faith, to be the same thing in an unconverted sinner, whom your words, ’being without faith,’
must mean, and therein we entirely agree. But I must think, as to the believer, his doubting
whether or not he has faith, is sinful, because it is belying the Holy Ghost, denying his work
in him, so there is no sin to which that doubting can so properly be reduced as unbelief.
You know, dear Sir, doubting and believing are opposed in Scripture, Matt. xiv. 31. Matt.
xxi. 21. Mark xi. 23. and I cannot exclude from the idea of doubting, a questioning the truth
and reality of a work of grace on one’s soul; for the Holy Ghost requires us to believe the
reality of his work in us, in all its parts, just as it is, and never would allow us, much less call
us to sin, or to believe a falsehood, that one is void of grace, when he has it, that good might
come of it, i.e. that the person might be awakened from security, &c. 1 John iii. 3. ‘Every
man that hath this hope in him purifieth himself, as he is pure;’ I think intimates, that in
proportion to the degree of one’s hope, that the Lord is his Father, will be his aim after
sanctification, and his attainment of it; if so, to renounce this hope, to throw it up at any
season, on any account, must be unlawful; whence I infer, for the believer to doubt of his
gracious state, to call it in question for any reason whatever, so as to raze it, it is simply sinful,
1 John ii. 12, 15. ‘I write unto you, little children, because your sins are forgiven you, viz.
Love not the world.’ Here forgiveness of sin is used as a motive or incitement not to love
the world; and this reasoning of the apostle would lose all its force, were it incumbent on a
believer, at some seasons, to think he was not within the bond of the new covenant,—he is
bound ever to hold that conclusion fixed. The exhortation, not to cast away one’s confidence,
certainly comprehends a call to persevere in believing in our interest in the Lord, and to
practise it at all seasons, Heb. x. 35. Job’s friends endeavoured to make him question,
whether the root of the matter was in him, and to conclude that he was a hypocrite. He re-
solved, though the Lord should slay him, he would trust in him, chap. xiii. 15 being confident
of his own good estate, chap. xxvii. 3, 5. ‘All the while my breath is in me;’ and ver. 5. ‘Till
xcvii
I die, I will not remove my integrity from me;’ and we see, from the whole tenor of his book,
what there he resolved, he actually did practise; he never entertained the thought of supposing
the Lord was not his God, notwithstanding the grievous eruptions of iniquity in him, in
quarrelling with the sovereignty of God, &c. And in the end, the Lord condemned his friends
for speaking of him ‘the things that were not right,’ and pronounced that Job, his servant,
had said of him the thing ‘that is right,’ Job iv. 1.; from which, it is to be presumed, he was
approved in guarding against razing his state 29 . Also, 2 Cor. i. 12. what the apostle terms
there, ‘his rejoicing,’ was what supposed his being confident of his good estate, that he was
participant of a principle of grace, which made him capable of acting, as he did, with godly
sincerity. All which, with other considerations, do satisfy me, that a believer never should
raze his state on any account whatever; and that, as has been mentioned, doubting of his
29 This, and several other Scotticisms, I do not feel at liberty to alter.
195
CHAPTER XV. Arrival of David Brainerd at Northampton. His sickness and…