The word ἀγγέν[ν]ητον was in the philosophical schools synonymous with ‘God;’ hence by asking whether there were two Unoriginates, the Arians implied that there were two Gods, if Christ was God in the sense in which the Father was. Hence Athan. retorts, φάσκοντες, οὐ λέγομεν δύο ἀγένητα, λέγουσι δύο θεούς. Orat. iii. 16, also ii. 38. Plato used ἀγέννητον of the Supreme God [not so; he used ἀγένητον, see note 2 on de Decr. 28]; the Valentinians, Tertull. contr. Val. 7; and Basilides, Epiph. Hær. 31. 10. S. Clement uses it, see de Syn. 47, note 7. [The earlier Arians apparently argued mainly, like Asterius, from ἀγένητος (cf. Epiph. 64. 8), the later (καινοί, Epiph. Hær. 73. 19) Anomœans rather from ἀγέννητος]; viz. that ἡ ἀγεννησία is the very οὐσία of God, not an attribute. So Aetius in Epiph. Hær. 76. S. Athanasius does not go into this question, but rather confines himself to the more popular form of it, viz. the Son is by His very name not ἀγένητος, but γενητὸς, but all γενητὰ are creatures; which he answers, as de Decr. §28, by saying that Christianity had brought in a new idea into theology, viz. the sacred doctrine of a true Son, ἐκ τῆς οὐσίας. This was what the Arians had originally denied ἓν τὸ ἀγέννητον ἓν δὲ τὸ ὑπ᾽ αὐτοῦ ἀληθῶς, καὶ οὐκ ἐκ τῆς οὐσίας αὐτοῦ γεγονός. Euseb. Nic. ap. Theod. H. E. i. 6. When they were urged what according to them was the middle idea to which the Son answered, if they would not accept the Catholic, they would not define but merely said, γέννημα, ἀλλ᾽ οὐκ ὡς ἓν τῶν γεννημάτων. [See pp. 149, 169, and the reference there to Lightfoot.]
{"author":"Historical editor/translator (individual note author unspecified)","date_end":1892,"date_label":"1892 (historical English edition; transcription printing date uncertain)","date_start":1892,"edition_year":1892,"edition_year_basis":"Original NPNF Series II Volume IV title and copyright1892; exact physical printing underlying Wikisource transcription not established","id":"ws-library-full-note:97a283520933e5bba3e5:cite_note-1","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Wikisource:Reusing_Wikisource_content","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"editorial-footnote","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Discourse 1, Chapter 9, Section 30, editorial note cite_note-1","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_context":[{"$text_sha256":"b1465f5379cbc1733245bb1bb98bfb21daf8d5f8eb78173623f2034601e006b4"}],"source_library_url":"/library/97a283520933e5bba3e5/#ws-library-full-note:97a283520933e5bba3e5:cite_note-1","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_IV/Against_the_Arians/Against_the_Arians/Discourse_I/Chapter_9#cite_note-1","translator":"John Henry Newman (translation and notes); Archibald Robertson (revision)","verification":{"note":{"backlink_hrefs":["#cite_ref-1"],"body_html":{"$text_sha256":"c21a60e1345ede71cd3be2294d1db42084428cf9db1521f4a71c2185c22087cd"},"body_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[1]/span[2]","container_html":{"$text_sha256":"df14b5f8143d69668c6c0bccfaddf5acec0a0da3554acedacbe99a811a7dbbd9"},"container_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[1]","id":"cite_note-1"},"original_work_coordinate":{"actual_note_parent_coordinates":[{"chapter":9,"native_section_number":30,"original_parent_paragraph":{"dom_serialized_html":{"$text_sha256":"75f5e8fe07cdc4ce34d86dbb36f892c2a1aac98fdf9f9d5ba071bc7cb92898a6"},"dom_serialized_sha256":"75f5e8fe07cdc4ce34d86dbb36f892c2a1aac98fdf9f9d5ba071bc7cb92898a6","original_node_id":"mwFQ","source_id":"97a283520933e5bba3e5","source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage6/97a283520933e5bba3e5.html","source_sha256":"356ab3539edb83b4b0f85a9d85069242db3c46e21ce0d1e886525e9deef738d3","text":{"$text_sha256":"b1465f5379cbc1733245bb1bb98bfb21daf8d5f8eb78173623f2034601e006b4"},"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[2]"},"source_paragraph_index":2}],"actual_original_chapter_number":9,"actual_original_discourse_number":1,"actual_original_letter_number":null,"chapter":9,"discourse":1,"letter":null,"native_section_number":30,"numbering_basis":"Literal