14. Sinning therefore takes place only by exercise of will. But our will is very well known to us; for neither should I know that I will, if I did not know what will itself is. Accordingly, it is thus defined: will is a movement of mind, no one compelling, either for not losing or for obtaining something. Why therefore could not I have so defined it then? Was it difficult to see that one unwilling is contrary to one willing, just as the left hand is contrary to the right, not as black to white? For the same thing cannot be at the same time black and white. But whoever is placed between two men is on the left hand with reference to one, on the right with reference to the other. One man is both on the right hand and on the left hand at the same time, but by no means both to the one man. So indeed one mind may be at the same time unwilling and willing, but it cannot be at the same time unwilling and willing with reference to one and the same thing. For when any one unwillingly does anything; if you ask him whether he wished to do it, he says that he did not. Likewise if you ask whether he wished not to do it, he replies that he did. So you will find him unwilling with reference to doing, willing with reference to not doing, that is to say, one mind at the same time having both attitudes, but each referring to different things. Why do I say this? Because if we should again ask wherefore though unwilling he does this, he will say that he is compelled. For every one also who does a thing unwillingly is compelled, and every one who is compelled, if he does a thing, does it only unwillingly. It follows that he that is willing is free from compulsion, even if any one thinks himself compelled. And in this manner every one who willingly does a thing is not compelled, and whoever is not compelled, either does it willingly or not at all. Since nature itself proclaims these things in all men whom we can interrogate without absurdity, from the boy even to the old man, from literary sport even to the throne of the wise, why then should I not have seen that in the definition of will should be put, "no one compelling," which now as if with greater experience most cautiously I have done. But if this is everywhere manifest, and promptly occurs to all not by instruction but by nature, what is there left that seems obscure, unless perchance it be concealed from some one, that when we wish for something, we will, and our mind is moved towards it, and we either have it or do not have it, and if we have it we will to retain it, if we have it not, to acquire it? Wherefore everyone who wills, wills either not to lose something or to obtain it. Hence if all these things are clearer than day, as they are, nor are they given to my conception alone, but by the liberality of truth itself to the whole human race, why could I not have said even at that time: Will is a movement of the mind, no one compelling, either for not losing or for obtaining something?
{"actual_source_scan_identifier":null,"author":null,"canonical_references":[],"classification":"UNCLASSIFIED","dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"685de0da9b562cbd19fca96fc2bf60d326fbdc8f87915f56fc9848db641a0f4d"},"edition_attribution_from_manifest":null,"heading_or_title_candidate_kind":null,"id":"ancl:cd5484d7f5ed5bfc3818:p:4","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"named_translator_from_manifest":null,"needs_review":false,"original_node_id":"mwIw","original_note_callouts":[{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"b838084bdefb8c444ff30042cbfdfab1f3af0a2a36b82ff036943201618ef0e2"},"original_id":"cite_ref-2","targets":["#cite_note-2"]}],"original_transclusion_root":{"attributes":{"class":"mw-content-ltr mw-parser-output","data-mw-html-version":{"$text_sha256":"a29febbf19e6af8302bb875ed5491063a87555cc01c7e55c79902f8041eac42f"},"data-mw-parsoid-version":"0.24.0.0-alpha25","dir":"ltr","lang":"en"},"edition_from_manifest_is_unreviewed":true,"original_id":null,"source_char_end":66183,"source_char_start":40371},"original_work_date":null,"physical_printing_year":null,"preceding_original_heading":{"candidate_kind":"literal-heading-prefix-unclassified","chapter_number":null,"classification":"UNCLASSIFIED","dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"d3a46aafa54a87e6ac7484292cbb365862e47c71e05a6c4feb8285d8e8706d9b"},"element_tag":"p","heading_is_metadata_only":true,"id":"ancl:cd5484d7f5ed5bfc3818:heading:1","original_node_id":"mwBA","original_source_span":{"raw_span_exact":true,"source_char_end":47718,"source_char_start":47510,"source_html":{"$text_sha256":"bbcff5d0a387d36c26e784924e436485b2c23d10fed70a5b7a465ad156e847e0"},"source_html_sha256":"bbcff5d0a387d36c26e784924e436485b2c23d10fed70a5b7a465ad156e847e0","source_line_1_based":572,"source_utf8_byte_end":47728,"source_utf8_byte_start":47516},"public_import_allowed":false,"source_page_at_start":null,"source_sha256":"8dfc2a5aeedfed3a69f36c1d5dadb3aa87c6dc908cd9437e9d6ee0eb441b39d6","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_I/Volume_IV/Manichaean_Controversy/On_Two_Souls/Chapter_10","text":"Chapter 10.—Sin is Only from the Will. His Own Life and Will Best Known to Each Individual. What Will is."