§2.
Catalogue of his
Works
.
There is no absolutely complete
edition of Eusebius’ extant works. The only one which can lay
claim even to relative completeness is that of Migne:
Eusebii
Pamphili, Cæsareæ Palestinæ Episcopi, Opera omnia
quæ extant, curis variorum, nempe: Henrici Valesii, Francisci
Vigeri, Bernardi Montfauconii, Card. Angelo Maii edita; collegit et
denuo recognovit J. P. Migne.
Par. 1857. 6 vols. (tom.
XIX.–XXIV. of Migne’s
Patrologia Græca
). This
edition omits the works which are extant only in Syriac versions, also
the
Topica
, and some brief but important Greek fragments (among
them the epistles to Alexander and Euphration). The edition, however,
is invaluable and cannot be dispensed with. References to it (under the
simple title
Opera
) will be given below in connection with those
works which it contains. Many of Eusebius’ writings, especially
the historical, have been published separately. Such editions will be
mentioned in their proper place in the Catalogue.
More or less incomplete lists of
our author’s writings are given by Jerome (
De vir. ill
.
87); by Nicephorus Callistus (
H. E
. VI. 37); by Ebedjesu (in
Assemani’s
Bibl. Orient
. III. p. 18 sq.); by Photius
(
Bibl
. 9–13, 27, 39, 127); and by Suidas (who simply
copies the Greek version of Jerome). Among modern works all the lives
of Eusebius referred to in the previous chapter give more or less
extended catalogues of his writings. In addition to the works mentioned
there, valuable lists are also found in Lardner’s
Credibility
, Part II chap. 72, and especially in
Fabricius’
Bibl. Græca
(ed. 1714), vol. VI. p. 30
sq.
The writings of Eusebius that
are known to us, extant and non-extant, may be classified for
convenience’ sake under the following heads: I. Historical. II.
Apologetic. III. Polemic. IV. Dogmatic. V. Critical and Exegetical. VI.
Biblical Dictionaries. VII. Orations. VIII. Epistles. IX. Spurious or
doubtful works. The classification is necessarily somewhat artificial,
and claims to be neither exhaustive nor exclusive.
4
I.
Historical
Works
.
Life of Pamphilus
(
ἡ
τοῦ
Παμφίλου
βίου
ἀναγραφή
; see
H. E
. VI. 32). Eusebius himself refers to this work
in four passages (
H. E
. VI. 32, VII. 32, VIII. 13, and
Mart.
Pal
. c. 11). In the last he informs us that it consisted of three
books. The work is mentioned also more than once by Jerome (
De vir.
ill
. 81;
Ep. ad Marcellam,
Migne’s ed.
Ep
. 34;
Contra Ruf
. I. 9), who speaks of it in terms of praise, and in
the last passage gives a brief extract from the third book, which is,
so far as known, the only extant fragment of the work. The date of its
composition can be fixed within comparatively narrow limits. It must of
course have been written before the shorter recension of the
Martyrs
of Palestine
, which contains a reference to it (on its relation to
the
longer
recension, which does not mention it, see below, p. 30), and also
before the
History,
(i.e. as early as 313
a.d.
(?), see below, p. 45). On the other hand, it was
written after Pamphilus’ death (see
H. E
. VII. 32, 25),
which occurred in 310.
Martyrs of
Palestine
(
περὶ τῶν ἐν
Παλαιστίνῃ
μαρτυρησ€ντων
). This work is extant in two recensions, a longer and a
shorter. The longer has been preserved entire only in a Syriac version,
which was published, with English translation and notes, by Cureton in
1861. A fragment of the original Greek of this work as preserved by
Simon Metaphrastes had previously been published by Papebroch in the
Acta Sanctorum
(June, tom. I. p. 64; reprinted by Fabricius,
Hippolytus,
II. p. 217), but had been erroneously regarded as an
extract from Eusebius’
Life of Pamphilus
. Cureton’s
publication of the Syriac version of the
Martyrs of Palestine
showed that it was a part of the original of that work. There are
extant also, in Latin, the
Acts of St. Procopius
, which were
published by Valesius (in his edition of Eusebius’
Hist.
Eccles
. in a note on the first chapter of the
Mart. Pal
.;
reprinted by Cureton,
Mart. Pal
. p. 50 sq.). Moreover, according
to Cureton, Assemani’s
Acta SS. Martyrum Orient. et
Occidentalium
, part II. p. 169 sq. (Romæ, 1748) contains
another Syriac version of considerable portions of this same work. The
Syriac version published by Cureton was made within less than a century
after the composition of the original work (the manuscript of it dates
from 411
a.d.
; see Cureton,
ib
.,
preface, p. i.), perhaps within a few years after it, and there is
every reason to suppose that it represents that original with
considerable exactness. That Eusebius himself was the author of the
original cannot be doubted. In addition to this longer recension there
is extant in Greek a shorter form of the same work which is found
attached to the
Ecclesiastical History
in most
mss.
of the latter. In some of them it is placed between
the eighth and ninth books, in others at the close of the tenth book,
while one
ms.
inserts it in the middle of
VIII. 13. In some of the most important
mss.
it is wanting entirely, as likewise in the translation of Rufinus, and,
according to Lightfoot, in the Syriac version of the
History
.
Most editions of Eusebius’
History
print it at the close
of the eighth book. Migne gives it separately in
Opera
, II. 1457
sq. In the present volume the translation of it is given as an appendix
to the eighth book, on p. 342 sq.
There can be no doubt that the
shorter form is younger than the longer. The mention of the
Life of
Pamphilus
which is contained in the shorter, but is not found in
the corresponding passage of the longer form would seem to indicate
that the former was a remodeling of the latter rather than the latter
of the former (see below, p. 30). Moreover, as Cureton and Lightfoot
both point out, the difference between the two works both in substance
and in method is such as to make it clear that the shorter form is a
revised abridgment of the longer. That Eusebius himself was the author
of the shorter as well as of the longer form is shown by the fact that
not only in the passages common to both recensions, but also in those
peculiar to the shorter one, the author speaks in the same person and
as an eye-witness of many of the events which he records. And still
further, in Chap. 11 he speaks of having himself written the
Life of
Pamphilus
in three books, a notice which is wanting in the longer
form and therefore must emanate from the hand of the author of the
shorter. It is interesting to inquire after Eusebius’ motive in
publishing an abridged edition of this work. Cureton supposes that he
condensed it simply for the purpose of inserting it in the second
edition of his
History
. Lightfoot, on the other hand, suggests
that it may have formed “part of a larger work, in which the
sufferings of the martyrs were set off against the deaths of the
persecutors,” and he is inclined to see in the brief appendix to
the eighth book of the
History
(translated below on p. 340)
“a fragment of the second part of the treatise of which the
Martyrs of Palestine
in the shorter recension formed the
first.” The suggestion is, to say the least, very plausible. If
it be true, the attachment of the shorter form of the
Martyrs of
Palestine
to the
Ecclesiastical History
was probably the
work, not of Eusebius himself, but of some copyist or copyists, and the
disagreement among the various
mss.
as to its
position in the
History
is more easily explained on this
supposition than on Cureton’s theory that it was attached to a
later edition of the latter work by Eusebius himself.
The date at which the
Martyrs of Palestine
was composed
cannot be determined with certainty. It was at any rate not published
until after the first nine books of the
Ecclesiastical History
(i.e. not before 313, see below, p. 45), for it is referred to as a
projected work in
H. E
. VIII. 13. 7. On the other hand, the
accounts contained in the longer recension bear many marks of having
been composed on the spot, while the impressions left by the martyrdoms
witnessed by the author were still fresh upon him. Moreover, it is
noticeable that in connection with the account of Pamphilus’
martyrdom, given in the shorter recension, reference is made to the
Life of Pamphilus
as a book already published, while in the
corresponding account in the longer recension no such book is referred
to. This would seem to indicate that the
Life of Pamphilus
was
written after the longer, but before the shorter recension of the
Martyrs
. But on the other hand the
Life
was written
before the
Ecclesiastical History
(see above, p. 29), and
consequently before the publication of either recension of the
Martyrs
. May it not be that the accounts of the various
martyrdoms were written, at least some of them, during the persecution,
but that they were not arranged, completed, and published until 313, or
later? If this be admitted we may suppose that the account of
Pamphilus’ martyrdom was written soon after his death and before
the
Life
was begun. When it was later embodied with the other
accounts in the one work
On the Martyrs of Palestine
it may have
been left just as it was, and it may not have occurred to the author to
insert a reference to the
Life of Pamphilus
which had meanwhile
been published. But when he came to abridge and in part rewrite for a
new edition the accounts of the various martyrdoms contained in the
work
On Martyrs
he would quite naturally refer the reader to the
Life
for fuller particulars.
If we then suppose that the
greater part of the longer recension of the
Martyrs
was already
complete before the end of the persecution, it is natural to conclude
that the whole work was published at an early date, probably as soon as
possible after the first edition of the
History
. How much later
the abridgment was made we cannot tell.
