Chapter 2.—Whether the Gods, Whom the Greeks and Romans Worshipped in Com-
mon, Were Justified in Permitting the Destruction of Ilium.
First, then, why was Troy or Ilium, the cradle of the Roman people (for I must not
overlook nor disguise what I touched upon in the first book121), conquered, taken and
destroyed by the Greeks, though it esteemed and worshipped the same gods as they? Priam,
some answer, paid the penalty of the perjury of his father Laomedon.122 Then it is true that
Laomedon hired Apollo and Neptune as his workmen. For the story goes that he promised
them wages, and then broke his bargain. I wonder that famous diviner Apollo toiled at so
huge a work, and never suspected Laomedon was going to cheat him of his pay. And Neptune
too, his uncle, brother of Jupiter, king of the sea, it really was not seemly that he should be
ignorant of what was to happen. For he is introduced by Homer123 (who lived and wrote
before the building of Rome) as predicting something great of the posterity of Æneas, who
44
in fact founded Rome. And as Homer says, Nep tune also rescued Æneas in a cloud from
the wrath of Achilles, though (according to Virgil124)
“All his will was to destroy
His own creation, perjured Troy.”
Gods, then, so great as Apollo and Neptune, in ignorance of the cheat that was to defraud
them of their wages, built the walls of Troy for nothing but thanks and thankless people.125
There may be some doubt whether it is not a worse crime to believe such persons to be gods,
than to cheat such gods. Even Homer himself did not give full credence to the story for
while he represents Neptune, indeed, as hostile to the Trojans, he introduces Apollo as their
champion, though the story implies that both were offended by that fraud. If, therefore,
they believe their fables, let them blush to worship such gods; if they discredit the fables, let
no more be said of the “Trojan perjury;” or let them explain how the gods hated Trojan, but
loved Roman perjury. For how did the conspiracy of Catiline, even in so large and corrupt
a city, find so abundant a supply of men whose hands and tongues found them a living by
perjury and civic broils? What else but perjury corrupted the judgments pronounced by so
many of the senators? What else corrupted the people’s votes and decisions of all causes
tried before them? For it seems that the ancient practice of taking oaths has been preserved
even in the midst of the greatest corruption, not for the sake of restraining wickedness by
religious fear, but to complete the tale of crimes by adding that of perjury.
121 Ch. 4.
122 Virg, Georg. i. 502, Laomedonteæ luimus perjuria Trojæ.
123 Iliad, xx. 293 et seqq.
124 Æneid. v. 810, 811.
125 Gratis et ingratis.
Whether the Gods, Whom the Greeks and Romans Worshipped in Common, Were Justified in Permitting the Destruction of Ilium.
115
Whether the Gods, Whom the Greeks and Romans Worshipped in Common, Were…