Gildo, because one of your colleagues2197 was his intimate friend, let the followers of Max-
imianus be our witnesses to their sufferings. For if one might appeal to Felicianus himself,
who is now with you, on his oath, whether Optatus did not compel him against his will to
return to your communion, he would not dare to open his lips, especially if the people of
Musti could behold his face, who were witnesses to everything that was done. But let them,
as I have said, be witnesses to what they have suffered at the hands of those with whom they
acted in such wise towards Rogatus. The Catholic Church herself, though strengthened by
the assistance of Catholic princes ruling by land and sea, was savagely attacked by hostile
troops in arms under Optatus. It was this that first made it necessary to urge before the
vicar Seranus that the law should be put in force against you which imposes a fine of ten
pounds of gold, which none of you have ever paid to this very day, and yet you charge us
with cruelty. But where could you find a milder course of proceeding, than that crimes of
such magnitude on your part should be punished by the imposition of a pecuniary fine?
Or who could enumerate all the deeds which you commit in the places which you hold, of
your own sovereign will and pleasure, each one as he can, without any friendship on the
part of judges or any others in authority? Who is there of our party, among the inhabitants
of our towns, who has not either learned something of this sort from those who came before
him, or experienced it for himself? Is it not the case that at Hippo, where I am, there are
not wanting some who remember that your leader Faustinus gave orders, in the time of his
supreme power, in consequence of the scanty numbers of the Catholics in the place, that
no one should bake their bread for them, insomuch that a baker, who was the tenant of one
of our deacons, threw away the bread of his landlord unbaked, and though he was not sen-
tenced to exile under any law, he cut him off from all share in the necessaries of life not only
in a Roman state,2198 but even in his own country, and not only in his own country, but in
his own house? Why, even lately, as I myself recall with mourning to this day, did not
Crispinus of Calama, one of your party, having bought a property, and that only copy-
hold,2199 boldly and unhesitatingly immerse in the waters of a second baptism no less than
eighty souls, murmuring with miserable groans under the sole influence of terror; and this
in a farm belonging to the Catholic emperors, by whose laws you were forbidden even to
be in any Roman city?2200 But what else was it, save such deeds as these of yours, that made
2197 Optatus of Thaumugade (Thamogade), the friend of Gildo.
2198 Augustin mentions again in his thirty-fifth epistle, to Eusebius, sec. 3, that Hippo had received the Roman
citizenship. His argument is that, even if not a native of the place, the deacon should have been safe from mo-
lestation wherever Roman laws prevailed.
2199 Emphyteuticam. The land, therefore, was held under the emperors, and less absolutely in the power
of the owner than if it had been freehold.
2200 Augustin remonstrates with Crispinus on the point, Epist. lxvi.
1129
Chapter 84