93
§39. Answer to the question he is always asking, “Can He who is be begotten?”
Eunomius does not like the meaning of the Ungenerate to be conveyed by the term
Father, because he wants to establish that there was a time when the Son was not. It is in
fact a constant question amongst his pupils, “How can He who (always) is be begotten?”
This comes, I take it, of not weaning oneself from the human application of words, when
we have to think about God. But let us without bitterness at once expose the actual falseness
of this ‘arrière pensée’ of his209, stating first our conclusions upon the matter.
These names have a different meaning with us, Eunomius; when we come to the tran-
scendent energies they yield another sense. Wide, indeed, is the interval in all else that divides
the human from the divine; experience cannot point here below to anything at all resembling
in amount what we may guess at and imagine there. So likewise, as regards the meaning of
our terms, though there may be, so far as words go, some likeness between man and the
Eternal, yet the gulf between these two worlds is the real measure of the separation of
meanings. For instance, our Lord calls God a ‘man’ that was a ‘householder’ in the parable210;
but though this title is ever so familiar to us, will the person we think of and the person there
meant be of the same description; and will our ‘house’ be the same as that large house, in
which, as the Apostle says, there are the vessels of gold, and those of silver211, and those of
the other materials which are recounted? Or will not those rather be beyond our immediate
apprehension and to be contemplated in a blessed immortality, while ours are earthern, and
to dissolve to earth? So in almost all the other terms there is a similarity of names between
things human and things divine, revealing nevertheless underneath this sameness a wide
difference of meanings. We find alike in both worlds the mention of bodily limbs and senses;
as with us, so with the life of God, which all allow to be above sense, there are set down in
order fingers and arm and hand, eye and eyelids, hearing, heart, feet and sandals, horses,
cavalry, and chariots; and other metaphors innumerable are taken from human life to illus-
trate symbolically divine things. As, then, each one of these names has a human sound, but
not a human meaning, so also that of Father, while applying equally to life divine and human,
hides a distinction between the uttered meanings exactly proportionate to the difference
existing between the subjects of this title. We think of man’s generation one way; we surmise
of the divine generation in another. A man is born in a stated time; and a particular place
must be the receptacle of his life; without it it is not in nature that he should have any concrete
substance: whence also it is inevitable that sections of time are found enveloping his life;
there is a Before, and With, and After him. It is true to say of any one whatever of those
born into this world that there was a time when he was not, that he is now, and again there
209 αὐτὸ τὸ πεπλασμενον τῆς ὑπονοιας.
210 the parable, i.e. of the Tares. Matthew xiii. 27: cf. v. 52.
211 2 Tim. ii. 20.
Answer to the question he is always asking, “Can He who is be begotten?”
177
Answer to the question he is always asking, “Can He who is be begotten?