Chapter 13.—That the Romans Should Have Understood that Gods Who Desired to
Be Worshipped in Licentious Entertainments Were Unworthy of Divine Honor.
But Scipio, were he alive, would possibly reply: “How could we attach a penalty to that
which the gods themselves have consecrated? For the theatrical entertainments in which
such things are said, and acted, and performed, were introduced into Roman society by the
gods, who ordered that they should be dedicated and exhibited in their honor.” But was
not this, then, the plainest proof that they were no true gods, nor in any respect worthy of
receiving divine honours from the republic? Suppose they had required that in their honor
the citizens of Rome should be held up to ridicule, every Roman would have resented the
hateful proposal. How then, I would ask, can they be esteemed worthy of worship, when
they propose that their own crimes be used as material for celebrating their praises? Does
not this artifice expose them, and prove that they are detestable devils? Thus the Romans,
though they were superstitious enough to serve as gods those who made no secret of their
desire to be worshipped in licentious plays, yet had sufficient regard to their hereditary
dignity and virtue, to prompt them to refuse to players any such rewards as the Greeks ac-
corded them. On this point we have this testimony of Scipio, recorded in Cicero: “They
[the Romans] considered comedy and all theatrical performances as disgraceful, and
therefore not only debarred players from offices and honors open to ordinary citizens, but
also decreed that their names should be branded by the censor, and erased from the roll of
their tribe.” An excellent decree, and another testimony to the sagacity of Rome; but I could
wish their prudence had been more thorough-going and consistent. For when I hear that
if any Roman citizen chose the stage as his profession, he not only closed to himself every
laudable career, but even became an outcast from his own tribe, I cannot but exclaim: This
30
is the true Roman spirit, this is worthy of a state jealous of its reputation. But then some
one interrupts my rapture, by inquiring with what consistency players are debarred from
all honors, while plays are counted among the honors due to the gods? For a long while the
virtue of Rome was uncontaminated by theatrical exhibitions;104 and if they had been adopted
for the sake of gratifying the taste of the citizens, they would have been introduced hand in
hand with the relaxation of manners. But the fact is, that it was the gods who demanded
that they should be exhibited to gratify them. With what justice, then, is the player excom-
municated by whom God is worshipped? On what pretext can you at once adore him who
exacts, and brand him who acts these plays? This, then, is the controversy in which the
Greeks and Romans are engaged. The Greeks think they justly honor players, because they
worship the gods who demand plays; the Romans, on the other hand, do not suffer an actor
104 According to Livy (vii. 2), theatrical exhibitions were introduced in the year 392 a.u.c. Before that time,
he says, there had only been the games of the circus. The Romans sent to Etruria for players, who were called
histriones, hister being the Tuscan word for a player. Other particulars are added by Livy.
That the Romans Should Have Understood that Gods Who Desired to Be Worshipped in Licentious Entertainments Were Unworthy of Divine Honor.
83
That the Romans Should Have Understood that Gods Who Desired to Be Worshipped…