again restored and created; since it seems a possible thing that rational natures, from whom
the faculty of free-will is never taken away, may be again subjected to movements of some
kind, through the special act of the Lord Himself, lest perhaps, if they were always to occupy
a condition that was unchangeable, they should be ignorant that it is by the grace of God
and not by their own merit that they have been placed in that final state of happiness; and
these movements will undoubtedly again be attended by variety and diversity of bodies, by
which the world is always adorned; nor will it ever be composed (of anything) save of variety
and diversity,—an effect which cannot be produced without a bodily matter.
4. And now I do not understand by what proofs they can maintain their position, who
assert that worlds sometimes come into existence which are not dissimilar to each other,
but in all respects equal. For if there is said to be a world similar in all respects (to the
present), then it will come to pass that Adam and Eve will do the same things which they
did before: there will be a second time the same deluge, and the same Moses will again lead
a nation numbering nearly six hundred thousand out of Egypt; Judas will also a second time
betray the Lord; Paul will a second time keep the garments of those who stoned Stephen;
and everything which has been done in this life will be said to be repeated,—a state of things
which I think cannot be established by any reasoning, if souls are actuated by freedom of
will, and maintain either their advance or retrogression according to the power of their will.
273
For souls are not driven on in a cycle which returns after many ages to the same round, so
as either to do or desire this or that; but at whatever point the freedom of their own will
aims, thither do they direct the course of their actions. For what these persons say is much
the same as if one were to assert that if a medimnus of grain were to be poured out on the
ground, the fall of the grain would be on the second occasion identically the same as on the
first, so that every individual grain would lie for the second time close beside that grain
where it had been thrown before, and so the medimnus would be scattered in the same order,
and with the same marks as formerly; which certainly is an impossible result with the
countless grains of a medimnus, even if they were to be poured out without ceasing for
many ages. So therefore it seems to me impossible for a world to be restored for the second
time, with the same order and with the same amount of births, and deaths, and actions; but
that a diversity of worlds may exist with changes of no unimportant kind, so that the state
of another world may be for some unmistakeable reasons better (than this), and for others
worse, and for others again intermediate. But what may be the number or measure of this
I confess myself ignorant, although, if any one can tell it, I would gladly learn.
5. But this world, which is itself called an age, is said to be the conclusion of many ages.
Now the holy apostle teaches that in that age which preceded this, Christ did not suffer, nor
even in the age which preceded that again; and I know not that I am able to enumerate the
number of anterior ages in which He did not suffer. I will show, however, from what
statements of Paul I have arrived at this understanding. He says, “But now once in the
624
On the Beginning of the World, and Its Causes.