5
The differences between the two
recensions lie chiefly in the greater fullness of detail on the part of
the longer one. The arrangement and general mode of treatment is the
same in both. They contain accounts of the Martyrs that suffered in
Palestine during the years 303–310, most of whom Eusebius himself
saw.
Collection of Ancient
Martyrdoms
(
ἀρχαίων
μαρτυρίων
συναγωγή
). This work is mentioned by Eusebius in his
H. E.
IV. 15,
V. præf., 4, 21. These notices indicate that it was not an
original
composition, but simply a compilation; a collection of extant
accounts of martyrdoms which had taken place before Eusebius’
day. The work is no longer extant, but the accounts of the martyrdom of
Pamphilus and others at Smyrna, of the persecution in Lyons and Vienne,
and of the defense of Apollonius in Rome, which Eusebius inserts in his
Ecclesiastical History
(IV. 15, V. 1, V. 21), are taken, as he
informs us, from this collection. As to the time of compilation, we can
say only that it antedates the composition of the earlier books of the
History
(on whose date, see below, p. 45).
Chronicle
(
χρονικοὶ
κανόνες
).
Eusebius refers to this work in his
Church History
(I. 1), in
his
Præparatio Evang
. X. 9, and at the beginning of his
Eclogæ propheticæ
. It is divided into two books, the
first of which consists of an epitome of universal history drawn from
various sources, the second of chronological tables, which
“exhibit in parallel columns the succession of the rulers of
different nations in such a way that the reader can see at a glance
with whom any given monarch was contemporary.” The tables
“are accompanied by notes, marking the years of some of the more
remarkable historical events, these notes also constituting an epitome
of history.” Eusebius was not the first Christian writer to
compose a work on universal chronology. Julius Africanus had published
a similar work early in the third century, and from that Eusebius drew
his model and a large part of the material for his own work. At the
same time his
Chronicle
is more than a simple revision of
Africanus’ work, and contains the result of much independent
investigation on his own part. The work of Africanus is no longer
extant, and that of Eusebius was likewise lost for a great many
centuries, being superseded by a revised Latin edition, issued by
Jerome. Jerome’s edition, which comprises only the second book of
Eusebius’
Chronicle
, is a translation of the original
work, enlarged by notices taken from various writers concerning human
history, and containing a continuation of the chronology down to his
own time. This, together with numerous Greek fragments preserved by
various ancient writers, constituted our only source for a knowledge of
the original work, until late in the last century an Armenian
translation of the whole work was discovered and published in two
volumes by J. B. Aucher: Venice, 1818. The Armenian translation
contains a great many errors and not a few
lacunæ
, but it
is our most valuable source for a knowledge of the original
work.
The aim of the
Chronicle
was, above all, apologetic, the author wishing to prove by means of it
that the Jewish religion, of which the Christian was the legitimate
continuation, was older than the oldest of heathen cults, and thus
deprive pagan opponents of their taunt of novelty, so commonly hurled
against Christianity. As early as the second century, the Christian
apologists had emphasized the antiquity of Judaism; but Julius
Africanus was the first to devote to the matter scientific study, and
it was with the same idea that Eusebius followed in his footsteps. The
Chronology
, in spite of its errors, is invaluable for the light
it throws on many otherwise dark periods of history, and for the
numerous extracts it contains from works no longer extant.
There are good and sufficient
reasons (as is pointed out by Salmon in his article in Smith and
Wace’s
Dictionary of Christian Biography
) for supposing
that two editions of the
Chronicle
were published by Eusebius.
But two of these reasons need be stated here: first, the chronology of
the Armenian version differs from that of Jerome’s edition in
many important particulars, divergencies which can be satisfactorily
accounted for only on the supposition of a difference in the sources
from which they respectively drew; secondly, Jerome states directly
that the work was brought down to the
vicennalia
of
Constantine,—that is, to the year 325,—but the
Chronicle
is referred to as an already published work in the
Eclogæ propheticæ
(I. 1), and in the
Præparatio Evang
. (X. 9), both of which were written before
313. We may conclude, then, that a first edition of the work was
published during, or more probably before, the great persecution, and
that a second and revised edition was issued probably in 325, or soon
thereafter.
For further particulars in
regard to the
Chronicle
see especially the article of Salmon
already referred to. The work has been issued separately a great many
times. We may refer here to the edition of Scaliger, which was
published in 1606 (2d ed. 1658), in which he attempted
to restore the Greek
text from the fragments of Syncellus and other ancient writers, and to
the new edition of Mai, which was printed in 1833 in his
Scriptorum
veterum nova collectio
, Tom. VIII., and reprinted by Migne,
Eusebii Opera
, I. 99–598. The best and most recent
edition, however, and the one which supersedes all earlier editions, is
that of Alfred Schoene, in two volumes: Berlin, 1875 and
1866.
Ecclesiastical
History
(
ἐκκλησιαστικὴ
ἱστορία
).
For a discussion of this work see below, p. 45 sq.
Life of
Constantine
(
εἰς τὸν βίον
τοῦ μακαρίου
Κωνσταντίνου
τοῦ
βασιλέως
). For particulars in regard to this work, see the prolegomena of
Dr. Richardson, on pp. 466–469 sq., of this volume.
II.
Apologetic
Works.
Against Hierocles
(
πρὸς τοὺς
ὑπὲρ
᾽Απολλωνίου
τοῦ τυανέως
῾Ιεροκλέους
λόγους
, as
Photius calls it in his
Bibl
. 39). Hierocles was governor of
Bithynia during the early years of the Diocletian persecution, and
afterwards governor of Egypt. In both places he treated the Christians
with great severity, carrying out the edicts of the emperors to the
fullest extent, and even making use of the most terrible and loathsome
forms of persecution (see Lactantius,
De Mort. Pers
. 16, and
Eusebius,
Mart. Pal
. 5, Cureton’s ed. p. 18). He was at
the same time a Neo-Platonic philosopher, exceedingly well versed in
the Scriptures and doctrines of the Christians. In a work against the
Christians entitled
λόγος
φιλαλήθης
πρὸς τοὺς
χριστιανούς
, he brought forward many scriptural difficulties and
alleged contradictions, and also instituted a comparison between Christ
and Apollonius of Tyana, with the intention of disparaging the former.
Eusebius feels called upon to answer the work, but confines himself
entirely to that part of it which concerned Christ and Apollonius,
leaving to some future time a refutation of the remainder of the work,
which indeed, he says, as a mere reproduction of the arguments of
Celsus, had been already virtually answered by Origen (see chap. 1).
Eusebius admits that Apollonius was a good man, but refuses to concede
that he was anything more, or that he can be compared with Christ. He
endeavors to show that the account of Apollonius given by Philostratus
is full of contradictions and does not rest upon trustworthy evidence.
The tone of the book is mild, and the arguments in the main sound and
well presented. It is impossible to fix the date of the work with any
degree of certainty. Valesius assigns it to the later years of the
persecution, when Eusebius visited Egypt; Stein says that it may have
been written about 312 or 313, or even earlier; while Lightfoot simply
remarks, “it was probably one of the earliest works of
Eusebius.” There is no ground for putting it at one time rather
than another except the intrinsic probability that it was written soon
after the work to which it was intended to be a reply. In fact, had a
number of years elapsed after the publication of Hierocles’
attack, Eusebius would doubtless, if writing against it at all, have
given a fuller and more complete refutation of it, such as he suggests
in the first chapter that he may yet give. The work of Hierocles,
meanwhile, must have been written at any rate some time before the end
of the persecution, for it is mentioned in Lactantius’
Div.
Inst
. V. 2.
Eusebius’ work has been
published by Gaisford:
Eusebii Pamph. contra Hieroclem et Marcellum
libri
, Oxon. 1852; and also in various editions of the works of
Philostratus. Migne,
Opera
IV. 795 sq., reprints it from
Olearius’ edition of Philostratus’ works (Lips.
1709).
Against Porphyry
(
κατὰ
Πορφυρίον
). Porphyry, the celebrated Neo-Platonic philosopher,
regarded by the early Fathers as the bitterest and most dangerous enemy
of the Church, wrote toward the end of the third century a work against
Christianity in fifteen books, which was looked upon as the most
powerful attack that had ever been made, and which called forth
refutations from some of the greatest Fathers of the age: from
Methodius of Tyre, Eusebius of Cæsarea, and Apollinaris of
Laodicea; and even as late as the end of the fourth or beginning of the
fifth century the historian Philostorgius thought it necessary to write
another reply to it (see his
H. E.
X. 10). Porphyry’s work
is no longer extant, but the fragments of it which remain show us that
it was both learned and skillful. He made much of the alleged
contra
dictions in the Gospel records, and suggested difficulties which
are still favorite weapons in the hands of skeptics. Like the work of
Porphyry, and all the other refutations of it, the Apology of Eusebius
has entirely perished. It is mentioned by Jerome (
de vir. ill
.
81 and
Ep. ad Magnum
, §3, Migne’s ed.
