Dr. T. says (p. 167. S.) “It is my persuasion, that the christian religion was very early
and grievously corrupted by dreaming, ignorant, superstitious monks, too conceited to be
satisfied with the plain gospel; and has long remained in that deplorable state.”—But how
came the whole christian world, without any blinding depravity, to hearken to these ignorant
foolish men, rather than unto wiser and better teachers? especially, when the latter had plain
gospel on their side, and the doctrines of the other were (as our author supposes) so very
contrary not only to the plain gospel, but to men’s reason and common sense? or were all
the teachers of the Christian church nothing but a parcel of ignorant dreamers? If so, this is
very strange indeed, unless mankind naturally loves darkness rather than light; seeing in all
parts of the christian world, there was a great multitude in the work of the ministry, who
had the gospel in their hands, and whose whole business it was to study and teach it; and
therefore had infinitely greater advantages to become truly wise, than the heathen philosoph-
ers. But if, by some strange and inconceivable means, notwithstanding all these glorious
advantages, all the teachers of the christian church through the world, without any native
evil propensity, very early became silly dreamers—and also in their dreaming, generally
stumbled on the same individual monstrous opinions, and so the world might be blinded
for a while—yet, why did not they hearken to that wise and great man, Pelagius, and others
like him, when he plainly held forth the truth to the christian world? Especially seeing his
instructions were so agreeable to the plain doctrines, and the bright and clear light of the
gospel of Christ, and also so agreeable to the plainest dictates of the common sense and
understanding of all mankind; but the other so repugnant to it, that (according to our author)
if they were true, it would prove understanding to be no understanding, and the word of God
to be no rule of truth, nor at all to be relied upon, and God to be a Being worthy of no regard?
Besides, if the inefficacy of the gospel to restrain sin and promote virtue, be owing to
the general prevalence of these doctrines, which are supposed to be so absurd and contrary
to the gospel, here is this further to be accounted for; namely, Why, since there has been so
great an increase of light in religious matters (as must be supposed on Dr. T.’s scheme) in
this and the last age, and these monstrous doctrines of original sin, election, reprobation,
justification, regeneration, &c. have been so much exploded, especially in our nation, there
has been no reformation attending this great advancement of light and truth: but on the
contrary, vice, and every thing opposite to practical Christianity, has gone on to increase,
with such a prodigious celerity, as to become like an overflowing deluge; threatening, unless
God mercifully interposes, speedily to swallow up all that is virtuous and praiseworthy.
Many other things might have been mentioned under this head—the means which
mankind have had to restrain vice, and promote virtue—such as wickedness being many
ways contrary to men’s temporal interest and comfort, and their having continually before
their eyes so many instances of persons made miserable by their vices; the restraints of human
laws, without which men cannot live in society; the judgments of God brought on men for
993
SECTION VIII. Great means used to oppose wickedness.