Chapter 7.—That the Words Love and Regard (Amor and Dilectio) are in Scripture
Used Indifferently of Good and Evil Affection.
He who resolves to love God, and to love his neighbor as himself, not according to man
but according to God, is on account of this love said to be of a good will; and this is in
Scripture more commonly called charity, but it is also, even in the same books, called love.
For the apostle says that the man to be elected as a ruler of the people must be a lover of
good.662 And when the Lord Himself had asked Peter, “Hast thou a regard for me (diligis)
more than these?” Peter replied, “Lord, Thou knowest that I love (amo) Thee.” And again
a second time the Lord asked not whether Peter loved (amaret) Him, but whether he had a
regard (diligeret)for Him, and, he again answered, “Lord, Thou knowest that I love (amo)
Thee.” But on the third interrogation the Lord Himself no longer says, “Hast thou a regard
(diligis) for me,”but “Lovest thou (amas) me?” And then the evangelist adds, “Peter was
grieved because He said unto him the third time, “Lovest thou (amas) me?” though the Lord
had not said three times but only once, “Lovest thou (amas) me?” and twice “Diligis me ?”
from which we gather that, even when the Lord said “diligis,” He used an equivalent for
“amas.” Peter, too, throughout used one word for the one thing, and the third time also
replied, “Lord, Thou knowest all things, Thou knowest that I love (amo) Thee.”663
I have judged it right to mention this, because some are of opinion that charity or regard
(dilectio) is one thing, love (amor) another. They say that dilectio is used of a good affection,
amor of an evil love. But it is very certain that even secular literature knows no such distinc-
tion. However, it is for the philosophers to determine whether and how they differ, though
their own writings sufficiently testify that they make great account of love (amor) placed
on good objects, and even on God Himself. But we wished to show that the Scriptures of
our religion, whose authority we prefer to all writings whatsoever, make no distinction
between amor, dilectio, and caritas; and we have already shown that amor is used in a good
connection. And if any one fancy that amor is no doubt used both of good and bad loves,
but that dilectio is reserved for the good only, let him remember what the psalm says, “He
that loveth (diligit) iniquity hateth his own soul;”664 and the words of the Apostle John, “If
any man love (diligere) the world, the love (dilectio) of the Father is not in him.”665 Here
you have in one passage dilectioused both in a good and a bad sense. And if any one demands
an instance of amor being used in a bad sense (for we have already shown its use in a good
sense), let him read the words, “For men shall be lovers (amantes) of their own selves, lovers
(amatores) of money.”666
662 Tit. i. 8, according to Greek and Vulgate.
663 John xxi. 15–17. On these synonyms see the commentaries in loc.
664 Ps. xi. 5.
665 1 John ii. 15.
666 2 Tim. iii. 2.
That the Words Love and Regard (Amor and Dilectio) are in Scripture Used Indifferently of Good and Evil Affection.
606
That the Words Love and Regard (Amor and Dilectio) are in Scripture Used…