Ep
. 70),
by Socrates (
H. E.
III. 23), and by Philostorgius (
H. E.
VIII. 14). There is some dispute as to the number of books it
contained. In his
Ep. ad Magn
. Jerome says that “Eusebius
et Apollinaris viginti quinque, et triginta volumina
condiderunt,” which implies that it was composed of twenty-five
books; while in his
de ver. ill
. 81, he speaks of thirty books,
of which he had seen only twenty. Vallarsi says, however, that all his
mss.
agree in reading
“twenty-five” instead of “thirty” in the latter
passage, so that it would seem that the vulgar text is
incorrect.
It is impossible to form an
accurate notion of the nature and quality of Eusebius’
refutation. Socrates speaks of it in terms of moderate praise
(“which [i.e. the work of Porphyry] has been ably answered by
Eusebius”), and Jerome does the same in his
Ep. ad Magnum
(“Alteri [i.e. Porphyry] Methodius, Eusebius, et Apollinaris
fortissime responderunt”). At the same time the fact that
Apollinaris and others still thought it necessary to write against
Porphyry would seem to show that Eusebius’ refutation was not
entirely satisfactory. In truth, Jerome (
Ep. ad Pammachium et
Oceanum
, §2, Migne’s ed.
Ep
. 84) appears to rank
the work of Apollinaris above that of Eusebius, and Philostorgius
expressly states that the former far surpassed the latter (
ἐπὶ πολὺ
κρατεῖν
ἠγωνισμένων
᾽Ευσεβί& 251·
κατ᾽ αὐτοῦ
). The date of Eusebius’ work cannot be determined.
The fact that he never refers to it, although he mentions the work of
Porphyry a number of times, has been urged by Valesius and others as
proof that he did not write it until after 325
a.d.
; but it is quite possible to explain his silence, as
Lardner does, by supposing that his work was written in his earlier
years, and that afterward he felt its inferiority and did not care to
mention it. It seems, in fact, not unlikely that he wrote it as early,
or even earlier than his work against Hierocles, at any rate before his
attention was occupied with the Arian controversy and questions
connected with it.
On the Numerous Progeny of
the Ancients
(
περὶ τῆς τῶν
παλαιῶν
ἀνδρῶν
πολυπαιδίας
). This work is mentioned by Eusebius in his
Præp.
Evang
. VII. 8. 20 (Migne,
Opera
, III. 525), but by no one
else, unless it be the book to which Basil refers in his
De Spir.
Sancto
, 29, as
Difficulties respecting the Polygamy of the
Ancients
. The work is no longer extant, but we can gather from the
connection in which it is mentioned in the
Præparatio
, that
it aimed at accounting for the polygamy of the Patriarchs and
reconciling it with the ascetic ideal of the Christian life which
prevailed in the Church of Eusebius’ lifetime. It would therefore
seem to have been written with an apologetic purpose.
Præparatio
Evangelica
(
προπαρασκευὴ
εὐαγγελική
) and
Demonstratio Evangelica
(
᾽Ευαγγελικὴ
ἀπόδειξις
). These two treatises together constitute Eusebius’
greatest apologetic work. The former is directed against heathen, and
aims to show that the Christians are justified in accepting the sacred
books of the Hebrews and in rejecting the religion and philosophy of
the Greeks. The latter endeavors to prove from the sacred books of the
Hebrews themselves that the Christians do right in going beyond the
Jews, in accepting Jesus as their Messiah, and in adopting another mode
of life. The former is therefore in a way a preparation for the latter,
and the two together constitute a defense of Christianity against all
the world, Jews as well as heathen. In grandeur of conception, in
comprehensiveness of treatment, and in breadth of learning, this
apology undoubtedly surpasses all other apologetic works of antiquity.
Lightfoot justly says, “This great apologetic work exhibits the
same merits and defects which we find elsewhere in Eusebius. There is
the same greatness of conception marred by the same inadequacy of
execution, the same profusion of learning combined with the same
inability to control his materials, which we have seen in his
History
. The divisions are not kept distinct; the topics start
up unexpectedly and out of season. But with all its faults this is
probably the most important apologetic work of the early Church. It
necessarily lacks the historical interest of the apologetic
writings of the
second century; it falls far short of the thoughtfulness and
penetration which give a permanent value to Origen’s treatise
against Celsus as a defense of the faith; it lags behind the Latin
apologists in rhetorical vigor and expression. But the forcible and
true conceptions which it exhibits from time to time, more especially
bearing on the theme which may be briefly designated ‘God in
history,’ arrest our attention now, and must have impressed his
contemporaries still more strongly; while in learning and
comprehensiveness it is without a rival.” The wide acquaintance
with classical literature exhibited by Eusebius in the
Præparatio
is very remarkable. Many writers are referred to
whose names are known to us from no other source, and many extracts are
given which constitute our only fragments of works otherwise totally
lost. The
Præparatio
thus does for classical much what the
History
does for Christian literature.
A very satisfactory summary of
the contents of the
Præparatio
is given at the beginning of
the fifteenth book. In the first, second, and third books, the author
exposes the absurdities of heathen mythology, and attacks the
allegorical theology of the Neo-Platonists; in the fourth and fifth
books he discusses the heathen oracles; in the sixth he refutes the
doctrine of fate; in the seventh he passes over to the Hebrews,
devoting the next seven books to an exposition of the excellence of
their system, and to a demonstration of the proposition that Moses and
the prophets lived before the greatest Greek writers, and that the
latter drew their knowledge from the former; in the fourteenth and
fifteenth books he exposes the contradictions among Greek philosophers
and the vital errors in their systems, especially in that of the
Peripatetics. The
Præparatio
is complete in fifteen books,
all of which are still extant.
The
Demonstratio
consisted originally of twenty books (see Jerome’s
de vir.
ill
. 81, and Photius’
Bibl
. 10). Of these only ten are
extant, and even in the time of Nicephores Callistus no more were
known, for he gives the number of the books as ten (
H. E.
VI.
37). There exists also a fragment of the fifteenth book, which was
discovered and printed by Mai (
Script. vet. nova coll
. I. 2, p.
173). In the first book, which is introductory, Eusebius shows why the
Christians pursue a mode of life different from that of the Jews,
drawing a distinction between Hebraism, the religion of all pious men
from the beginning, and Judaism, the special system of the Jews, and
pointing out that Christianity is a continuation of the former, but a
rejection of the latter, which as temporary has passed away. In the
second book he shows that the calling of the Gentiles and the
repudiation of the Jews are foretold in Scripture. In books three to
nine he discusses the humanity, divinity, incarnation, and earthly life
of the Saviour, showing that all were revealed in the prophets. In the
remainder of the work we may assume that the same general plan was
followed, and that Christ’s death, resurrection, and ascension,
and the spread of his Church, were the subjects discussed in this as in
nearly all works of the kind.
There is much dispute as to the
date of these two works. Stroth and Cave place them after the Council
of Nicæa, while Valesius, Lightfoot, and others, assign them to
the ante-Nicene period. In two passages in the
History
Eusebius
has been commonly supposed to refer to the
Demonstratio
(
H.
E
. I. 2 and 6), but it is probable that the first, and quite likely
the second also, refers to the
Eclogæ Proph
. We can,
therefore, base no argument upon those passages. But in
Præp.
Evang
. XII. 10 (
Opera
, III. 969) there is a reference to the
persecution, which seems clearly to imply that it was still continuing;
and in the
Demonstratio
(III. 5 and IV. 6;
Opera
, IV. 213
and 307), which was written after the
Præparatio
, are still
more distinct indications of the continuance of the persecution. On the
other hand, in V. 3 and VI. 20 (
Opera
, IV. 364 and 474) there
are passages which imply that the persecution has come to an end. It
seems necessary then to conclude, with Lightfoot, that the
Demonstratio
was begun during the persecution, but not completed
until peace had been established. The
Præparatio
, which was
completed before the
Demonstratio
was begun (see the
proœmium
to the latter), must have been finished during the
persecution. It contains in X. 9 (
Opera
, III. 807) a reference
to the
Chronicle
as an already published work (see above, p.
31).
The
Præparatio
and
Demonstratio
are found in
Migne’s edition of the
Opera
, III. and IV. 9 sq. A more
recent text is that of Dindorf in Teubner’s series, 1867. The
Præparatio
has been published separately by Heinichen, 2
vols., Lips. 1842, and by Gaisford, 4 vols., Oxon. 1843. The latter
contains a full critical apparatus with Latin translation and notes,
and is the most useful edition which we have. Seguier in 1846 published
a French translation with notes. The latter are printed in Latin in
Migne’s edition of the
Opera
, III. 1457 sq. The French
translation I have not seen.
The
Demonstratio
was also
published by Gaisford in 2 vols., Oxon. 1852, with critical apparatus
and Latin translation. Hænell has made the two works the subject
of a monograph entitled
De Eusebio Cæsariensi religionis
Christianæ Defensore
(Gottingæ, 1843) which I know only
from the mention of it by Stein and Lightfoot.
