§5. The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.
About the year 318, while Alexander was bishop of Alexandria, the Arian controversy
broke out in that city, and the whole Eastern Church was soon involved in the strife. We
cannot enter here into a discussion of Arius’ views; but in order to understand the rapidity
with which the Arian party grew, and the strong hold which it possessed from the very start
in Syria and Asia Minor, we must remember that Arius was not himself the author of that
system which we know as Arianism, but that he learned the essentials of it from his instructor
Lucian. The latter was one of the most learned men of his age in the Oriental Church, and
founded an exegetico-theological school in Antioch, which for a number of years stood
outside of the communion of the orthodox Church in that city, but shortly before the mar-
tyrdom of Lucian himself (which took place in 311 or 312) made its peace with the Church,
and was recognized by it. He was held in the highest reverence by his disciples, and exerted
a great influence over them even after his death. Among them were such men as Arius, Eu-
sebius of Nicomedia, Asterius, and others who were afterward known as staunch Arianists.
According to Harnack the chief points in the system of Lucian and his disciples were the
creation of the Son, the denial of his co-eternity with the Father, and his immutability ac-
12
quired by persistent progress and steadfastness. His doctrine, which differed from that of
Paul of Samosata chiefly in the fact that it was not a man but a created heavenly being who
became “Lord,” was evidently the result of a combination of the teaching of Paul and of
Origen. It will be seen that we have here, at least in germ, all the essential elements of
Arianism proper: the creation of the Son out of nothing, and consequently the conclusion
that there was a time when he was not; the distinction of his essence from that of the Father,
but at the same time the emphasis upon the fact that he “was not created as the other
creatures,” and is therefore to be sharply distinguished from them. There was little for Arius
to do but to combine the elements given by Lucian in a more complete and well-ordered
system, and then to bring that system forward clearly and publicly, and endeavor to make
it the faith of the Church at large. His christology was essentially opposed to the Alexandrian,
and it was natural that he should soon come into conflict with that church, of which he was
a presbyter (upon Lucian’s teaching and its relation to Arianism, see Harnack’s Dog-
mengeschichte, II. p. 183 sq.).
Socrates (H. E. I. 5 sq.), Sozomen (H. E. I. 15) and Theodoret (H. E. I. 2 sq.), all of whom
give accounts of the rise of Arianism, differ as to the immediate occasion of the controversy,
but agree that Arius was excommunicated by a council convened at Alexandria, and that
both he and the bishop Alexander sent letters to other churches, the latter defending his
own course, the former complaining of his harsh treatment, and endeavoring to secure ad-
herents to his doctrine. Eusebius of Nicomedia at once became his firm supporter, and was
one of the leading figures on the Arian side throughout the entire controversy. His influential
position as bishop of Nicomedia, the imperial residence, and later of Constantinople, was
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.
20
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.