explains the orthodox doctrine; for because the Father is not of the Son, but the Son of the
Father, therefore He says, “I am in the Father,” showing the fact that He is not of another
but of Him, and then reverses the phrase to, “and the Father in Me,” indicating that he who,
in his curious speculation, passes beyond the Son, passes also beyond the conception of the
Father: for He who is in anything cannot be found outside of that in which He is: so that
the man who, while not denying that the Father is in the Son, yet imagines that he has in
any degree apprehended the Father as external to the Son, is talking idly. Idle too are the
wanderings of our adversaries’ fighting about shadows touching the matter of “ungeneracy,”
proceeding without solid foundation by means of nonentities. Yet if I am to bring more
fully to light the whole absurdity of their argument, let me be allowed to spend a little longer
on this speculation. As they say that the Only-begotten God came into existence “later,”
after the Father, this “unbegotten” of theirs, whatever they imagine it to be, is discovered of
necessity to exhibit with itself the idea of evil. Who knows not, that, just as the non-existent
is contrasted with the existent, so with every good thing or name is contrasted the opposite
conception, as “bad” with “good,” “falsehood” with “truth,” “darkness” with “light,” and all
the rest that are similarly opposed to one another, where the opposition admits of no middle
term, and it is impossible that the two should co-exist, but the presence of the one destroys
its opposite, and with the withdrawal of the other takes place the appearance of its contrary?
Now these points being conceded to us, the further point is also clear to any one, that,
as Moses says darkness was before the creation of light, so also in the case of the Son (if,
according to the heretical statement, the Father “made Him at that time when He willed”),
before He made Him, that Light which the Son is was not; and, light not yet being, it is im-
possible that its opposite should not be. For we learn also from the other instances that
nothing that comes from the Creator is at random, but that which was lacking is added by
creation to existing things. Thus it is quite clear that if God did make the Son, He made Him
by reason of a deficiency in the nature of things. As, then, while sensible light was still
lacking, there was darkness, and darkness would certainly have prevailed had light not come
into being, so also, when the Son “as yet was not,” the very and true Light, and all else that
the Son is, did not exist. For even according to the evidence of heresy, that which exists has
no need of coming into being; if therefore He made Him, He assuredly made that which
did not exist. Thus, according to their view, before the Son came into being, neither had
truth come into being, nor the intelligible Light, nor the fount of life, nor, generally, the
nature of any thing that is excellent and good. Now, concurrently with the exclusion of each
of these, there is found to subsist the opposite conception: and if light was not, it cannot be
denied that darkness was; and so with the rest,—in place of each of these more excellent
conceptions it is clearly impossible that its opposite did not exist in place of that which was
lacking. It is therefore a necessary conclusion, that when the Father, as the heretics say, “had
not as yet willed to make the Son,” none of those things which the Son is being yet existent,
418
Then, having shown that Eunomius' calumny against the great Basil, that…