Præparatio
Ecclesiastica
(
᾽Εκκλησιαστικὴ
Προπαρασκευή
), and
Demonstratio Ecclesiastica
(
᾽Εκκλησιαστικὴ
᾽Απόδειξις
). These two works are no longer extant. We know of the
former only from Photius’ reference to it in
Bibl
. 11, of
the latter from his mention of it in
Bibl
. 12.
Lightfoot says that the latter
is referred to also in the
Jus Græco-Romanum
(lib. IV. p.
295; ed. Leunclav.). We know nothing about the works (except that the
first according to Photius contained extracts), and should be tempted
to think them identical with the
Præparatio
and
Demonstratio Evang
. were it not that Photius expressly mentions
the two latter in another part of his catalogue (
Bibl
. 10).
Lightfoot supposes that the two lost works did for the society what the
Præp
. and
Dem. Evang
. do for the doctrines of which
the society is the depositary, and he suggests that those portions of
the
Theophania
(Book IV.) which relate to the foundation of the
Church may have been adopted from the
Dem. Ecclesiastica
, as
other portions of the work (Book V.) are adopted from the
Dem.
Evang
.
If there is a reference in the
Præp. Evang
. I. 3 (
Opera
, III. 33) to the
Demonstratio Eccles
., as Lightfoot thinks there may be, and as
is quite possible, the latter work, and consequently in all probability
the
Præp. Eccles
. also, must have been written before 313
a.d.
Two Books of Objection and
Defense
(
᾽Ελέγχου καὶ
᾽Απολογίας
λόγοι δύο
). These are no longer extant, but are mentioned by Photius in his
Bibl
. 13. We gather from Photius’ language that two
editions of the work were extant in his time. The books, as Photius
clearly indicates, contained an apology for Christianity against the
attacks of the heathen, and not, as Cave supposed, a defense of the
author against the charge of Arianism. The tract mentioned by Gelasius
of Cyzicus (see below, p. 64) is therefore not to be identified with
this work, as Cave imagined that it might be.
Theophania
or
Divine Manifestation
(
θεοφ€νεια
). A Syriac version of this work is extant in the same
ms.
which contains the
Martyrs of
Palestine
, and was first published by Lee in 1842. In 1843 the same
editor issued an English translation with notes and extended
prolegomena (Cambridge, 1 vol.). The original work is no longer extant
in its entirety, but numerous Greek fragments were collected and
published by Mai in 1831 and 1833 (
Script. vet. nov. coll
. I.
and VIII.), and again with additions in 1847 (
Bibl. Nova Patrum
,
IV. 110 and 310; reprinted by Migne,
Opera
, VI. 607–690.
Migne does not give the Syriac version). The manuscript which contains
the Syriac version was written in 411, and Lee thinks that the
translation itself may have been made even during the lifetime of
Eusebius. At any rate it is very old and, so far as it is possible to
judge, seems to have reproduced the sense of the original with
comparative accuracy. The subject of the work is the manifestation of
God in the incarnation of the Word. It aims to give, with an apologetic
purpose, a brief exposition of the divine authority and influence of
Christianity. It is divided into five books which handle successively
the subject and the recipients of the revelation, that is, the Logos on
the one hand, and man on the other; the necessity of the revelation;
the proof of it drawn from its effects; the proof of it drawn from its
fulfillment of prophecy; finally, the common objections brought by the
heathen against Christ’s character and wonderful works. Lee says
of the work: “As a brief exposition of Christianity,
particularly of its
Divine authority, and amazing influence, it has perhaps never been
surpassed.” “When we consider the very extensive range of
inquiry occupied by our author, the great variety both of argument and
information which it contains, and the small space which it occupies;
we cannot, I think, avoid coming to the conclusion, that it is a very
extraordinary work, and one which is as suitable to our own times as it
was to those for which it was written. Its chief excellency is, that it
is argumentative, and that its arguments are well grounded, and
logically conducted.”
The
Theophania
contains
much that is found also in other works of Eusebius. Large portions of
the first, second, and third books are contained in the
Oratio de
Laudibus Constantini
, nearly the whole of the fifth book is given
in the
Dem. Evang
., while many passages occur in the
Præp. Evang
.
These coincidences assist us in
determining the date of the work. That it was written after persecution
had ceased and peace was restored to the Church, is clear from II. 76,
III. 20, 79, V. 52. Lee decided that it was composed very soon after
the close of the Diocletian persecution, but Lightfoot has shown
conclusively (p. 333) from the nature of the parallels between it and
other writings of Eusebius, that it must have been written toward the
end of his life, certainly later than the
De Laud. Const
. (335
a.d.
), and indeed it is not improbable that it
remained unfinished at the time of his death.
III.
Polemic
Works
.
Defense of Origen
(
᾽Απολογία
ὑπὲρ
᾽Ωριγένους
). This was the joint work of Eusebius and Pamphilus, as is
distinctly stated by Eusebius himself in his
H. E.
VI. 33, by
Socrates,
H. E.
III. 7, by the anonymous collector of the
Synodical Epistles
(
Ep
. 198), and by Photius,
Bibl
. 118. The last writer informs us that the work consisted of
six books, the first five of which were written by Eusebius and
Pamphilus while the latter was in prison, the last book being added by
the former after Pamphilus’ death (see above, p. 9). There is no
reason to doubt the statement of Photius, and we may therefore assign
the first five books to the years 307–309, and assume that the
sixth was written soon afterward. The
Defense
has perished, with
the exception of the first book, which was translated by Rufinus
(
Rufin. ad Hieron
. I. 582), and is still extant in his Latin
version. Rufinus ascribed this book expressly to Pamphilus, and
Pamphilus’ name alone appears in the translation. Jerome
(
Contra Ruf
. I. 8; II. 15, 23; III. 12) maintains that the whole
work was written by Eusebius, not by Pamphilus, and accuses Rufinus of
having deliberately substituted the name of the martyr Pamphilus for
that of the Arianizing Eusebius in his translation of the work, in
order to secure more favorable acceptance for the teachings of Origen.
Jerome’s unfairness and dishonesty in this matter have been
pointed out by Lightfoot (p. 340). In spite of his endeavor to saddle
the whole work upon Eusebius, it is certain that Pamphilus was a joint
author of it, and it is quite probable that Rufinus was true to his
original in ascribing to Pamphilus all the explanations which introduce
and connect the extracts from Origen, which latter constitute the
greater part of the book. Eusebius may have done most of his work in
connection with the later books.
The work was intended as a
defense of Origen against the attacks of his opponents (see
Eusebius’
H. E.
VI. 33, and the Preface to the
Defense
itself). According to Socrates (
H. E.
VI. 13),
Methodius, Eustathius, Apollinaris, and Theophilus all wrote against
Origen. Of these only Methodius had written before the composition of
the
Defense
, and he was expressly attacked in the sixth book of
that work, according to Jerome (
Contra Ruf
. I. 11). The wide
opposition aroused against Origen was chiefly in consequence not of his
personal character, but of his theological views. The
Apology
,
therefore, seems to have been devoted in the main to a defense of those
views over against the attacks of the men that held and taught opposite
opinions, and may thus be regarded as in some sense a regular polemic.
The extant book is devoted principally to a discussion of
Origen’s views on the Trinity and the Incarnation. It is not
printed in Migne’s edition of Eusebius’
Opera
, but
is published in the various editions of
Origen’s works (in
Lommatzsch’s edition, XXIV. 289–412). For further
particulars in regard to the work, see Delarue’s introduction to
it (Lommatzsch, XXIV. 263 sq.), and Lightfoot’s article on
Eusebius, pp. 340 and 341.
Against Marcellus, Bishop of
Ancyra
(
κατὰ
Μαρκέλλου
τοῦ ᾽Αγκύρας
ἐπισκόπου
). The occasion of this work has been already described (see
p. 25), and is explained by Eusebius himself in Book II. chap. 4. The
work must have been written soon after the Council at which Marcellus
was condemned. It aims simply to expose his errors, exegetical as well
as theological. The work consists of two books, and is still extant
(
Opera
, VI. 707–824).
On the Theology of the
Church, a Refutation of Marcellus
(
οἱ
πρὸς
Μ€ρκελλον
žλεγχοι περὶ
τῆς
ἐκκλησιαστικῆς
Θεολογίας
). The occasion of this work is stated in the first chapter.
In the previous work Eusebius had aimed merely to expose the opinions
of Marcellus, but in this he devotes himself to their refutation,
fearing that some might be led astray by their length and plausibility.
The work, which consists of three books, is still extant, and is given
by Migne in the
Opera
, VI. 825–1046. Both it and the
preceding are published with the
Contra Hieroclem
in
Gaisford’s
Euseb. Pamph. contra Hieroclem et Marcellum
,
Oxon. 1852. Zahn has written a valuable monograph entitled
Marcellus
von Ancyra
(Gotha, 1867).
Against the
Manicheans
. Epiphanius (
Hær
.