original p headings and actual observed reading-body catalogue ancestry; URL ordinals never treated as native chapter/letter numbers","original_chapter_heading":{"$text_sha256":"a741a8db2a722c929294027cb07de62064409b5105b4520ac837e0df066ae03a"},"original_heading_evidence":[{"discourse":1,"heading_source_id":"347c934f7cfb86dd3883","heading_source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29"},"html_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29"},"source_html_sha256":"c90edb27f00ca9b2bf47a48b8fa058c1d0e8a3caa71fc7b60e43d897b86eac29","source_utf8_byte_end":49156,"source_utf8_byte_start":49127,"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[2]"},"heading_source_record_id":"ancl:347c934f7cfb86dd3883:p:2","original_discourse_heading":"Discourse I."},{"chapter":9,"heading_source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"d0adc804b420002d3a410b78d36b1c1f8c64853d1e77ff44bc716c24213c3436"},"html_sha256":"d0adc804b420002d3a410b78d36b1c1f8c64853d1e77ff44bc716c24213c3436","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"bb8d636e52162ab571513dae48085aa964b150268019f743ed24878a29727b6f"},"source_html_sha256":"bb8d636e52162ab571513dae48085aa964b150268019f743ed24878a29727b6f","source_utf8_byte_end":50765,"source_utf8_byte_start":49104,"xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[1]"},"heading_source_record_id":"ancl:97a283520933e5bba3e5:p:1","original_chapter_heading":{"$text_sha256":"a741a8db2a722c929294027cb07de62064409b5105b4520ac837e0df066ae03a"}}],"original_letter_heading":null,"original_reading_body_catalogue_memberships":[{"actual_anchor_html":{"$text_sha256":"77633e5fb48a9532554c21358bb7e4af3012bfd21b631184984f916c177c1646"},"actual_anchor_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[9]/a","actual_label":"Chapter 9","modern_navigation_excluded":true,"parent_source_id":"5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf","parent_source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage5/5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf.html","parent_source_sha256":"50bd01a585621098d58ccc2ebca3ba3456b47025829f2812c64a87a4c8850f65"},{"actual_anchor_html":{"$text_sha256":"77633e5fb48a9532554c21358bb7e4af3012bfd21b631184984f916c177c1646"},"actual_anchor_xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ul/li[9]/a","actual_label":"Chapter 9","actual_original_UL_reading_body_catalogue":true,"modern_navigation_excluded":true,"parent_source_id":"5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf","parent_source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage5/5c52ddb7ca5b4896abbf.html","parent_source_sha256":"50bd01a585621098d58ccc2ebca3ba3456b47025829f2812c64a87a4c8850f65"}],"original_section_range_heading":null,"owner_verified_section_label":"Discourse 1, Chapter 9, Section 30","private_original_node_id":"mw-reference-text-cite_note-1","source_paragraph_index":null,"unestablished_native_number_not_invented":false},"reference_proofs":[],"source_id":"97a283520933e5bba3e5","source_library_context_witnesses":[{"html":{"$text_sha256":"75f5e8fe07cdc4ce34d86dbb36f892c2a1aac98fdf9f9d5ba071bc7cb92898a6"},"html_sha256":"75f5e8fe07cdc4ce34d86dbb36f892c2a1aac98fdf9f9d5ba071bc7cb92898a6","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[1]/p[2]"}],"source_node":{"html":{"$text_sha256":"c21a60e1345ede71cd3be2294d1db42084428cf9db1521f4a71c2185c22087cd"},"html_sha256":"c21a60e1345ede71cd3be2294d1db42084428cf9db1521f4a71c2185c22087cd","xpath":"/html/body/div[3]/div/div[3]/main/div[3]/div[2]/div[1]/section[2]/ol/li[1]/span[2]"},"source_path":"raw/research/wikisource/patristic-series-stage6/97a283520933e5bba3e5.html","source_record_file":"raw/review/athanasius-psalms-library-note-batch-0090/original-source-records.jsonl","source_record_file_sha256":"4b06e30487b04ff6f328981a08c3956d99fc7f5284b0ab0c262ac0d82cfe56e0","source_record_id":"ws-library-full-note:97a283520933e5bba3e5:cite_note-1","source_sha256":"356ab3539edb83b4b0f85a9d85069242db3c46e21ce0d1e886525e9deef738d3","text_sha256":"550a7744edd648c24d39842662036bed3fd638c6efc0de750f28c02a4c939500","type":"whole-source-library-dom"},"verified":true,"work":"Discourses Against the Arians (I–III)","work_id":"ws-npnf2-4-athanasius-arians-i-iii"}
