Chapter V.
That “through whom” is said also in the case of the Father, and “of whom” in the case of the
Son and of the Spirit.
7. Afterthus describing the outcome of our adversaries’ arguments, we shall now proceed
to shew, as we have proposed, that the Father does not first take “of whom” and then abandon
“through whom” to the Son; and that there is no truth in these men’s ruling that the Son
refuses to admit the Holy Spirit to a share in “of whom” or in “through whom,” according
to the limitation of their new-fangled allotment of phrases. “There is one God and Father
of whom are all things, and one Lord Jesus Christ through whom are all things.”734
Yes; but these are the words of a writer not laying down a rule, but carefully distinguish-
ing the hypostases.735
The object of the apostle in thus writing was not to introduce the diversity of nature,
but to exhibit the notion of Father and of Son as unconfounded. That the phrases are not
opposed to one another and do not, like squadrons in war marshalled one against another,
bring the natures to which they are applied into mutual conflict, is perfectly plain from the
passage in question. The blessed Paul brings both phrases to bear upon one and the same
subject, in the words “of him and through him and to him are all things.”736 That this
plainly refers to the Lord will be admitted even by a reader paying but small attention to the
meaning of the words. The apostle has just quoted from the prophecy of Isaiah, “Who hath
6
known the mind of the Lord, or who hath been his counsellor,”737 and then goes on, “For
of him and from him and to him are all things.” That the prophet is speaking about God
the Word, the Maker of all creation, may be learnt from what immediately precedes: “Who
hath measured the waters in the hollow of his hand, and meted out heaven with the span,
and comprehended the dust of the earth in a measure, and weighed the mountains in scales,
and the hills in a balance? Who hath directed the Spirit of the Lord, or being his counsellor
hath taught him?”738 Now the word “who” in this passage does not mean absolute impossib-
734 1 Cor. viii. 6.
735 If Catholic Theology does not owe to St. Basil the distinction between the connotations of οὐσία and
ὑπόστασις which soon prevailed over the identification obtaining at the time of the Nicene Council, at all events
his is the first and most famous assertion and defence of it. At Nicæa, in 325, to have spoken of St. Paul as
“distinguishing the hypostases” would have been held impious. Some forty-five years later St. Basil writes to
his brother, Gregory of Nyssa (Ep. xxxviii.), in fear lest Gregory should fall into the error of failing to distinguish
between hypostasis and ousia, between person and essence. cf. Theodoret Dial. i. 7, and my note on his Ecc.
Hist. i. 3.
736 Rom. xi. 36.
737 Rom. xi. 34, and Is. xl. 13.
738 Is. xl. 12, 13.
That v: not found “of whom” in the case of the Son and of the Spirit.
149
That v: not found “of whom” in the case of the Son and of the Spirit.