LXVI. 21) mentions, among other refutations of the Manicheans, one by
our Eusebius. The work is referred to nowhere else, and it is possible
that Epiphanius was mistaken in his reference, or that the refutation
he has in mind formed only a part of some other work, but we are hardly
justified in asserting, as Lightfoot does, that the work cannot have
existed.
IV.
Dogmatic
Works
.
General Elementary
Introduction
(
῾Η
καθόλου
στοιχειώδης
εἰσαγωγή
). This work consisted of ten books, as we learn from a reference
to it in the
Eclogæ Propheticæ
, IV. 35. It was
apparently a general introduction to the study of theology, and covered
a great variety of subjects. Five brief fragments have been preserved,
all of them apparently from the first book, which must have dealt
largely with general principles of ethics. The fragments were published
by Mai (
Bibl. Nova Patrum
, IV. 316), and are reprinted by Migne
(
Opera
, IV. 1271 sq.). In addition to these fragments, the
sixth, seventh, eighth, and ninth books of the work are extant under
the title:
Prophetical
Extracts
(
Προφητικαὶ
᾽Εκλογαί
). Although this formed a part of the larger work, it is complete
in itself, and circulated independently of the rest of the
Introduction
. It contains extracts of prophetical passages from
the Old Testament relating to the person and work of Christ,
accompanied by explanatory notes. It is divided into four books, the
first containing extracts from the historical Scriptures, the second
from the Psalms, the third from the other poetical books and from the
prophets, the fourth from Isaiah alone. The personality of the Logos is
the main topic of the work, which is thus essentially dogmatic, rather
than apologetic, as it might at first glance seem to be. It was
composed during the persecution, which is clearly referred to in Book
I. chap. 8 as still raging; it must have been written therefore between
303 and 313. The date of these books, of course, fixes the date of the
General Introduction
, of which they formed a part. The
Eclogæ
are referred to in the
History
, I. 2. On the
other hand, they mention the
Chronicle
as a work already written
(I. 1:
Opera
, p. 1023); a reference which goes to prove that
there were two editions of the
Chronicle
(see above, p. 31). The
four books of the
Prophetical Extracts
were first published by
Gaisford in 1842 (Oxford) from a Vienna
ms.
The
ms.
is mutilated in many places, and the
beginning, including the title of the work, is wanting. Migne has
reprinted Gaisford’s edition in the
Opera
, IV. 1017
sq.
On the Paschal
Festival
(
περὶ τῆς τοῦ
π€σχα ἑ&
231·ρτης
). This work,
as Eusebius informs us in his
Vita Const
. IV. 34, was addressed
to the Emperor Constantine, who commends it very highly in an epistle
to Eusebius preserved in the
Vita Const
. IV. 35. From this
epistle we learn, more
over, that the work had been translated into Latin. It is no
longer extant in its entirety, but a considerable fragment of it was
discovered by Mai in Nicetas’
Catena on Luke
, and
published by him in his
Bibl. Nova Patrum
, IV. p. 208 sq. The
extant portion of it contains twelve chapters, devoted partly to a
discussion of the nature of the Passover and its typical significance,
partly to an account of the settlement of the paschal question at the
Council of Nicæa, and partly to an argument against the necessity
of celebrating the paschal feast at the time of the Jewish Passover,
based on the ground that Christ himself did not keep the Passover on
the same day as the Jews.
Jerome, although he does not
mention this work in his catalogue of Eusebius’ writings (
de
vir. ill
. 81), elsewhere (
ib
. 61) states that Eusebius
composed a paschal canon with a cycle of nineteen years. This cycle may
have been published (as Lightfoot remarks) as a part of the writing
under discussion. The date of the work cannot be determined with
exactness. It was written after the Council of Nicæa, and, as
would seem from the connection in which it is mentioned in the
Vita
Constantini
, before the Emperor’s
tricennalia
(335
a.d.
), but not very long before. The extant
fragment, as published by Mai, is reprinted by Migne in the
Opera
, VI. 693–706.
V.
Critical
and Exegetical Works.
Biblical
Texts
. We learn from Jerome (
Præf.
in librum Paralip
.) that Eusebius and Pamphilus published a number
of copies of Origen’s edition of the LXX., that is, of the fifth
column of the Hexapla. A colophon found in a Vatican
ms.
, and given in facsimile in Migne’s
Opera
,
IV. 875, contains the following account of their labors (the
translation is Lightfoot’s): “It was transcribed from the
editions of the Hexapla, and was corrected from the Tetrapla of Origen
himself, which also had been corrected and furnished with scholia in
his own handwriting; whence I, Eusebius, added the scholia, Pamphilus
and Eusebius corrected [this copy].” Compare also Field’s
Hexapla
, I. p. xcix.
Taylor, in the
Dictionary of
Christian Biography
, III. p. 21, says: “The whole work [i.e.
the Hexapla] was too massive for multiplication; but many copies of its
fifth column alone were issued from Cæsarea under the direction of
Pamphilus the martyr and Eusebius, and this recension of the LXX. came
into common use. Some of the copies issued contained also marginal
scholia, which gave
inter alia
a selection of readings from the
remaining versions in the Hexapla. The oldest extant
ms.
of this recension is the Leiden
Codex
Sarravianus
of the fourth or fifth century.” These editions
of the LXX. must have been issued before the year 309, when Pamphilus
suffered martyrdom, and in all probability before 307, when he was
imprisoned (see Lardner’s
Credibility
, Part II. chap.
72.
In later years we find Eusebius
again engaged in the publication of copies of the Scriptures. According
to the
Vita Const
. IV. 36, 37, the Emperor wrote to Eusebius,
asking him to prepare fifty sumptuous copies of the Scriptures for use
in his new Constantinopolitan churches. The commission was carefully
executed, and the
mss.
prepared at great cost.
It has been thought that among our extant
mss.
may be some of these copies which were produced under Eusebius’
supervision, but this is extremely improbable (see Lightfoot, p.
334).
Ten Evangelical Canons, with
the Letter to Carpianus prefixed
(
κανόνες
δέκα
;
Canones decem
harmoniæ evangeliorum præmissa ad Carpianum epistola
).
Ammonius of Alexandria early in the third century had constructed a
harmony of the Gospels, in which, taking Matthew as the standard, he
placed alongside of that Gospel the parallel passages from the three
others. Eusebius’ work was suggested by this Harmony, as he tells
us in his epistle to Carpianus. An inconvenient feature of
Ammonius’ work was that only the Gospel of Matthew could be read
continuously, the sequence of the other Gospels being broken in order
to bring their parallel sections into the order followed by Matthew.
Eusebius, desiring to remedy this defect, constructed his work on a
different principle. He made a table of ten canons, each containing a
list of passages as follows: Canon I. passages common to all four
Gospels; II. those common to Matthew, Mark, and Luke; III. those
common to Matt.,
Luke, and John; IV. those common to Matt., Mark, and John; V. those
common to Matthew and Luke; VI. those common to Matt. and Mark; VII.
those common to Matt. and John; VIII. those common to Luke and Mark;
IX. those common to Luke and John; X. those peculiar to each Gospel:
first to Matthew, second to Mark, third to Luke, and fourth to
John.
Each Gospel was then divided
into sections, which were numbered continuously. The length of the
section was determined, not by the sense, but by the table of canons,
each section comprising a passage common to four, to three, to two
Gospels, or peculiar to itself, as the case might be. A single section
therefore might comprise even less than a verse, or it might cover more
than a chapter. The sections were numbered in black, and below each
number was placed a second figure in red, indicating the canon to which
the section belonged. Upon glancing at that canon the reader would find
at once the numbers of the parallel sections in the other Gospels, and
could turn to them readily. The following is a specimen of a few lines
of the first canon:—
MT.
MP.
Λ.
ΙΩ.
η
β
ζ
ι
ια
δ
ι
ς
ια
δ
ι
ιβ
ια
δ
ι
ιδ
Thus, opposite a certain passage
in John, the reader finds
ιβ
(12) written, and beneath
it, Α (1). He
therefore turns to the first canon (A) and finds that sections
ια
(11) in
Matthew,
δ
(4) in Mark, and
ι
(10) in Luke are parallel
with
ιβ
in John. The advantage and convenience of such a system are
obvious, and the invention of it shows great ingenuity. It has indeed
never been superseded, and the sections and canons are still indicated
in the margins of many of our best Greek Testaments (e.g., in those of
Tregelles and of Tischendorf). The date of the construction of these
canons it is quite impossible to determine. For further particulars in
regard to them, see Lightfoot’s article on Eusebius, p. 334 sq.,
and Scrivener’s
Introduction to the Criticism of the New
Testament,
2d ed. p. 54 sq. The canons, with the letter to
Carpianus prefixed, are given by Migne,
Opera,
IV.
1275–1292.
Gospel Questions and
Solutions.