{"author":"Historical editor/translator (individual note author unspecified)","date_end":1892,"date_label":"1892 (historical English edition; transcription printing date uncertain)","date_start":1892,"edition_year":1892,"edition_year_basis":"Original NPNF Series II Volume IV title and copyright1892; exact physical printing underlying Wikisource transcription not established","id":"ws-library-full-note:97a283520933e5bba3e5:cite_note-1","is_genuine_commentary_verified":false,"license_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Wikisource:Reusing_Wikisource_content","public_import_allowed":true,"publication_location":"source-library","record_type":"editorial-footnote","references":[],"rights_approved":true,"section":"Discourse 1, Chapter 9, Section 30, editorial note cite_note-1","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_context":["30. These considerations encourage the faithful, and distress the heretical, perceiving, as they do, their heresy overthrown thereby. Moreover, their further question, ‘whether the Unoriginate be one or two,’ shews how false are their views, how treacherous and full of guile. Not for the Father’s honour ask they this, but for the dishonour of the Word. Accordingly, should any one, not aware of their craft, answer, ‘the Unoriginated is one,’ forthwith they spirit out their own venom, saying, ‘Therefore the Son is among things originated,’ and well have we said, ‘He was not before His generation.’ Thus they make any kind of disturbance and confusion, provided they can but separate the Son from the Father, and reckon the Framer of all among His works. Now first they may be convicted on this score, that, while blaming the Nicene Bishops for their use of phrases not in Scripture, though these not injurious, but subversive of their irreligion, they themselves went off upon the same fault, that is, using words not in Scripture, and those in contumely of the Lord, knowing ‘neither what they say nor whereof they affirm.’ For instance, let them ask the Greeks, who have been their instructors (for it is a word of their invention, not Scripture), and when they have been instructed in its various significations, then they will discover that they cannot even question properly, on the subject which they have undertaken. For they have led me to ascertain that by ‘unoriginate’ is meant what has not yet come to be, but is possible to be, as wood which is not yet become, but is capable of becoming, a vessel; and again what neither has nor ever can come to be, as a triangle quadrangular, and an even number odd. For a triangle neither has nor ever can become quadrangular; nor has even ever, nor can ever, become odd. Moreover, by ‘unoriginate’ is meant, what exists, but has not come into being from any, nor having a father at all. Further, Asterius, the unprincipled sophist, the patron too of this heresy, has added in his own treatise, that what is not made, but is ever, is ‘unoriginate.’ They ought then, when they ask the question, to add in what sense they take the word ‘unoriginate,’ and then the parties questioned would be able to answer to the point."],"source_library_url":"/library/97a283520933e5bba3e5/#ws-library-full-note:97a283520933e5bba3e5:cite_note-1","source_url":"https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Nicene_and_Post-Nicene_Fathers:_Series_II/Volume_IV/Against_the_Arians/Against_the_Arians/Discourse_I/Chapter_9#cite_note-1","translator":"John Henry Newman (translation and notes); Archibald Robertson (revision)","verification":{"proof_file":"raw/review/athanasius-psalms-library-note-batch-0090/proof-records.jsonl","proof_file_sha256":"134f60e56c87c2ec4333e23b6a2d2bf46ade76d1e36ebaa8435bdf01633d4a58","proof_record_id":"ws-library-full-note:97a283520933e5bba3e5:cite_note-1"},"verified":true,"work":"Discourses Against the Arians (I–III)","work_id":"ws-npnf2-4-athanasius-arians-i-iii"}