63ebbdfd4722422d539dd9f716e46e91112e","date_end":null,"date_start":null,"edition_year":null,"id":"sermonindex-ecf-10938","native_reference":{"book_number":60,"chapter_from":7,"chapter_to":7,"system":"MyBible module coordinates (mapping unverified)","verse_from":15,"verse_to":15},"public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"verse-keyed-module-record","review_required":["English edition and exact text","author/work attribution","dating","verse mapping and citation kind","reuse and attribution","split author quotations and deduplicate"],"review_status":"unreviewed","source_html":"<p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: We can rightly ask why Joshua ordered the people to stone the individual who was surprised at having broken the anathema, when the Lord had commanded that, if it were discovered, he should be handed over to the fire. Or perhaps it was fitting that he should die, like Joshua, who was closer to the Lord, could he understand the words of the Lord who commanded him? No other, in fact, could understand them more easily. Therefore, we must ask why the Lord calls fire to stoning before thinking that Joshua did something different from what the Lord sent him. Because there could not be another wiser to understand the words of the Lord or anyone more obedient than him to fulfill them. Therefore, the Scripture testifies in Deuteronomy that, under the name of fire, the punishment could be indicated, when it is said to the children of Israel: \"And I brought you out of the iron furnace of Egypt.\" Here, evidently, the Scripture wanted to mean a hard tribulation. Two reasons occur to me - not because they fit the two, but only one of them - to say why Akar was not burned with all his things by a visible fire. If the Lord judged that his sin was of such a nature that, atoned for by that torment, he would not punish it eternally, the penalty would very appropriately be called fire by his own atonement and purification. No one would be led to think this if a fire visible in its own right had burned him. Everyone would rather stop to think about what they clearly saw done and no one else would ask another reason. Now, since it is reasonably said that the stoning was also a fire, because of the words of God and the performance of Joshua, it is elegantly recognized that man was purified by that punishment, so that he would not perish later because of that sin In the same way, in Leviticus, the utensils that are purged by fire are also meant (Cf Leviticus 13,52) But if the sin was of such a nature that such a man was worthy of gehenna, because of that sin, even after this life, Joshua would have wanted to stone him precisely to warn that in what the Lord had said: he will be delivered to the fire (Joshua 7,15), you had to understand not what they did, but what the Lord was going to do. Well, if the Lord had said: You will give it to the fire with all its things, there would be no possibility for this sense. But as the sentence is set so that it seems that God foretold what would happen to the guilty rather than sending what men should do to him, that is why Joshua, who understood the divine words as a great prophet and prophetically realized this very thing, He could not do better than to make him die by stoning instead of burning, so that in those flames the words of the Lord would not be fulfilled, that he wished that it be understood that he had said them for another reason. And no problem should arise from the fact that God had predicted that not only the person, but all his things had to be given to fire. For the Lord said thus: He will be delivered to the fire with all his things. In all his things his works can be understood, that, according to God, they should be burned with him, not as the Apostle says about certain works burned by fire, that he, on the other hand, will be saved (1 Corinthians 3,15), if the sin of this man should be understood in the sense that he was punished even with eternal fire. The people, by punishing the guilty, also covered their children and their daughters with stones, with the cattle and with all the things they had. But Joshua did not do this moved by a human judgment, but by the prophetic spirit, or by having understood the words: with all his things, so that he did not even consider the stoning to be exempt from the children, by also applying the punishment instead of the fire, or because he wanted to signify his works, that God after the death of the culprit had to burn with him, not only by means of the other things that he had, but also by his children. But not for that reason we must think that also their children, after death, were punished with the torment of the fire of hell for the sin of their father, of whom they were innocent. Because this death, which awaits us all, even if it comes from the first sin, because we were born, and therefore we necessarily have to die, (Cf Rm 5,12) can be useful for some if it accelerates. That is why the following is read about a person: He was taken so that evil did not change his intelligence (Sab 4,11). Therefore, it is something that only those who have no iniquity know the reason for the judgment of God or for the mercy that was applied to both the sons of this man and those thirty-six warriors, all of whom are alien to the sin of that man. Man (Cf Rm 9,14) But it is clear that it was also convenient for the people to investigate with panic what had happened and the others feared so much more to imitate the action of the former the greater the fear of human frailty, and that such a great and just hatred of the people it also gave in those who thought that for the hope of the propagation of the lineage he would let die for his sin, consumed with him his own descendants.<br/><i>— QUESTIONS ON JOSHUA, Q. 9 (tr. J. Litteral, draft)</i></p>","source_html_sha256":"61f771606efeefead926b66c0835fb88ba497b1cb44d15368c6242fa22531d5d","source_module":"ECF","source_row_id":10938,"source_url":"https://www.sermonindex.net/commentary/ecf/","text_sha256":"6e36f9a4d3cc2792471e766dacc386a67a9e3da3624bfa04f9d29dc5c01c9751","translator":null,"work":null}

references: [] | work_id: | origin: existing-private-derived-record | source: https://www.sermonindex.net/commentary/ecf/

Plaatsingen (1)

OrdinalInputVersie
line:10938183220acb13962ada7a8d27850a7d528cdee606e5871a6773d810df28ba48cf2c81f

Bijbelverwijzingen (0)

CoördinaatReferentie

Live-status (1)

Live IDStatusMatchesSchema
sermonindex-ecf-10938processed_not_found_in_observed_live0