This work consists of two parts,
or of two separate works combined. The first bears the title
Gospel
Questions and Solutions addressed to Stephanus
(
πρὸς
Στέφανον
περὶ τῶν ἐν
εὐαγγελίοις
ζητημ€των
καὶ λύσεων
), and is referred to by Eusebius in his
Dem. Evang.
VII. 3, as
Questions and Solutions on the Genealogy of our
Saviour
(
τῶν
εἰς τὴν
γενεαλογίαν
τοῦ σωτῆρος
ἡμῶν
ζητημ€των
καὶ λύσεων
). The second part is entitled
Gospel Questions and
Solutions addressed to Marinus
(
πρὸς
Μαρῖνον
).
The first work consisted of two books, we learn from the opening of the
second work. In that passage, referring to the previous work, Eusebius
says that having discussed there the difficulties which beset the
beginning of the Gospels, he will now proceed to consider questions
concerning the latter part of them, the intermediate portions being
omitted. He thus seems to regard the two works as in a sense forming
parts of one whole. In his
de vir ill.
81, Jerome mentions among
the writings of Eusebius one
On the Discrepancy of the Gospels (De
Evangeliorum Diaphonia),
and in his
Comm. in Matt.
chap. I.
vers. 16, he refers to Eusebius’
libri
διαφωνίας
εὐαγγελίων
. Ebedjesu also remarks, “Eusebius Cæsariensis
composuit librum solutionis contradictionum evangelii.” In the
sixteenth century there were found in Sicily, according to the
announcement of Latino Latini, “libri tres Eusebii
Cæsariensis de Evangeliorum diaphonia,” but nothing more has
been heard or seen of this Sicilian
ms.
There
can be no doubt that the work referred to under the title
De
Evangeliorum Diaphonia
is identical with the
Gospel Questions
and Solutions,
for the discrepancies in the Gospels occupy a
considerable space in the
Questions and Solutions
as we have it,
and the word
διαφωνία
occurs frequently. The three books mentioned by Latino
Latini were therefore the two books addressed to Stephanus which
Eusebius himself refers to, and the one book addressed to Marinus. The
complete work is no longer extant, but an epitome of
it was discovered and
published by Mai, together with numerous fragments of the unabridged
work, two of them in Syriac (
Bibl. Nova Patrum,
IV. 217 sq.;
reprinted by Migne,
Opera,
IV. 879–1016). In the epitome
the work addressed to Stephanus consists of sixteen chapters, and the
division into two books is not retained. The work addressed to Marinus
consists of only four chapters.
The work purports to have been
written in answer to questions and difficulties suggested by Stephanus
and Marinus, who are addressed by Eusebius in terms of affection and
respect. The first work is devoted chiefly to a discussion of the
genealogies of Christ, as given by Matthew and Luke; the second work
deals with the apparent discrepancies between the accounts of the
resurrection as given by the different evangelists. Eusebius does not
always reach a solution of the difficulties, but his work is suggestive
and interesting. The question as to the date of the work is complicated
by the fact that there is in the
Dem. Evang.
VII. 3 a reference
to the
Questions and Solutions addressed to Stephanus,
while in
the epitome of the latter work (
Quæst.
VII. §7) there
is a distinct reference to the
Demonstratio Evang.
This can be
satisfactorily explained only by supposing, with Lightfoot, that the
Epitome was made at a later date than the original work, and that then
Eusebius inserted this reference to the
Demonstratio.
We are
thus led to assume two editions of this work, as of the others of
Eusebius’ writings, the second edition being a revised
abridgement of the first. The first edition, at least of the
Quæstiones ad Stephanum,
must have been published before
the
Demonstratio Evangelica.
We cannot fix the date of the
epitome, nor of the
Quæstiones ad Marinum.
Commentary on the
Psalms
(
εἰς τοὺς
ψαλμούς
).
This commentary is extant entire as far as the 118th psalm, but from
that point to the end only fragments of it have been preserved. It was
first published in 1707, by Montfaucon, who, however, knew nothing of
the fragments of the latter part of the work. These were discovered and
published by Mai, in 1847 (
Bibl. Nov. Patrum,
IV. 65 sq.), and
the entire extant work, including these fragments, is printed by Migne,
Opera,
V. and VI. 9–76. According to Lightfoot, notices of
extant Syriac extracts from it are found in Wright’s
Catal.
Syr.
mss.
Brit. Mus.
pp. 35 sq. and 125.
Jerome (
de vir. ill.
96 and
Ep. ad Vigilantium,
§2;
Migne’s ed.
Ep.
61) informs us that Eusebius of
Vercellæ translated this commentary into Latin, omitting the
heretical passages. This version is no longer extant. The commentary
had a high reputation among the Fathers, and justly so. It is
distinguished for its learning, industry, and critical acumen. The
Hexapla
is used with great diligence, and the author frequently
corrects the received LXX. text of his day upon the authority of one of
the other versions. The work betrays an acquaintance with Hebrew,
uncommon among the Fathers, but by no means extensive or exact.
Eusebius devotes considerable attention to the historical relations of
the Psalms, and exhibits an unusual degree of good judgment in their
treatment, but the allegorical method of the school of Origen is
conspicuous, and leads him into the mystical extravagances so common to
patristic exegesis.
The work must have been written
after the close of the persecution and the death of the persecutors
(
in Psal
. XXXVI. 12). In another passage (
in Psal
.
LXXXVII. 11) there seems to be a reference to the discovery of the site
of the Holy Sepulchre and the erection of Constantine’s basilica
upon it (see
Vita Const.
III. 28, 30, &c.). The basilica was
dedicated in the year 335 (see above, p. 24), and the site of the
sepulchre was not discovered until the year 326, or later (see
Lightfoot, p. 336). The commentary must have been written apparently
after the basilica was begun, and probably after its completion. If so,
it is to be placed among the very latest of Eusebius’
works.
Commentary on
Isaiah
(
ὑπομνήματα
εἰς
῾Ησαΐαν
).
This work is also extant almost entire, and was first published in
1706, by Montfaucon (
Coll. Nova Patrum et Script. Græc.
II.; reprinted by Migne,
Opera,
VI. 77–526). In his
de
vir. ill.
81 Jerome refers to it as containing ten books (
in
Isaiam libri decem
), but in the preface to his
Comment. in
Isaiam
he speaks of it as composed of fifteen (
Eusebius quoque
Pamphili juxta historicam explanationem quindecim edidit
volumina
). In its present form there
is no trace of a division into books. The commentary is marked by the
same characteristics which were noticed in connection with the one on
the Psalms, though it does not seem to have acquired among the ancients
so great a reputation as that work. It must have been written after the
close of the persecution (
in Is
. XLIV. 5), and apparently after
the accession of Constantine to sole power (
in Is
. XLIX. 23
compared with
Vita Const.
IV. 28). If the commentary on the
Psalms was written toward the close of Eusebius’ life, as assumed
above, it is natural to conclude that the present work preceded
that.
Commentary on Luke
(
εἰς
τὸ κατὰ
Λουκᾶν
εὐαλλέλιον
). This work is no longer extant, but considerable
fragments of it exist and have been published by Mai (
Bibl. Nova
Patrum,
IV. 159 sq.; reprinted by Migne,
Opera,
VI.
529–606). Although the fragments are all drawn from Catenæ
on Luke, there are many passages which seem to have been taken from a
commentary on Matthew (see the notes of the editor). A number of
extracts from the work are found in Eusebius’
Theophania
(see Mai’s introduction to his fragments of the latter
work).
The date of the commentary
cannot be fixed with certainty, but I am inclined to place it before
the persecution of Diocletian, for the reason that there appears in the
work, so far as I have discovered, no hint of a persecution, although
the passages expounded offer many opportunities for such a reference,
which it is difficult to see how the author could have avoided making
if a persecution were in progress while he was writing; and further,
because in discussing Christ’s prophecies of victory and dominion
over the whole world, no reference is made to the triumph gained by the
Church in the victories of Constantine. A confirmation of this early
date may be found in the extreme simplicity of the exegesis, which
displays neither the wide learning, nor the profound study that mark
the commentaries on the Psalms and on Isaiah.
Commentary on the First
Epistle to the Corinthians.
This work is no
longer extant, and we know of it only from a reference in
Jerome’s
Ep. ad Pammachium,
§3 (Migne’s ed.
Ep.
49): “Origenes, Dionysius, Pierius, Eusebius
Cæsariensis, Didymus, Apollinaris latissime hanc Epistolam
interpretati sunt.”
Exegetical
Fragments.
Mai has published brief
fragments containing expositions of passages from
Proverbs
(
Bibl. Nova Patrum,
IV. 316; reprinted by Migne,
Opera,
VI. 75–78), from
Daniel
(
ib.
p. 314; Migne, VI.
525–528), and from the
Epistle to the Hebrews
(
ib.
p. 207; Migne, VI. 605). Fabricius mentions also fragments from a
commentary on the
Song of Songs
as published by Meursius, and
says that other commentaries are referred to by Montfaucon in his
Epistola de Therapeutis,
p. 151. We have no references in the
works of the ancients to any such commentaries, so far as I am aware,
and it is quite possible that the various fragments given by Mai, as
well as those referred to by Fabricius may have been taken not from
continuous commentaries, but from Eusebius’
General Elementary
Introduction,
or others of his lost works. According to Migne (VI.
