of adoption.1099 Christ is the Son of God by virtue of His real and abiding nature. How,
then, can He, Who out of nothing fashioned all things, be Himself created out of nothing?
127. He who knows not whence the Son is hath not the Son. The Jews therefore had not
the Son, for they knew not whence He was. Wherefore the Lord said to them: “Ye know not
whence I came;”1100 and again: “Ye neither have found out Who I am, nor know My Father,”
for he who denies that the Son is of the Father knows not the Father, of Whom the Son is;
and again, he knows not the Son, because he knows not the Father.
128. Arius says: “[The Son is] of another Substance.” But what other substance is exalted
to equality with the Son of God, so that simply in virtue thereof He is Son of God? Or what
right have the Arians for censuring us because we speak, in Greek, of the οὐσία, or in Latin,
of the Substantia of God, when they themselves, in saying that the Son of God is of another
“Substance,” assert a divine Substantia.
129. Howbeit, should they desire to dispute the use of the words “divine Substance” or
“divine Nature,” they shall easily be refuted, for Holy Writ oft-times hath spoken of οὐσία
222
in Greek, or Substantia in Latin, and St. Peter, as we read, would have us become partakers
in the divine Nature. But if they will have it that the Son is of another “Substance,” they with
their own lips confute themselves, in that they both acknowledge the term “Substance,”
whereof they are so afraid, and rank the Son on a level with the creatures above which they
feign to exalt Him.
130. Arius calls the Son of God a creature, but “not as the rest of the creatures.” Yet
what created being is not different from another? Man is not as angel, earth is not as heaven,
the sun is not as water, nor light as darkness. Arius’ preference, therefore, is empty—he hath
but disguised with a sorry dye his deceitful blasphemies, in order to take the foolish.
131. Arius declares that the Son of God may change and swerve. How, then, is He God
if He is changeable, seeing that He Himself hath said: “I am, I am, and I change not”?1101
1099 (1) “the word spoken,” etc.—Ps. xlv. 1. Eructavit cor meum verbum bonum.—Vulg. ἐξρεύξατο ἡ καρδία
μου λόγον ἀγαθόν.—LXX. (2) “sons by adoption.”—Gal. iv. 4, 5.
1100 S. John viii. 14.
1101 St. Ambrose’ version differs in expression from the Vulg.—Ego enim Dominus et non mutor (Mal. iii.
6)—but not in substance, for Ego sum Dominus and “I am the Lord” both mean “I am He who is”—(ὁ ὢν)—which
is very well represented by Ego sum, Ego sum—“I am, I am.”—Cf. Ex. iii. 14.
490
Chapter XIX. Arius is charged with the first of the above-mentioned errors,…