338
would be no need of a witness at all. Moreover, in the promise of the Holy Spirit as the
Paraclete, it is said, "He shall lead you into all truth;"1060 but how can you be led into all
truth by one who teaches you that Christ was a deceiver? And again, if you were to prove
that all that is said in the Gospel of the promise of the Paraclete could apply to no one but
Manichæus, as the predictions of the prophets are applicable to Christ; and if you quoted
passages from those manuscripts which you say are genuine, we might say that on this very
point, as proving Manichæus to be the only person intended, the passages have been altered
in the interest of your sect. Your only answer to this would be, that you could not possibly
alter documents already in the possession of all Christians; for at the very outset of such an
attempt, it would be met by an appeal to older copies. But if this proves that the books could
not be corrupted by you, it also proves that they could not be corrupted by any one. The
first person who ventured to do such a thing would be convicted by a comparison of older
manuscripts; especially as the Scripture is to be found not in one language only, but in many.
As it is, false readings are sometimes corrected by comparing older copies or the original
language. Hence you must either acknowledge these documents as genuine, and then your
heresy cannot stand a moment; or if they are spurious, you cannot use their authority in
support of your doctrine of the Paraclete, and so you refute yourselves.
17. Further, what is said in the promise of the Paraclete shows that it cannot possibly
refer to Manichæus, who came so many years after. For it is distinctly said by John, that
the Holy Spirit was to come immediately after the resurrection and ascension of the Lord:
"For the Spirit was not yet given, because that Jesus was not yet glorified."1061 Now, if the
reason why the Spirit was not given was, that Jesus was not glorified, He would necessarily
be given immediately on the glorification of Jesus. In the same way, the Cataphrygians1062
said that they had received the promised Paraclete; and so they fell away from the Catholic
faith, forbidding what Paul allowed, and condemning second marriages, which he made
lawful. They turned to their own use the words spoken of the Spirit, "He shall lead you into
all truth," as if, forsooth, Paul and the other apostles had not taught all the truth, but had
left room for the Paraclete of the Cataphrygians. The same meaning they forced from the
words of Paul: "We know in part, and we prophesy in part; but when that which is perfect
is come, then that which is in part shall be done away;"1063 making out that the apostle knew
and prophesied in part, when he said, "Let him do what he will; if he marries, he sinneth
1060 John xvi. 13.
1061 John vii. 39.
1062 [Another name for the Montanists, who arose in Phrygia shortly after the middle of the second cen-
tury.—A.H.N.]
1063 1 Cor. xiii. 9, 10.
577
Faustus fails to understand why he should be required either to accept or…