527) some Greek Catenæ published by Cramer in Oxford in the year
1884 contain extensive fragments on Matthew and John, which, however,
have been taken from Eusebius’
Quæst. Evang.
Other
fragments in Catenæ on the same Evangelists and on Mark, have been
taken, according to Migne, from the
Quæstiones ad
Stephanum,
or from the
Commentary on Luke.
It is, however, quite possible,
as it seems to me, that Eusebius wrote a commentary on Daniel. At any
rate, the exegetical fragments which we have, taken with the extended
discussions of certain passages found in the
Dem. Evang.
VIII. 2
and in the
Eclogæ Proph.
III. 40 sq., show that he
expounded at one time or another a considerable portion of the
book.
VI.
Biblical
Dictionaries
.
Interpretation of the
Ethnological Terms in the Hebrew Scriptures.
This work is no longer extant, but is known to us from
Eusebius’ reference to it in the preface to his work
On the
Names of Places,
where he writes as follows:
τῶν ἀνὰ τὴν
οἰκουμένην
ἐθνῶν ἐπὶ
τὴν ἑλλ€δα
φωνὴν
μεταβαλὼν
τὰς ἐν τῇ
θεί& 139· γραφῇ
κειμένας
ἑβραίοις
ὀνόμασι
προσρήσεις
. Jerome, in the preface to his Latin version of the same
work, also refers to it in the following words:
“…diversarum
vocabula nationum, quæ
quomodo olim apud Hebræos dicta sint, et nunc dicantur,
exposuit.” No other ancient authority mentions the work so far as
I am aware.
Chorography of Ancient Judea
with the Inheritances of the Ten Tribes.
This work too is lost, but is referred to by Eusebius in the same
preface in the following words:
τῆς π€λαι
᾽Ιουδαίας
ἀπὸ π€σης
Βίβλου
καταγραφὴν
πεποιημένος
καὶ τὰς ἐν
αὐτῇ τῶν
δώδεκα φυλῶν
διαιρῶν
κλήρους
.
Jerome (
ib.
) says: “…Chorographiam terræ
Judaeæ, et distinctas tribuum sortes
…laboravit.”
It is remarked by Fabricius that
this work is evidently intended by Ebedjesu in his catalogue, where he
mentions among the writings of Eusebius a
Librum de Figura Mundi
(cf. Assemani’s
Bibl. Orient.
III. p. 18, note
7).
A Plan of Jerusalem and of
the Temple, accompanied with Memoirs relating to the Various
Localities.
This too is lost, but is
referred to by Eusebius (
ib.
) in the following words:
ὡς ἐν
γραφῆς τύπῳ
τῆς π€λαι
διαβοήτου
μητροπόλεως
αὐτῆς
(
λέγω δὲ
τὴν
῾Ιερουσαλήμ
)
τοῦ
τε ἐν αὐτῇ
ἱεροῦ τὴν
εἰκόνα
διαχαρ€ξας
μετὰ
παραθέσεως
τῶν εἰς τοὺς
τύπους
ὑπομνημ€των
. Jerome (
ib.
) says: “ipsius quoque Jerusalem
templique in ea cum brevissima expositione picturam, ad extremum in hoc
opusculo laboravit.”
On the Names of Places in
Holy Scripture
(
περὶ τῶν
τοπικῶν
ὀνομ€των τῶν
ἐν τῇ θεί& 139·
γραφῇ
). In
Jerome’s version this work bears the title
Liber de Situ et
Nominibus Locorum Hebraicorum,
but in his
de vir. ill.
81,
he refers to it as
τοπικῶν
,
liber unus,
and so it is commonly called simply
Topica.
It is still extant, both in the original Greek and in a
revised and partly independent Latin version by Jerome. Both are
published by Vallarsi in
Hieronymi Opera,
III. 122 sq. Migne, in
his edition of Eusebius’ works, omits the
Topica
and
refers to his edition of Jerome’s works, where, however, he gives
only Jerome’s version, not the original Greek (III.
859–928). The best editions of the Greek text are by Larsow and
Parthey (
Euseb. Pamph. Episc. Cæs. Onomasticon,
&c.,
Berolini, 1862), and by Lagarde (
Onomastica Sacra,
I.
207–304, Gottingæ, 1870). The work aims to give, in the
original language, in alphabetical order, the names of the cities,
villages, mountains, rivers, &c., mentioned in the Scriptures,
together with their modern designations and brief descriptions of each.
The work is thus of the same character as a modern dictionary or
Biblical geography. The other three works were narrower than this one
in their scope, but seem also to have been arranged somewhat on the
dictionary plan. The work is dedicated to Paulinus, a fact which leads
us to place its composition before 325
a.d.
,
when Paulinus was already dead (see below, p. 369). Jerome, in the
preface to his version, says that Eusebius wrote the work after his
History
and
Chronicle.
We are to conclude, then, either
that the work was published in 324 or early in 325, within a very few
months after the
History,
or, what is more probable, that Jerome
is mistaken in his statement. He is proverbially careless and
inaccurate, and Eusebius, neither in his preface—from which
Jerome largely quotes in his own—nor in the work itself, gives
any hint of the fact that his
History
and
Chronicle
were
already written.
On the Nomenclature of the
Book of the Prophets
(
περὶ τῆς
τοῦ βιβλίου
τῶν προφητῶν
ὀνομασίας
καὶ ἀπὸ
μέρους τί
περιέχει
ἕκαστος
).
This work contains brief accounts of the several prophets and notes the
subjects of their prophecies. It is thus, so far as it goes, a sort of
biographical dictionary. It was first published by Curterius in his
Procopii Sophistæ Christinæ variarum in Isaiam Prophetam
commentationum epitome
(Paris, 1850, under the title
De vitis
Prophetarum,
by which it is commonly known. We have no means of
determining the date of its composition. Curterius’ text has been
reprinted by Migne,
Opera,
IV. 1261–1272.
VII.
Orations
.
Panegyric on the Building of
the Churches, addressed to Paulinus, Bishop of Tyre
(
Πανηγυρικὸς
ἐπὶ τῇ τῶν
ἐκκλησιῶν
οἰκοδομῇ,
Παυλίνῳ
Τυρίων
ἐπισκόπῳ
προσπεφωνημένος
). This oration was delivered at the dedication of
Paulinus’ new church in Tyre, to which reference has already been
made (see above, p. 11). It has been preserved in Eusebius’
History,
Book X. chap. 4 (see below, p. 370. sq.).
Oration delivered at the Vicennalia of
Constantine
. Eusebius refers to this in the
Preface to his
Vita Constantini
as
εἰκοσαετηρικοὶ
ὕμνοι
. It is to be
identified with the oration delivered at the opening of the Council of
Nicæa (
Vita Const
. III. 11), as stated above, on p. 19. It
is unfortunately no longer extant.
Oration on the Sepulchre of
the Saviour
. In his
Vita Const
. IV.
33 Eusebius informs us that he delivered an oration on this subject
(
ἀμφὶ τοῦ
σωτηρίου
μνήματος
λόγος
) in the
presence of the Emperor at Constantinople. In the same work, IV. 46, he
says that he wrote a description of the church of the Saviour and of
his sepulchre, as well as of the splendid presents given by the Emperor
for their adornment. This description he gave in a special work which
he addressed to the Emperor (
ἐν
οἰκεί& 251·
συγγρ€μματι
παραδόντες,
αὐτῷ βασιλεῖ
προσεφωνήσαμεν
). If these two are identical, as has always been assumed,
the
Oration on the Sepulchre
must have been delivered in 335,
when Eusebius went to Constantinople, just after the dedication of the
Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem (see above, p. 23), and just
before the
Oratio deo laudibus Constantini
(see
ib
. IV.
46). That the two are identical has always been assumed, and seems most
probable. At the same time it is worthy of notice that in IV. 33
Eusebius speaks as if he returned to Cæsarea immediately after
delivering his oration, and gives no hint of the delivery of his
De
laud. Const
. at that time. It is noticeable also that he speaks in
IV. 46 of a
work
(
σύγγραμμα
) not of an
oration
(
λόγος
), and that
in IV. 45 he mentions the fact that he has described the splendid
edifice and gifts of the Emperor
in writing
(
διὰ
γρ€μματος
), which would seem to imply something else than an address.
Finally, it is to be observed that, whereas, in IV. 46, he expressly
refers to the church erected by Constantine and to his rich gifts in
connection with its construction, in IV. 33 he refers only to the
sepulchre. It appears to me, in fact, quite possible that Eusebius may
be referring to two entirely different compositions, the one an oration
delivered after the discovery of the sepulchre and before the Emperor
had built the church (perhaps containing the suggestion of such a
building), the other a descriptive work written after the completion of
that edifice. I present this only as a possibility, for I realize that
against it may be urged the unlikelihood that two separate works should
have been composed by Eusebius upon subjects so nearly, if not quite,
identical, and also the probability that, if there were two, both, and
not one only, would have been attached to the end of the
Vita
Const
. with the
De laud Const
. (see IV. 46). Neither the
Oration on the Sepulchre of the Saviour
nor the
Work on the
Church and the Sepulchre
(whether the two are the same or not) is
now extant.