},"public_import_allowed":false,"raw_span_exact":true,"reading_policy":"Existing collect_structured_editions.reading: source whitespace collapsed, zero-width formatting removed, pagination/navigation/callouts omitted, source dropinitial alt used; exact HTML retained.","reading_text_is_derived":true,"record_kind":"original-transcribed-p-node-unclassified","reported_author_unreviewed":null,"reported_translator_unreviewed":null,"review_issues":[],"semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_char_end":56994,"source_char_start":52642,"source_document_format":"legacy-wikisource-content-not-scan-transclusion","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"685de0da9b562cbd19fca96fc2bf60d326fbdc8f87915f56fc9848db641a0f4d"},"source_html_sha256":"685de0da9b562cbd19fca96fc2bf60d326fbdc8f87915f56fc9848db641a0f4d","source_id":"cd5484d7f5ed5bfc3818","source_image_alt_used":[],"source_line_1_based":584,"source_page_anchors":[],"source_paragraph_index":4,"source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/cd5484d7f5ed5bfc3818.html","source_sha256":"8dfc2a5aeedfed3a69f36c1d5dadb3aa87c6dc908cd9437e9d6ee0eb441b39d6","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_I/Volume_IV/Manichaean_Controversy/On_Two_Souls/Chapter_10","source_utf8_byte_end":57049,"source_utf8_byte_start":52674,"text_sha256":"d07f0dafde4d01a43091f8c60e1b7b9bacf05bec550808d934bd893ed75f5439","volume":"Volume_IV","work_group_id":"NPNF-I-Volume_IV","work_id":null}
{"actual_source_scan_identifier":null,"author":null,"canonical_references":[],"classification":"UNCLASSIFIED","dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"fa950888113dfa71c8df1db5c2c87a721b69758ba730d4ba36639da4fada8ef9"},"edition_attribution_from_manifest":null,"heading_or_title_candidate_kind":null,"id":"ancl:cd5484d7f5ed5bfc3818:p:4","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"named_translator_from_manifest":null,"needs_review":false,"original_node_id":"mwIw","original_note_callouts":[{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"b838084bdefb8c444ff30042cbfdfab1f3af0a2a36b82ff036943201618ef0e2"},"original_id":"cite_ref-2","targets":["#cite_note-2"]}],"original_transclusion_root":{"attributes":{"class":"mw-content-ltr mw-parser-output","data-mw-html-version":{"$text_sha256":"a29febbf19e6af8302bb875ed5491063a87555cc01c7e55c79902f8041eac42f"},"data-mw-parsoid-version":"0.24.0.0-alpha25","dir":"ltr","lang":"en"},"edition_from_manifest_is_unreviewed":true,"original_id":null,"source_char_end":66183,"source_char_start":40371},"original_work_date":null,"physical_printing_year":null,"preceding_original_heading":{"candidate_kind":"literal-heading-prefix-unclassified","chapter_number":null,"classification":"UNCLASSIFIED","dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"d3a46aafa54a87e6ac7484292cbb365862e47c71e05a6c4feb8285d8e8706d9b"},"element_tag":"p","heading_is_metadata_only":true,"id":"ancl:cd5484d7f5ed5bfc3818:heading:1","original_node_id":"mwBA","original_source_span":{"raw_span_exact":true,"source_char_end":47718,"source_char_start":47510,"source_html":{"$text_sha256":"bbcff5d0a387d36c26e784924e436485b2c23d10fed70a5b7a465ad156e847e0"},"source_html_sha256":"bbcff5d0a387d36c26e784924e436485b2c23d10fed70a5b7a465ad156e847e0","source_line_1_based":572,"source_utf8_byte_end":47728,"source_utf8_byte_start":47516},"public_import_allowed":false,"source_page_at_start":null,"source_sha256":"8dfc2a5aeedfed3a69f36c1d5dadb3aa87c6dc908cd9437e9d6ee0eb441b39d6","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_I/Volume_IV/Manichaean_Controversy/On_Two_Souls/Chapter_10","text":"Chapter 10.—Sin is Only from the Will. His Own Life and Will Best Known to Each Individual. What Will is."},"public_import_allowed":false,"raw_span_exact":true,"reading_policy":"Existing collect_structured_editions.reading: source whitespace collapsed, zero-width formatting removed, pagination/navigation/callouts omitted, source dropinitial alt used; exact HTML retained.","reading_text_is_derived":true,"record_kind":"original-transcribed-p-node-unclassified","reported_author_unreviewed":null,"reported_translator_unreviewed":null,"review_issues":[],"semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_char_end":56994,"source_char_start":52642,"source_document_format":"legacy-wikisource-content-not-scan-transclusion","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"685de0da9b562cbd19fca96fc2bf60d326fbdc8f87915f56fc9848db641a0f4d"},"source_html_sha256":"685de0da9b562cbd19fca96fc2bf60d326fbdc8f87915f56fc9848db641a0f4d","source_id":"cd5484d7f5ed5bfc3818","source_image_alt_used":[],"source_line_1_based":584,"source_page_anchors":[],"source_paragraph_index":4,"source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-observed-graph-20261010/cd5484d7f5ed5bfc3818.html","source_sha256":"8dfc2a5aeedfed3a69f36c1d5dadb3aa87c6dc908cd9437e9d6ee0eb441b39d6","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_I/Volume_IV/Manichaean_Controversy/On_Two_Souls/Chapter_10","source_utf8_byte_end":57049,"source_utf8_byte_start":52674,"text_sha256":"d07f0dafde4d01a43091f8c60e1b7b9bacf05bec550808d934bd893ed75f5439","volume":"Volume_IV","work_group_id":"NPNF-I-Volume_IV","work_id":null}