Oration delivered at the
Tricennalia of Constantine
(
εἰς
Κωνσταντῖνον
τὸν βασιλέα
τριακονταετηρικός
), commonly known under the title
Oratio de laudibus
Constantini
. In his
Vita Const
. IV. 46, Eusebius promised to
append this oration, together with the writing
On the Church and the
Sepulchre
, to that work. The
de laudibus
is still found at
the end of the
mss.
of the
Vita
, while
the other writing is lost. It was delivered in Constantinople in 335 on
the occasion of the Emperor’s
tricennalia
, very soon after
the dedication of the church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem (see
above, p. 25). It is highly panegyrical, but contains a great deal of
theology, especially in regard to the person and work of the Logos.
Large portions of it were afterward incorporated into the
Vita
Constantini
and the
Theophania
. The oration is published in
most, if not all, editions of the
Vita Constantini
; in Migne,
Opera
, II. 1315–1440.
Oration in Praise of the
Martyrs
. This oration is mentioned in the
catalogue of Ebedjesu (
et orationem de laudibus eorum
[i.e.
Martyrum Occidentalium]; see Assemani,
Bibl. Orient.
III. p.
19), and, according to Lightfoot, is still extant in a Syriac version,
which has been published in the
Journal of Sacred Literature
, N.
S., Vol. V. p. 403 sq., with an English translation by B. H. Cowper,
ib
. VI. p. 129 sq. Lightfoot finds in it an indication that it
was delivered at Antioch, but pronounces it of little value or
importance.
On the Failure of
Rain
. This is no longer extant, and is
known to us only from a reference in the catalogue of Ebedjesu (
et
orationem de defectu pluviæ
; see Assemani,
ib
.).
VIII.
Epistles.
To Alexander
, bishop of Alexandria. The purpose and the character of
this epistle have been already discussed (see above). A fragment of it
has been preserved in the Proceedings of the Second Council of
Nicæa, Act VI., Tom. V. (
Labbei et Cossartii Conc.
VII.
col. 497). For a translation of the epistle, see below. This and the
following epistle were written after the outbreak of the Arian
controversy, but before the Nicene Council.
To Euphration
, bishop of Balaneæ in Syria, likewise a strong
opponent of the Arians (see Athan.
de Fuga
, 3;
Hist. Ar. ad
Mon.
5). Athanasius states that this epistle declared plainly that
Christ is not God (Athan.
de Synod
. 17). A brief fragment of it
has been preserved in the Acts of the Second Council of Nicæa
(
l.c.
), which probably contains the very passage to which
Athanasius refers. Upon the interpretation and significance of the
fragment, see above.
To Constantia
Augusta
, the sister of Constantine and wife
of Licinius. Constantia had written to Eusebius requesting him to send
her a certain likeness of Christ of which she had heard. Eusebius, in
this epistle, rebukes her, and speaks strongly against the use of such
representations, on the ground that it tends toward idolatry. The tone
of the letter is admirable. Numerous fragments of it have been
discovered, so that we have it now almost entire. It is printed in
Migne,
Opera
, II. 1545–1550. We have no means of
ascertaining the date at which it was written.
To the Church of
Cæsarea
. This epistle was written from
Nicæa in 325
a.d.
, during or immediately
after the Council. Its purpose and character have been discussed above
on p. 16 sq., where a translation of it is given. The epistle is
preserved by Athanasius (
de Decret. Syn. Nic.
app.); by
Socrates,
H. E.
I. 8; by Theodoret,
H. E.
I. 11, and
others. It is printed by Migne,
Opera
, II.
1535–1544.
In the Acts of the Second
Council of Nicæa (
l.c.
) we find a mention of “all the
epistles” of Eusebius, as if many were at that time extant. We
know, however, only of those which have been mentioned
above.
IX.
Spurious
or Doubtful Works.
Fourteen Latin
opuscula
were discovered and published by Sirmond in 1643, and have been
frequently reprinted (Migne,
Opera
, VI. 1047–1208). They
are of a theological character, and bear the following
titles:—
De fide adv. Sabellium, libri
duo.
De Resurrectione, libri
duo.
De Incorporali et invisibili
Deo.
De Incorporali.
De Incorporali Anima.
De Spiritali Cogitatu
hominis.
De eo quod Deus Pater
incorporalis est, libri duo.
De eo quod ait Dominus, Non
veni pacem,
etc.
De Mandato Domini, Quod ait,
Quod dico vobis in aure,
etc.
De operibus bonis et
malis.
De operibus bonis, ex epist. II.
ad Corinth.
Their authenticity is a matter
of dispute. Some of them may be genuine, but Lardner is doubtless right
in denying the genuineness of the two Against Sabellius, which are the
most important of all (see Lardner’s
Credibility
, Part II.
chap. 72).
Lightfoot states that a
treatise,
On the Star which appeared to the Magi
, was published
by Wright in the
Journal of Sacred Literature
(1866) from a
Syriac
ms.
It is ascribed to Eusebius, but its
genuineness has been disputed, and good reasons have been given for
supposing that it was written originally in Syriac (see Lightfoot, p.
345).
Fabricius (
Bibl. Gr
. VI. 104) reports that the following
works are extant in
ms.
:
Fragmentum de
Mensuris ac Ponderibus
(
mss.
Is. Vossii,
n. 179);
De Morte Herodis
(
ms.
in Bibl.
Basil.);
Præfatio ad Canticum Mosis in Exodo
(Lambec. III.
p. 35).
4
In the
preparation of the following Catalogue of Eusebius’ writings
Stein, and especially Lightfoot, have been found most
helpful.
5
Since the
above section was written, another possibility has suggested itself to
me. As remarked below, on p. 45, it is possible that Eusebius issued a
second edition of his
History
in the year 324 or 325, with a
tenth book added, and that he inserted at that time two remarks not
contained in the first edition of the first nine books. It is possible,
therefore to suppose that the references to the
Vita Pamphili
,
as an already published book, found in
H. E.
VI. 32 and VII. 32,
may have been added at the same time. Turning to the latter passage we
find our author saying, “It would be no small matter to show what
sort of man he [Pamphilus] was, and whence he came. But we have
described in a separate work devoted to him all the particulars of his
life, and of the school which he established, and the trials which he
endured in many confessions during the persecution, and the crown of
martyrdom with which he was finally honored.
But
of all who were
there he was the most admirable” (ἀλλ᾽
οὗτος μὲν τῶν
τῇδε
θαυμασιώτατος). The ἀλλὰ,
but
, seems
very unnatural after the paragraph in regard to the work which Eusebius
had already written. In fact, to give the word its proper adversative
force after what precedes is quite impossible, and it is therefore
commonly rendered (as in the translation of the passage on p. 321,
below) simply “indeed.” If we suppose the passage in regard
to the Biography of Pamphilus to be a later insertion, the use of
the ἀλλὰ becomes quite
explicable. “It would be no small matter to show what sort of man
he was and whence he came.
But
(this much I can say here) he was
the most admirable of all who were there.” Certainly the
reference at this point to the
Vita Pamphili
thus has something
of the look of a later insertion. In VI. 32, the reference to that work
might be struck out without in the least impairing the continuity of
thought. Still further, in VIII. 13, where the
Vita
is
mentioned, although the majority of the
mss
.
followed by most of the modern editions have the past tense
ἀνεγρ€ψαμεν
“we have written,” three of the best
mss
. read ἀναγρ€ψομεν
“we shall write.” Might not this confusion
have arisen from the fact that Eusebius, in revising the
History
, instead of rewriting this whole passage simply
substituted in the copy which he had before him the word ἀνεγρ€ψαμεν
for the earlier ἀναγρ€ψομεν, and that some copyist, or copyists, finding the earlier
form still legible, preferred that to the substituted form, thinking
the latter to be an insertion by some unauthorized person? If we were
then to suppose that the
Vita Pamphili
was written after the
first edition of the
History
, but before the issue of the
complete work in its revised form, we should place its composition
later than the longer recension of the
Martyrs
, but earlier than
the shorter recension, and thus explain quite simply the lack of any
reference to the
Vita
in the former. Against the theory stated
in this note might be urged the serious objection that the reference to
the
Martyrs of Palestine
in VIII. 13 is allowed to remain in the
future tense even in the revised edition of the
History
, a fact
which of course argues against the change of ἀναγρ€ψομεν
to ἀνεγρ€ψαμεν
in the reference to the
Vita
in the same
chapter. Indeed, I do not which to be understood as maintaining this
theory, or as considering it more probable than the one stated in the
text. I suggest it simply as an alternative possibility.